A case for mutual recognition
This presentation is the property of its rightful owner.
Sponsored Links
1 / 16

A case for mutual recognition Silvan Agius , Policy Director, ILGA-Europe LGBT Intergroup meeting PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 52 Views
  • Uploaded on
  • Presentation posted in: General

A case for mutual recognition Silvan Agius , Policy Director, ILGA-Europe LGBT Intergroup meeting 21 st October 2010, European Parliament (Strasbourg). Viviane Reding

Download Presentation

A case for mutual recognition Silvan Agius , Policy Director, ILGA-Europe LGBT Intergroup meeting

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript


A case for mutual recognition silvan agius policy director ilga europe lgbt intergroup meeting

A case for mutual recognition

Silvan Agius, Policy Director, ILGA-EuropeLGBT Intergroup meeting

21st October 2010, European Parliament (Strasbourg)


A case for mutual recognition silvan agius policy director ilga europe lgbt intergroup meeting

Viviane Reding

Discrimination of same-sex married or in civil-partnership couples (debate)7 September 2010, European Parliament [Strasbourg]

“Let me stress this. If you live in a legally-recognised same-sex partnership, or marriage, in country A, you have the right – and this is a fundamental right – to take this status and that of your partner to country B. If not, it is a violation of EU law, so there is no discussion about this. This is absolutely clear, and we do not have to hesitate on this.”


1 eu legal framework

1EU Legal Framework


Freedom of movement

Freedom of movement

  • Directive 2004/38/EC regulates the right of citizens of the EU and their family members to move and reside freely within its territory. It does not differentiate between different-sex and same-sex couples. In practice, however, ...

 MSs respect the right to freedom of movement

 MSs recognise the civil status of different-sex couples

 Social security is guaranteed under Reg. 1408/71

Many MSs do not respect the right to freedom of movement

Host MSs feel free to base their recognition of the civil

status of same-sex couples on its form of legal recognition

or otherwise

 Host MSs only provide social security when they recognise

same-sex couples as equal to different-sex couples


2 national legal recognition

2National Legal Recognition


Legal recognition in 2004

The legal situation as was

when Freedom of Movement

Directive was adopted.

Marriage equality 2

Registered partnership 8

No recognition 19

Legal recognition in 2004


Legal recognition in 2010

The legal situation today.

Marriage equality 7

Registered partnership 12

No recognition 12

Legal recognition in 2010


Likely further developments

The legal situation if current

national debates progress

ahead as expected.

Marriage equality 11

Registered partnership 10

No recognition 10

Likely further developments


3 snapshot of current situation

3Snapshot of Current Situation


A case for mutual recognition silvan agius policy director ilga europe lgbt intergroup meeting

  • CY, EE, EL, IE, IT, LI, LV, LT, MT, PL, SI, SK(and maybe others): Still in conflict with the entry and residence criteria when applied to same-sex partners.

  • Romania: Art 277 of the Civil Code (2009) prohibits domestic same-sex couple recognition, and prohibits recognition of marriages/partnership registered elsewhere.

  • Poland: Refused on various occasions to provide copies of civil status documents to Polish nationals who were going to enter a partnership in another MS.

What problems are there? [1]


A case for mutual recognition silvan agius policy director ilga europe lgbt intergroup meeting

  • Rights of the child: Children born to same-sex partners often loose the link to one of their parents when moving from one EU MS to another.

  • Pensions and Social Security: Regulation 1408/71 is still silent about same-sex partners and their children. Social security remains therefore only regulated by the host MS.

What problems are there? [2]


A case for mutual recognition silvan agius policy director ilga europe lgbt intergroup meeting

  • France: Following various problems in recognition of same-sex partners’ civil status*, in 2009 France changed its domestic legislation to recognise other EU registered partnerships to the level of its PACs.

  • Luxembourg: Followed suit in 2010.

  • United Kingdom: UK entered into bilateral discussions with other MSs that had registered partnerships to ensure recognition of its nationals’ civil partnerships.

  • * Mostly UK civil partners. Problems included 60% inheritance tax amongst others.

What solutions are there?


A case for mutual recognition silvan agius policy director ilga europe lgbt intergroup meeting

  • A number of MSs still disregard the obligations posed by Dir 2004/38/EC.

  • Domestic legislators have drawn different forms of recognition with different entitlements. MS often argue that non-domestic partnerships and ‘not equivalent’.

  • Growth in legal recognition since 2004 has not been followed by mutual recognition of civil status.

Why should EU play a role?


4 proposals for mutual recognition

4Proposals for Mutual Recognition


A case for mutual recognition silvan agius policy director ilga europe lgbt intergroup meeting

  • Monitor and enforce Dir 2004/38/EC’s provisions.

  • Launch study on obstacles on recognition of civil status.

  • Provide for legal certainty of civil status through the adoption of a European Authentication Act.

  • Take same-sex partners into account in the implementation of the mutual recognition provisions in the Stockholm Programme.

  • Take same-sex partners into account when applying the newly adopted strategy to ensure respect for EU Charter of Fundamental Rights.

What should the EU do?


Thank you www ilga europe org

… ‘ifs’ and ‘buts’ at border control?

Thank you!www.ilga-europe.org


  • Login