1 / 21

High maths-anxiety in student nurses Identifying maths-anxiety and tackling the causes.

High maths-anxiety in student nurses Identifying maths-anxiety and tackling the causes. Heather Bull Lecturer (Biology and Maths) School of Nursing University of Nottingham. E-mail contact: heather.bull@nottingham.ac.uk. Maths anxiety.

jaimeh
Download Presentation

High maths-anxiety in student nurses Identifying maths-anxiety and tackling the causes.

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. High maths-anxiety in student nurses Identifying maths-anxiety and tackling the causes. Heather Bull Lecturer (Biology and Maths) School of Nursing University of Nottingham E-mail contact: heather.bull@nottingham.ac.uk

  2. Maths anxiety • ‘…feelings of tension and anxiety that interfere with the manipulation of numbers and the solving of mathematical problems in a wide variety of ordinary life and academic situations.’ (Richardson and Suinn, 1972). i.e. maths-anxiety as a cause of error despite the level of maths ability.

  3. What happens in maths anxiety?- some explanations in the literature • Maths anxiety overloads the working memory with interfering thoughts which affect performance. • This is especially apparent in sequential procedures such as carryover or counting-like operations. (Ashcraft, 2001) • EEG investigations showed differences in the: • frontal area of the brain in response to carry operations • parietal area during general calculation activity (Sheffield, D, 2006)

  4. Poor maths performance What the literature says: Maths (test) anxiety Maths self-efficacy Alexander L, Martray C (1989) Ashcraft MH, Kirk EP (2001) Hodge J.E. (2002)

  5. Maths Anxiety Rating Scales (MARS):developed for research and therapy. 98-item. Richardson and Suinn (1972). ‘adding two three-digit numbers while someone looks over your shoulder. ‘ an upcoming math test 1 hour before.’* 25-item* Alexandra and Martray (1989) 9-item*. Hopko et al (2003) Many more…

  6. How does this transfer into everyday nursing? • Diagnostic tool (2nd person)? • However...key terms in nurse training / practice are: • reflective practice • accountability • professional responsibility • SWOT analysis • action plans • awareness (self and professional) • self-managed learning

  7. In training (3 years) Post-registration practice Tutor monitors with MARS. (2nd person) Reflect on maths-related anxiety as part of daily practice. (1st person)* Department updates: include MARS (2nd person) Maths anxiety evaluation in nursing - some possibilities * ‘How anxious do I feel about performing this maths task?’

  8. Would a ‘single-item’, reflective evaluation of maths anxiety: • be a useful evaluation to increase awareness? • show similar association patterns to MARS? • glean information underlying maths anxiety? • help focus remedial action? • be worth including in diagnostic numeracy testing? • have value in promoting ‘safe practice’ ?

  9. Stage 1 (at 4 weeks). Questionnaire 1: Anxiety Belief in maths skills Reliance on calculator Command of tables Level 2 maths (Y/N) Open comments Test 1. 20-item Stage 2 (at 10 weeks). Questionnaire 2: Anxiety Belief in maths skills Test 1. 20-item 6 week gap A Preliminary Study:

  10. Key questionnaire items: • Maths (test) anxiety rating (1-5): • ‘How anxious would you feel about needing to achieve 14/20 in a maths test today?’ • Maths self-efficacy (belief in having maths skills) rating (1-5): • ‘How do you rate your basic maths skills?’ • Embedded numeracy skills: • (a) Calculator-reliance rating (1-5): ‘To what extent do you need a calculator to perform basic maths calculations correctly?’ • (b) Command of multiplication tables (1-11) ‘How many multiplication tables can you recall?’ • Highest level of previous achievement in maths. Below level 2 - Level 2 and above

  11. 1. Frequencies of maths anxiety ratings (%). Low anxiety (1&2) High anxiety (4&5) 2. Mann-Whitney 3. Spearman’s (p) L vs H anxiety (p) with anxiety Self-efficacy (<.05) (<.05) Test score (<.05)(<.05) Calculator Rel. (<.05) (<.05) Tables Comm. (<.05)(.>.05) Results Stage 1 (2-tailed, alpha = .05 where applicable)

  12. 1. Frequencies of maths self-efficacy ratings (%). Low self-efficacy (1&2) High self-efficacy(4&5) 2. Mann-Whitney 3. Spearman’s (p) L vs H self-efficacy (p) with self-efficacy Test score (<.05)(<.05) Calculator Rel (<.05)(<.05) Tables Comm. (<.05)(<.05) Results (2-tailed, alpha = .05 where applicable)

  13. Results stage 1 (2-tailed, alpha = .05 where applicable) 1. Frequencies of calculator-reliance ratings (%). Low reliance (1&2) High reliance (4&5) 2. Mann-Whitney 3. Spearman’s 4. Spearman’s (p) LvsH calc. rel. (p) vs calc.rel. (p) vs score Test score (<.05)(<.05)- Tables Comm. (<.05)(<.05)(<.05)

  14. Results Stage 1 (2-tailed, alpha = .05 where applicable) 1. Frequency with and without a level 2 maths qualification (%) Without level 2 = 1 With level 2 = 2 2. Mann-Whitney (Below L2 maths vs L2and above) (p) Anxiety (>.05) Self-efficacy (<.05) Test score (>.05) Calculator Rel (>.05) Tables Comm (>.05)

  15. Comparison of stage 1 and stage 2 variables (Wilcoxon) Maths self-efficacy p > .05 Maths (test) anxiety p < .05 [Stage 1 > 2] Test score p < .05 [Stage 1 < 2] Results Stage 1 and 2(2-tailed, alpha = .05 where applicable)

  16. Building-up a picture. inverse direct Focused practice Calculator-reliance Tables command Maths (test) anxiety Test performance Previous achievement Maths self-efficacy

  17. Open comments from stage 1 After test 1: ‘I feel very, very, very deflated and extremely disappointed.’ ‘I felt fine before I started, now I feel pretty poor about myself.’ Reasons for declining test 1: ‘Just can’t bare the thought of the pressure.’ ‘I feel sick and trembly.’ ‘Facing my worst fear which most of the time I try to avoid.’ ‘I feel I can’t put my self through it.’ ‘Please help!’

  18. Frequencies of anxiety rating for nursing students achieving high (>70%)intermediate (40-69%) and low (<40%) scores in test 2. Possible scenario: Able to over-ride anxiety (totally or partially)? Able to over-ride some anxiety? Anxiety interfering with cognition?

  19. Summary of results: • Students with high maths (test) anxiety and/or low maths self-efficacy tended to have: • Higher reliance on a calculator for basic maths • Poorer command of multiplication tables • Lower test score • Students with low maths self-efficacy also tended to have: • Lower previous achievement in maths • So, what were they really saying when they said: • ‘I’m really worried about the maths’ or • ‘I’m useless at maths!’ • A period of focused study tended to: • Decrease student anxiety • Increase student test scores • Not affect self-efficacy

  20. A one-item reflective evaluation of maths (test) anxiety: • gave a useful evaluation of anxiety to increase (self) awareness. • showed similar association patterns to MARS • gleaned information associated with maths anxiety • helped focus remedial action • Unanswered questions: • Value of including it in diagnostic numeracy testing? • Value for promoting ‘safe practice’ ? • Value for promoting awareness as a first stage in overcoming maths-related anxiety.

  21. References: • Alexander L, Martray C (1989). The development of an abbreviated version of the mathematics anxiety rating scale. Measurement and evaluation in counselling and development. 22:143-150. • Ashcraft MH and Kirk EP (2001). The relationships among working memory, maths anxiety, and performance. Journal of experimental psychology: general. 130(2):224-237. • Hodge JE. (2002). The effect of math anxiety, math self-efficacy and computer-assisted instruction on the ability of undergraduate nursing students to calculate drug dosages. Dissertation: Doctor of Education, West Virginia University. • Hopko DR, Mahadevan R, Bare RL, Hunt MK. (2003). The abbreviated maths anxiety scale (AMAS): Construction, validity and reliability. Assessment. 10(2):178-182. • Richardshon FC and Suinn RM (1972). The mathematics anxiety rating scale: psychometric data. Journal of Counselling Psychology. 19(6):551-554. • Sheffield D. (2006). Presented at ‘Supporting maths difficulties in health sciences and practice How does anxiety influence maths performance and what can we do about it? ’, HEA/University of Nottingham Joint workshop. June.

More Related