1 / 24

Jens Johansen, ETF 3-4 March 2010, Kiev

The role of human capital in international economic competitiveness indices and implications for national education policy reform. Jens Johansen, ETF 3-4 March 2010, Kiev. Education is a driver of competitiveness, but why and how?.

jacob-gross
Download Presentation

Jens Johansen, ETF 3-4 March 2010, Kiev

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. The role of human capital in international economic competitiveness indices and implications for national education policy reform Jens Johansen, ETF 3-4 March 2010, Kiev

  2. Education is a driver of competitiveness, but why and how? • Is it the amount of education? At an individual and at a macro level? The quality? The manner of teaching? Is it the changes in the mindset of participants which education gives rise to that create competitiveness? Is it what you teach? Is it a question of how many students complete education?

  3. Today’s session (part I): • We will demonstrate the effect of the current indicators • How much can a country improve its competitiveness through education reforms? • We will see that it is possible to weigh different reform options against each other through simulations • Group work on which options to go for in Ukraine

  4. World Economic Forum (WEF) • The WEF uses simple measurements of education & training to cover many countries: • Extent of formal education (hard data) • Cost of formal education (hard data) • Quality of education (survey) • Training on-the-job (survey) • Facilities, i.e. internet access (survey) • ETF did simulations using the full dataset of the Global Competitiveness Inex: 2007-2008

  5. WEF’s Competitiveness model

  6. Which WEF indicators cover education and training in human capital? • Pillar 4: Quality of primary education, Primary enrolment, Education expenditure • Pillar 5: Secondary enrolment, Tertiary enrolment, Quality of the educational system, Quality of science and mathematics education, Quality of management schools, Internet access in schools, Local availability of research and training services, Extent of staff training • Pillar 12: Capacity for innovation, Quality of research institutions, Company spending on research and development,University-industry research collaboration, Availability of researchers and engineers, Utility patents. • + Brain-drain (pillar 7)

  7. Effect of the E&T indicators: Some results • Three stages of analysis; 1- Number of E&T and Innovation indicators in GCI 2007-2008: 18/113 = 15.9% of total 2- Weight of these indicators on the overall GCI 2007-2008:

  8. Effect of the E&T indicators: Some results, cont. 3- Simulations: What would be the effect on the total competitiveness score for a country that became equal to the best (or worst) performer in E&T and Innovation indicators?

  9. Effect of the current indicators: Some results, cont.

  10. Tool for improving national economic competitiveness • Possibility of analysing the potential of a given country’s competitiveness if it improved its performance on the E&T & Innovation variables • Possibility of exploring time series, combined with educational reforms data. • And we can assess which kind of E&T or innovation reforms that will have the biggest impact on competitiveness…

  11. Improving through comparisons…

  12. Locally or regionally…

  13. Or you can improve by focusing on selected areas

  14. Part II – 4 March 2010 Education policies for a knowledge society and national economic competitiveness

  15. What are the elements within education that can foster competitiveness? • Europe has been advocating more education and training broadly as part of its Lisbon agenda • But we need to look deeper…

  16. Lisbon Strategy 2010 • Europe will be the leading knowledge-based economic region • Education and Training 2010 • Single comprehensive education strategy for Europe • Achieving the set goals through lifelong learning • Primary focus on quality, access and opening education to the world of work • More mobility • Enhancing teaching of mathematics, science and technology • Strategic goals will not be reached by 2010

  17. European Union in 1995

  18. European Union in 2009

  19. Post-Lisbon Strategy 2020 • Assumptions: • Demographic change • Climate change • Shift of economic epicentre towards East • Four themes: • Making lifelong learning and mobility a reality; • Improving the quality and efficiency of education and training; • Promoting equity, social cohesion and active citizenship; and • Enhancing creativity and innovation at all levels of education

  20. Pillars of national economic competitiveness Trust Risk-taking I nnovation Creativity = Keys to success

  21. Education policy for national economic competitiveness • Concept of knowledge • Dynamics of knowing and learning • Construction vs. storage of knowledge • Understanding innovation • Extracting value from knowledge • Social rather than individual process • Building social capital • Shared knowing, skills and expertise • Collaborative procedures • Power of human imagination • Crisis of ‘human resources’ • Finding personal talent

  22. Education policy for national economic competitiveness Knowledge Social capital Imagination POLICY Innovation

  23. Possible ways forward • Make national education and competitiveness policies coherent • Trust, risk-taking, strategic alliances and learning from mistakes • Cultivate diversity, not standardisation • Less competition • Unlock creativity at all levels of education • Value creative behaviours and institutions • Redesign static and content-driven curricula • Increase collaboration and communication in teaching and learning • Shift focus from individual seatwork toward cooperative learning • Reward teacher collaboration and networking • Focus on building healthy identities and strong personalities • Character education and role modelling • Allow differences and support self-esteem development

  24. THANK YOU! www.etf.europa.eu jjo@etf.europa.eu

More Related