Power exchange operations
This presentation is the property of its rightful owner.
Sponsored Links
1 / 94

Power Exchange Operations PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 87 Views
  • Uploaded on
  • Presentation posted in: General

Power Exchange Operations. S.C. Saxena National Load Despatch Center. Presentation Outline. Review of Fundamentals Power Exchanges Concepts Implementation in India Regulatory Framework Procedures for Collective Transactions Congestion Management Market Splitting

Download Presentation

Power Exchange Operations

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript


Power exchange operations

Power Exchange Operations

S.C. Saxena

National Load Despatch Center


Presentation outline

Presentation Outline

  • Review of Fundamentals

  • Power Exchanges

    • Concepts

    • Implementation in India

  • Regulatory Framework

  • Procedures for Collective Transactions

  • Congestion Management

    • Market Splitting

    • Sharing of Available Margins amongst the Power Exchanges

  • Experience Gained in India

  • Trading of Renewable Energy Certificates in the Power Exchanges

  • Taking the Markets to the Next Level

    • Proposal For Evening Market

    • Sub-Hourly (15 – Minute) Market in Power Exchange

  • Recent International Experience


Review of fundamentals

Review of Fundamentals


Market

Market

A mechanism through which buyers and sellers interact to determine prices and exchange goods and services

Entire set of conditions surrounding production, transport and distribution of a product

Size determined by geography, transport, costs, etc.


In a market everything has a price

In a market everything has a price !!!

  • Price

    • is the value (not cost) of the good/service in terms of money

    • represents the terms on which voluntary exchange of goods & services takes place

    • Serves as signal to the producers and consumers


Demand

Demand

Need + Purchasing power = Demand

Law of downward–sloping demand

When price of a commodity is raised, buyers tend to buy less of the commodity, other things remaining constant (e.g., purchasing power, related goods, preferences, environment, etc.)

Price

Quantity


Supply curve

Supply Curve

The supply curve shows the relationship between its price and the amount of that commodity that producers are willing to produce and sell, other things held constant (e.g., cost of production, technological advancement, related goods, etc.)

Price

Quantity


Equilibrium

Equilibrium

Quantity demanded is equal to quantity supplied !

Surplus

Shortage

Price of

commodity

Quantity


Shift in equilibrium

Shift in equilibrium


Price elasticity of demand

Price elasticity of demand

Change in Quantity Demanded in response to change in Price

More Elastic

Elastic

Perfectly Inelastic

Less elastic

Perfectlyelastic


Power exchanges concepts

Power Exchanges: Concepts


Bilateral otc markets

Bilateral (OTC) Markets

  • Common price through a co-operative approach

  • Major Concerns –

    • Price Discovery

    • Price Discrimination

    • Liquidity

    • Transaction Costs


Power exchanges definition

Power Exchanges - Definition

  • An electricity Power Exchange provides a spot market, mainly day-ahead, for electricity, which like any other market matches demand and supply for each time block, while providing a public price index


Power exchange characteristics 1

Power Exchange – Characteristics (1)

  • A Market Place

    • Voluntary or Mandatory

    • Anonymous auction platform

    • Neutral

  • Liquidity

    • A competitive wholesale spot trading arrangement

  • Energy Only Markets

    • Do not account for any technical constraints or capacity payments

  • Bids

    • Sale Bid – Quantum and Minimum price

    • Buy Bid – Quantum and Maximum price


Power exchange characteristics 2

Power Exchange – Characteristics (2)

  • Price Discovery

    • Common price achieved through non co-operative approach

    • Price Discovery by matching of demand-supply

    • Price signals

    • Benchmark reference price

  • Congestion Management

    • Implicit Auction

    • Market Splitting


Power exchange characteristics 3

Power Exchange – Characteristics (3)

  • Standardized specifications

    • Contract structure

  • Robust Clearing & Settlement systems

    • Counter party credit risk absorbed

  • Risk Management

    • Payment Security

    • Standard margining system

      • Eliminates credit rating

  • Fair, Safe, orderly market

    • Rigorous financial standards and surveillance procedures


Bilateral otc contract vs power exchange

Bilateral (OTC) Contract vs. Power Exchange


Interplay px bilateral markets otc

Interplay: PX – Bilateral Markets (OTC)

  • Rivals

    • Competition between two types of markets

  • Complementary

    • Competition limited to day-ahead

    • Preference to OTC in longer time frame

  • Inter-dependent

    • Prices on the PX & OTC must be very close else arbitrage occurs

    • Hedging


The px clearing house

The PX Clearing House

  • Subordinate to the PX

  • Intermediary for transactions

  • Tracks all transactions

  • Primary role

    • Guarantee financial reliability to the participants

  • Participants required to maintain margin accounts

  • Effectively hedges against credit risk


Advantages px

Advantages PX

  • Promotes trade and competition

  • Reliable price discovery

    • Reference for bilateral contracts

  • PX recognizes value of the commodity (electricity)

    • Does not guarantee lower prices

  • Optimal utilization of sparse resources

    • Generation

    • Transmission

  • Credit risks covered by the PX

  • Congestion Management

  • Facilitates trading of short term arising on account of uncertainty in demand forecasting


Auction models

Auction Models

PRICE

PRICE

Demand

Supply

Supply

Estimated Demand

MCP

VOLUME

MCV

MCV

VOLUME

MCP = Market Clearing Price

MCV = Market Clearing Volume

One Side Auction

Two Side Auction

MCP


Social welfare maximization

PRICE

Purchase

Sale

MCP

MCV

Social Welfare Maximization

Accepted Purchase Bids (>= MCP)

(Consumers’ Discount)

Accepted Sale Bids (<= MCP)

(Generators’ Surplus)


Price calculation algorithm day ahead hourly bids

Price Calculation Algorithm -Day ahead– Hourly Bids

AGGREGATED PURCHASE BIDS

AGGREGATEDSALE BIDS

Market Clearing Price (MCP) : 270 p

Market Clearing Volume (MCV): 600MW


Types of bids

Types of Bids

  • Single bids

    • Price – Quantity pairs, one for each hour

  • Block Bids

    • A Block bid is all or none type of a bid i.e. bid will get accepted by the system only if price and volume condition is getting satisfied.

    • Can cause unpredictable movements of prices and volumes

System Operator Training


Power exchange implementation in india

Power Exchange Implementation in India


The milestones

The Milestones

  • July 2006

    • Staff Paper by CERC

  • February 2007

    • CERC Guidelines for establishment of Power Exchange

  • August 2007

    • In principle approval to the first power exchange in the country

  • January 2008

    • Revised Regulations for Open Access in Inter-state Transmission, Effective 1st April 2008

  • June 2008

    • Procedure for Scheduling of Collective Transactions by CTU

    • Commencement of operations

  • October 2008

    • Second Exchange begins operations


Power exchange in india salient features

Power Exchange in India – Salient Features

  • Multiple Power Exchanges

    • Competition amongst Exchanges

  • Voluntary participation

  • Double sided bidding

  • Uniform pricing

  • Day-ahead exchange

  • Hourly bids

  • Congestion management by market splitting


Regulatory framework

Regulatory Framework

System Operator Training


Regulator s approach

Regulator’s Approach

  • CERC Guidelines for setting up of a Power Exchange:

    “The general approach of the Commission is to allow operational freedom to the PX within an overall framework. The regulation would be minimal and restricted to requirements essential for preventing derailment/accidents and collusion. Private entrepreneurship would be allowed to play its role. The Commission shall keep away from governance of PX, which would be required to add value and provide quality service to the customers”

NLDC


Cerc power market regulations 2010 1

CERC Power Market Regulations, 2010 (1)

  • Scope & Extent

    • OTC Markets

    • Power Exchange Market

    • Other Power Exchange Markets

      • Derivatives

  • Types of Contracts

    • Delivery based OTC Contracts

    • Financially settled electricity derivatives contracts transacted in OTC market

    • Delivery based contracts transacted on Exchange

    • REC Contracts

    • Capacity, Ancillary, Derivative based contracts (future)

System Operator Training


Cerc power market regulations 2010 2

CERC Power Market Regulations, 2010 (2)

  • Prior to grant of permission to Power Exchange, CERC may examine

    • Type of contract (day ahead, term ahead etc);

    • Price Discovery methodology and matching rules proposed;

    • Transaction period – When transaction shall commence and for what tenure transaction session shall continue before delivery commences;

    • Risk Management mechanism

      • Margining mechanism

      • Final Price Settlement mechanism

    • Delivery mechanism, delivery duration

System Operator Training


Cerc power market regulations 2010 3

CERC Power Market Regulations, 2010 (3)

Objectives of the Power Exchange (Regulation 10)

  • Ensure fair, neutral, efficient and robust price discovery

  • Provide extensive and quick price dissemination

  • Design standardised contracts and work towards increasing liquidity in such contracts

    • Explanation: Liquidity is a measure of ease of entering or exiting into a transaction (generally large transaction) with minimal impact in the market price of the transacted contract.

System Operator Training


Cerc power market regulations 2010 4

CERC Power Market Regulations, 2010 (4)

Principles of Price Discovery (Regulation 11)

The economic principle of social welfare maximisation and to create buyer and seller surplus simultaneously during price discovery.

The bidding mechanism shall be double sided closed bid auction on a day ahead basis.

The price discovered for the unconstrained market shall be a uniform market clearing price for all buyers and sellers who are cleared

In case of congestion in transmission corridor, market splitting mechanism shall be adopted.

The delivery / drawl of power shall be considered at the regional periphery.

System Operator Training


Cerc power market regulations 2010 5

CERC Power Market Regulations, 2010 (5)

  • Other Provisions

    • Prudential Norms

    • Governance Issues

    • Ownership Patterns

    • Registration – Fees

    • Membership

    • Clearing House

    • Interface with System Operator

System Operator Training


Open access regulations 2008

Open Access Regulations, 2008

  • Earlier Regulations notified in February 2004 (amended in 2005) stand repealed

  • Covers Short Term Open Access Transactions only

  • Categories of Transactions

    • Bilateral

    • Collective Transactions discovered on a Power Exchange

  • Nodal Agency

    • Bilateral: RLDCs

    • Collective: NLDC


Open access regulations 2008 provisions for collective transactions

Open Access Regulations, 2008: Provisions For Collective Transactions

  • Transmission Charges

    • Shift from “Contract Path” to “Point of Connection”

    • Both buyers and sellers to pay

    • IR Links – no separate treatment

  • Transmission Losses

    • Applicable on both buyers and sellers

  • Disbursement of Transmission Charges

    • 25% retained by CTU

    • 75% to be credited to long-term customers


Open access regulations 2008 provisions for collective transactions1

Open Access Regulations, 2008: Provisions For Collective Transactions

  • Thrust on Empowerment of SLDCs

  • SLDC Concurrence [Clause 8(2)]

    • NOC/Standing Clearance to be obtained by State Utilities/Intra-State Entities from the SLDC for trading through PX

    • SLDC to respond within 3 days

    • SLDCs may charge appropriate fee for such NOC/Standing Clearance (as per SERC or Rs. 5000 if not notified by SERC)


Procedures for scheduling of collective transactions

Procedures for Scheduling of Collective Transactions

System Operator Training


Eligibility conditions

Eligibility Conditions

  • Entities scheduled by RLDCs

    • Deemed Regional Entity

      • Entities whose metering and energy accounting done by RLDCs

  • Entities scheduled by SLDCs

    • SLDCs to assess TTC/ATC for their State system

    • Prior Consent from respective SLDCs

    • Standing Clearance / NOC

  • New Entities

    • To Satisfy conditions as laid down in IEGC

    • Obtain Prior Approval from RLDCs/SLDCs as per jurisdiction

NLDC


Commercial conditions 1

Commercial Conditions (1)

  • Charges for Collective Transactions payable to SLDCs

    • Transmission Charges: As per SERC, if notified or else Rs. 80/MWh

    • Operating Charges: Rs. 2,000 per day for each point of transaction

    • Each point of injection and drawl to be counted separately by SLDCs

    • PX to settle SLDC charges directly with respective SLDC


Commercial conditions 2

Commercial Conditions (2)

  • Charges for Collective Transactions payable to NLDC

  • Application Fee

    • @ Rs. 5,000/-, payable by PX to NLDC at the time of application

  • Transmission Charges

    • Applicable for each point of injection and drawl

    • Charges for use of ISTS @ Rs. 100 per MWh

  • Operating Charges

    • @ Rs. 5,000/- per day per group involved

    • Buyers and Sellers in a State to be clubbed into separate groups

    • Each group to be counted as a single entity by NLDC

  • Payment by PX to NLDC

    • Transmission and Operating Charges: By next working day

    • Preferred Mode: Electronic Fund Transfer


Treatment of losses

Treatment Of Losses

  • Average transmission losses of the respective region to be applied, both on Buyers and Sellers

    • Sellers to inject extra power (MW) in addition to contracted power (Contracted Power + Losses)

    • Buyers to draw less power (MW) than contracted power (Contracted Power – Losses)

  • Applicable losses to be declared in advance

  • Intra-State losses to be taken care of by the respective SLDCs

  • Additional losses for wheeling, if necessary

    • To be notified in advance by NLDC

    • Applicable only for Injection

NLDC


Real time congestion management

Real Time Congestion Management

  • Curtailment

    • By RLDCs at the periphery of Regional Entities

      • SLDCs to further incorporate this curtailment for State Utilities/Intra-State Entities

  • Settlement

    • Transmission Charges: Pro-rata refund by NLDC to PX

    • Operating Charges: Not to be revised

    • Direct settlement between PX and its participants


Power exchange operations

Information Exchange

Power Exchange

Constraints, if any

Acceptance by NLDC

Information exchanged over leased line between NLDC and PX

Request for Scheduling

Provisional Solution

N L D C

Over WAN

Trades

Schedules

RLDCs

Over Internet

(RLDC Website)

Schedules

SLDCs

Final Trade Results for State Utilities & Intra State Entities to be sent by PX directly to SLDCs


Congestion management

Congestion Management

NLDC


Demarcation into bid areas

Demarcation into Bid Areas

NLDC


Skewed load generation balance

SR

ER+NER

WR

NR

SKEWED LOAD GENERATION BALANCE

  • Scenarios:

  • 4D

  • 3D + 1S

  • 2D + 2S

  • 1D + 3S (Congestion)

  • 4S


Congestion management market splitting

Congestion Management - Market Splitting

Case – I : No Transmission Constraint

Zone – A

Load=100 MW

Zone – B

Gen=120 MW

Case – II : Constraint = 40 MW

  • Solution:

  • Increase price in Zone A to reduce demand to 40 MW

  • Decrease price in Zone B to reduce supply to 40 MW

MCP=125

Cost of Congestion: 2000

NLDC


Transmission congestion management methods

Transmission Congestion Management: Methods

  • Pricing Based

    • Explicit Auction

    • Implicit Auction

    • Market Splitting

  • Remedial

    • Counter Trade

    • Re-dispatching

NLDC


Congestion management in multi exchange scenario 1

Congestion Management in Multi Exchange Scenario (1)

  • ISSUE

    • Sharing of available margins

  • Possible Methods

    • Priority Based Rules

    • Explicit Auction

    • Merging of Bids

  • Priority Based Rules

    • Lowest MCP

    • Highest MCV

    • Highest MCP X MCV

    • Maximization of Social Welfare, consumer surplus, etc.

    • May not lead to an overall economy

NLDC


Congestion management in multi exchanges scenario 2

Congestion Management in Multi Exchanges Scenario (2)

  • Explicit Auctioning amongst Exchanges

    • Inter-dependencies in the Indian scenario

    • Difficult to implement

  • Merging of bids obtained by each Power Exchange

    • Equivalent to system operator interfacing with only one Exchange

    • Confidentiality issues

  • Pro – rata rationing of available margins

    • Simple to implement

    • Sub-optimal method

    • Possibility of over-estimation of capacity

    • Further complications

      • Arising out of inter-dependencies in the Indian scenario

NLDC


Implementation in india

Implementation in India

  • Worldwide, one Power Exchange dealing with physical delivery in one market

  • Pro-rata sharing of available margins

    • Applied on cleared trade volumes on each area and each corridor

    • Interim arrangement

    • Debate on for a more optimal method

NLDC


Discovery of multiple prices interplay

Discovery of Multiple Prices & Interplay

  • Prices discovered in Power Exchange

    • Reflection of anticipated UI price for the next day

  • Multiple Prices

    • Collective Transactions:

      • Two prices – one for each exchange

    • Two Grids – two UI Prices

    • In case of congestion, market split

      • Area prices

      • Multiple exchanges

NLDC


Case study

Case Study

  • No congestion till onset of severe winter

  • Occasional congestion after 12th Dec 08

    • Foggy conditions in Talcher area

  • Case of 12th Dec 2008

    • Period of Congestion: 0500 – 0600 Hrs

    • Congested Corridor: Total import to SR

    • TTC to SR reduced from 4000 MW to 3600 MW

    • Total provisional requisition: 1430 MW

    • Total trades cleared: 1091 MW

    • Market split into NEW Grid and SR Grid

    • MCP [IEX website]:

      • NEW Grid: Rs. 4.80 per kWh

      • SR Grid: Rs. 6.00 per kWh

    • Cost of Transmission discovered

      • Rs. 1.20 per kWh

NLDC


Experience gained

Experience Gained

NLDC


Monthly energy traded through power exchanges

Monthly Energy Traded through Power Exchanges

Data Up to April 2011


Daily energy traded through power exchanges

Daily Energy Traded through Power Exchanges

Data Up to April 2011


Correlation prices shortage surplus

Correlation: Prices & Shortage/ Surplus

Data: June-08 to Apr-11; IEX


Distribution of prices in power exchange iex

Distribution of Prices in Power Exchange (IEX)

System Operator Training


Distribution of shortage surplus iex

Distribution of Shortage / Surplus (IEX)

System Operator Training


Case of mcv increase after congestion

CASE OF MCV INCREASE AFTER CONGESTION

  • Day ahead Market saw increase in Cleared Volume after congestion is declared in particular time blocks due to:

    • Block –bids

    • New Sell/Buy bid getting cleared in Final iteration

NLDC

SOURCE:IEX Website


Segments in the short term market

Segments in the Short Term Market

NLDC


Volumes in the short term electricity market

Volumes in the Short Term Electricity Market

Source: MMC, CERC


Renewable energy certificates rec

Renewable Energy Certificates (REC)

NLDC


Dealing in renewable energy certificates 1

Dealing in Renewable Energy Certificates (1)

Provisions in the CERC REC Regulations, 2010

Regulation 8.1

“Unless otherwise specifically permitted by the Commission by order, the Certificates shall be dealt only through the Power Exchange and not in any other manner.”

Regulation 8.2

“The Certificate issued to eligible entity by the Central Agency may be placed for dealing in any of the Power Exchanges as the Certificate holder may consider appropriate, and such Certificate shall be available for dealing in accordance with the rules and byelaws of such Power Exchange.

Provided that the Power Exchanges shall obtain prior approval of the Commission on the rules and byelaws including the mechanism for discovery of price of the Certificates in the Power Exchange.”

NLDC


Dealing in renewable energy certificates 2

Dealing in Renewable Energy Certificates (2)

  • Statement 3.7.2 of the SOR on “Dealing in the Certificates” states that

    “The Commission has noted the observations and would like to reiterate that provision in the Regulation that REC shall be dealt only in the Power Exchange is adequate and also legally sustainable. The nature of operation of Power Exchange (which essentially is a platform where buyers and sellers buy and sell at the price discovered by matching aggregate demand and supply) is conducive to the development of the new and emerging concept of REC. The Commission is well within its jurisdiction under Section 66 of the Act to provide for the specific manner in which this new concept should be evolved. In any case this mechanism does not debar the traders from facilitating transactions in REC as Members of the Power Exchanges. The final regulations provide that the bye-laws of power exchange to be approved by the Commission should include price discovery mechanism.

NLDC


Pricing of renewable energy certificates 1

Pricing of Renewable Energy Certificates (1)

CERC determined Floor price and Forbearance price for dealing in Certificates, which shall remain valid up to FY 2012.

68

Provisions in the CERC REC Regulations, 2010: Regulation 9.1

“ The price of Certificate shall be as discovered in the Power Exchange. Provided that the Commission may, in consultation with the Central Agency and Forum of Regulators from time to time provide for the floor price and forbearance price separately for solar and non-solar Certificates.

NLDC


Pricing of renewable energy certificates 2

Pricing of Renewable Energy Certificates (2)

  • Statement 3.8.2 of the SOR on “Pricing of Certificates” states that

    “ The Commission has noted the observations. As regards the need for forbearance price, the Commission would like to emphasize that forbearance price is necessary to avoid price volatility which may defeat the very purpose of facilitating the RPO compliance by utilities through REC mechanism. The Commission has, however, acceded to the suggestion of providing for minimum price for REC along with forbearance price, to ensure the threshold level of revenue certainty. This is considered necessary to instill confidence in the investors towards REC mechanism. The Commission has also agreed to the suggestion of providing for broad guiding principles which the Commission would bear in mind while determining the forbearance price.Suitable modifications have accordingly been made in the draft regulations.”

NLDC


Trade redemption 1

Trade & Redemption (1)

  • Price Discovery in Power Exchanges

    • Double sided auction

    • Closed auction to start with, provision of continuous trade

    • Uniform price, with provision for pay-as-bid in future

  • Market lot = 1 REC

  • Trading Sessions

    • Monthly for the first year, frequency may be increased depending on liquidity

    • Non-Solar and Solar RECs

    • Last Wednesday of every month

    • Timing: 1 PM to 3 PM

NLDC


Trade redemption 2

Trade & Redemption (2)

  • Provisional Results

    • By 3:30 PM from both PX to NLDC

    • Max bid volumes, seller wise, to be sent to NLDC for checking

  • Post Trade Check

    • Sellers to limit total sell in both the PXs to the total RECs held by the concerned RE Generator such that the total cleared volume is less than total RECs held

  • Checking by NLDC

    • For total quantum of bids in both the PXs taken together

    • NLDC to revert back by 4 PM.

NLDC


Trade redemption 3

Trade & Redemption (3)

  • Default by Sellers

    • In case of default by any Seller(s) in terms of volume, bids of the defaulter(s) to be rejected in both the PXs and auction to be run by both PXs excluding the defaulter(s) bids.

    • Defaulter can bid in the subsequent auction next month onwards. In case of three defaults in a year, report to CERC.

  • Final Results

    • By 5 PM from PX to CA

  • Checking and Extinguish

    • By the Central Agency by 6 PM

NLDC


Schematic description of procedure for redemption

Schematic Description of Procedure for Redemption

Central

Agency

Confirmation

Of REC validity &

quantity

(by 16:00)

Verification

Conditions

(By 15:30)

2

Offer for Sale

13:00 to 15:00 hrs

Bid for Purchase

13:00 to 15:00

Obligated

Entity / Buyer

Eligible

Entity

Power

Exchange(s)

1a

1b

Market Clearance

(Volume & Price)

Intimation of Trade results

For Extinguishing REC

(By 17:00)

3

Central

Agency

4

Reports

Fully Automated Flow of Information: Paperless Working

NLDC


Snapshot rec inventory www recregistryindia in

Snapshot: REC Inventory (www.recregistryindia.in)

NLDC


Information dissemination

Information Dissemination

  • Central Agency Website: www.recregistryindia.in

    • List of Registered REC Holders

    • Total quantum valid RECs as on date, trend for the past

  • Trade Results

    • MCP and MCV on Power Exchange Websites

      • www.iexindia.com

      • www.powerexindia.com

  • List of REC Buyers, obligated entities:

    • PX to give monthly report to CERC/CA

  • List of seller defaulters:

    • PX Website / CA Website

NLDC


Moving to the next level some issues under discussion

Moving to the Next Level: Some Issues under Discussion

NLDC


Market snapshot 27th june 2010 source iex

Market Snapshot: 27th June 2010 (source: IEX)


Missed opportunity

Missed Opportunity

Due to Congestion

Unmatched Volume

7/15/2014

POSOCO

78


Potential volume for evening market

Potential Volume for Evening Market

7/15/2014

POSOCO

79


Corridor utilization

Corridor Utilization

Congestion

Observed

Seasonally

Only towards

NR, SR and

S1 – S2

Only a couple of

corridors

congested

out of

a dozen

IEX Website

7/15/2014

POSOCO

80


Prevailing scenario

Prevailing Scenario

Shortages

Round the clock and in all regions

In many hours

Sale bids >> Purchase bids 

Volume lost due to price mismatch is substantial

Congestion

During some hours

Only couple of corridors facing mild congestion

Margins available on other corridors

Market split by very low price difference !!

Need for an Evening Market in the Power Exchanges

7/15/2014

POSOCO

81


Advantages of the proposed evening market

Advantages of the Proposed Evening Market

Consumers

More choice and satisfaction

Sellers

Another opportunity

Further optimization of the portfolio

Take a more informed position in the market

Better utilization of uncongested and under-utilized corridors

More economy and efficiency

Social welfare maximization

Change in strategy and an overall improvement

Likely that more volume is cleared

Movement to the next level

7/15/2014

POSOCO

82


Fluctuations in wind generation

Fluctuations in Wind Generation

MW

Tamil Nadu

Aug 2010

DATE

TIME


Sharp price movements aug 10

Sharp Price Movements (Aug ‘10)

PRICE

DAYS

HOUR

7/15/2014

POSOCO

84


15 minute bidding in px 1

15 – Minute bidding in PX (1)

USP of the Indian Market Structure

15 Minute Scheduling

15 Minute Metering

15 Minute Accounting

Ramping Rate

Hour boundary: high ramp rate (1000 MW)

Large Changes in HVDC set points (NEW – SR) in operation

15 minute bidding

facilitate gradual ramping up and down

provide operational ease to the participants

Better portfolio management

Better management of imbalances

Deviations from the schedule

NLDC

85


15 minute bidding in px 2

15 – Minute bidding in PX (2)

Encourage participation by the Renewable Energy Sources

Australian Market has adopted 5 minute interval for facilitation of renewable energy sources

Prices discovered in PX and UI Prices

Hourly prices on the Power Exchanges

UI Prices are on a 15 minute interval

Introduction of 15 minute bidding would make the two comparable

Both the Morning and the Evening Markets should have 15 – minute bidding interval

NLDC

86


International experience

International Experience

NLDC


Cigre 2010 study committee c5 on electricity markets

CIGRE 2010: Study Committee C5 on Electricity Markets

  • Preferential Subject 1:

    • Challenges of national or state regulations of transmission and system operators in regional markets, L. A. Dale

    • 8 Papers

  • Preferential Subject 2:

    • Impact of intermittent Resources or Demand Response on Market Designs; Andrew L. Ott

    • 10 Papers

  • Preferential Subject 3:

    • Interactions of environmental incentives and markets (e.g. carbon) with electricity markets, Charles F. Zimmermann

    • 4 Papers


C5 101 experience of india s first power exchange and challenges ahead

C5-101: Experience of India’s first powerexchange and challenges ahead

  • Outline of Electricity trading in India

  • Features of Power Exchange

    • Members and clients

    • Delivery and interface with system operator

    • Block bids

  • Operational experience

    • Participation level

    • Price trend and volatility

  • Issues and challenges

    • Propensity to over draw rather than schedule power

    • Last priority to power exchanges in transmission capacity allocation

    • Price cap on day-ahead transaction


Power exchange operations

C5-102: Harmonization of cross border transmission capacity allocation within the Central West Europe region

  • Presentation of CWE Region (Belgium, France, Netherlands, Luxembourg and Germany)

    • harmonisation of the rules for allocating the transmission capacity within CWE

  • The establishment of the Joint Auction Office (JAO)

  • The scope of activities of the Joint auction office

    • allocating the daily capacity on the German borders

    • Operating the explicit daily auctions on Belgium borders

    • Coupling fallback

    • Collecting and sharing the congestion revenue for the TSOs

  • Harmonisation and improvement of the auction rules

  • Brief of CWE Market Coupling project


Attempt to harmonize in europe c5 102

Attempt to Harmonize in Europe (C5-102)

definitions,

products to be auctioned,

participation requirements,

financial guarantees,

firmness of both allocated capacities and nominated programs,

definition of force majeure,

bids format,

time schedule of the auctions,

compensation/reimbursement in case of reduction,

payment modalities,

secondary market principles (”use it or sell it”),

responsibility of parties,

the suspension/termination of contract conditions.


Power exchange operations

C5-106 : Czech and Slovak spot electricity market coupling on the basis of implicit capacity allocation

Daily transactions between the two market areas take place exclusively in the form of implicit auctions.

The implicit auction office is a virtual area in the information system of one of the market operators; it ensures that sell bids and buy bids in the two market areas are matched.

The virtual office is a part of both information systems, and the two market operators will alternate in performing the function of the virtual office.

Implicit auctions are based on the principle of price coupling;

In the event of capacity constraints at the interconnection point the market splits, and two prices are created.

In the event of transactions constrained due to congestion and market split, the price difference generates an implicit auction price that generates revenues allocated between the two transmission system operators.


C5 107 multiple power exchanges in india a case study

C5-107: Multiple power exchanges in India – a case study

  • Study of the experience gained from the operation of multiple power exchanges in a single physical delivery market in India

  • Salient features of PX implementation in India

  • Allocation of available transfer margins,

  • Congestion management

  • Interplay between the bilateral market, day-ahead market in Power Exchanges and the real time market.

  • Issues

    • Multiplicity of price signals

    • Regulatory overlap – forward price signals

    • Regulatory uncertainty – price caps

    • Transmission pricing & losses

    • Balancing market guiding vector

    • Available margins for the PXs

    • Impact of block bids


Thank you for your attention saxena samir@gmail com

Thank You for your attention !!

[email protected]

NLDC


  • Login