Payment by results innovation pilots 11 august 2011 l.jpg
This presentation is the property of its rightful owner.
Sponsored Links
1 / 21

Payment by results Innovation pilots 11 August 2011 PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 121 Views
  • Uploaded on
  • Presentation posted in: General

Payment by results Innovation pilots 11 August 2011. Crispin Blunt MP Minister for Prisons and Probation Ministry of Justice. Helen Judge Director, Sentencing and Rehabilitation Ministry of Justice. Today’s event. Update you on the payment by results programme

Download Presentation

Payment by results Innovation pilots 11 August 2011

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript


Payment by results innovation pilots 11 august 2011 l.jpg

Payment by resultsInnovation pilots 11 August 2011


Slide2 l.jpg

Crispin Blunt MPMinister for Prisons and ProbationMinistry of Justice


Slide3 l.jpg

Helen JudgeDirector, Sentencing and RehabilitationMinistry of Justice


Today s event l.jpg

Today’s event

  • Update you on the payment by results programme

  • To set out the details of the innovation pilots

  • To discuss with you some of the opportunities and challenges

  • To hear your views

  • To help you consider whether you want to put your proposals forward for these pilots


What has been committed to l.jpg

What has been committed to:

  • The coalition Agreement stated the Government’s intention to:

    “pay independent providers to reduce reoffending, paid for by the savings this new approach will generate for the criminal justice system”

    The Green Paper outlines what this will mean in practice:

    • New approach paying providers to reduce reoffending

    • Ambition to apply the principles to all providers by 2015

    • At least six new pilots – with innovation pilots on top of this

    • Supported by wider reforms over the next two years


Payment by results is really about l.jpg

Payment by Results is really about…..

  • A focus on Outcomes rather than process.

  • Risk Transfer – ensuring that the financial risk for reductions in reoffending is transferred to the provider and not borne by the taxpayer

  • Innovation – encouraged by giving increased discretion to providers and engaging a wide range of providers

  • Principle is ‘we should pay for what works’

  • Innovation underlines our commitment to open up the payment by results market. We want to give you an opportunity to bring your ideas to us. We want to use these pilots as an opportunity to expand our understanding of what works.


We have defined 4 pilot types l.jpg

We have defined 4 pilot types…..

  • Prisons

  • Community

  • Justice Reinvestment

  • Innovation


Progress so far l.jpg

Progress so far……

  • Launched:

    • HMP Peterborough - Social Impact Bond

    • HMP Doncaster – Private Sector model

    • ‘Justice Reinvestment’ pilots in Greater Manchester and five London Boroughs

      In progress:

    • We have begun the innovation pilots programme

    • We are working with public sector prisons to consider a PbR pilot

    • We are working with probation trusts to consider a pilot working with offenders on licence and community sentences


Slide9 l.jpg

  • Luke Edwards

  • Deputy Director, Reducing Reoffending:

  • Payment by Results and Localism

  • Ministry of Justice


Why innovation l.jpg

Why innovation?

We must ensure our commissioning model harnesses the creativity and expertise that independent providers can bring. This includes small and specialist providers and social enterprises. Breaking the Cycle Green Paper, Page 41

  • Enthusiasm for the sector but concerns about applying traditional commissioning routes

  • Aim of the pilots are to:

    • Genuinely test whether the enthusiasm and confidence can translate into concrete investment

    • Build the evidence base by testing different delivery models

    • Build a wider provider base with a demonstrable track record at reasonable scale

    • Enabling the potential new funding models to emerge

    • Enable the voluntary and other sectors to potentially engage in a different way with the process


Innovation pilots l.jpg

Innovation Pilots

  • We are proposing two opportunities for people to provide their ideas:

    • Proposals focusing onthose offenders sentenced to less than 12 months in custody

    • Genuinely innovative ideas focusing on different types of offenders

  • We are interested in both innovative ways of:

    • Delivering services;

    • Commissioning services.

  • Intention is to compete over the summer for the ‘under 12 month proposals’, which means we will draw together a more detailed specification

  • Informal submissions for ‘other’ proposals for policy consideration in the autumn

  • Aim is to move into implementation phase for the under 12 months pilots from April 2011 depending on the nature of the proposal


  • Offenders sentenced to less than 12 months l.jpg

    Offenders sentenced to less than 12 months

    • Ambition is for one or two pilots – depending on nature and size of proposals

    • We will be expecting ‘bidders’ to lead on the pilots - done with and not done to

    • Partnerships and investment will need to be secured by the bidders – we may provide a small amount of upfront investment to deliver the pilots if a rationale for this demonstrates it is necessary

    • We will pay on success. £20m has been allocated for success payments


    What will you need to think about l.jpg

    What will you need to think about?

    • Measurement and attributation

    • Innovation is key but value for money remains a paramount consideration

    • Cohort

    • You will need to define which offenders are you planning on working with? Will the pilot be sufficiently large to test your interventions at scale?

    • Delivery model

    • What is your proposed model? Is it scalable and responsive? Is it supported by an evidence base?

    • Funding

    • The first outcome payments are likely to be made in the third year. Working capital is critical. There is some scope for MoJ to provide initial working capital potentially linked to attachments or interim outcomes.

    • Working in Partnership

    • Which organisations will be delivering your pilot? How will you work with the public sector? Have you considered consortia?


    Slide14 l.jpg

    • Brian Farthing

    • Economic Adviser, Analytical Services

    • Ministry of Justice


    Key pilot design issues to consider l.jpg

    Key pilot design issues to consider…


    Examples of existing payment by results schemes l.jpg

    Examples of existing payment by results schemes


    Session one l.jpg

    Session One

    • Discussion about what you have heard:

      • What are the key issues for you?

      • What opportunities might this present?


    Slide18 l.jpg

    • Ian PoreeDirector, Commissioning & CommercialNational Offender Management Service


    Wider context l.jpg

    Wider Context

    • The Payment by Results pilot programme is a fundamental component of the recently published ‘Competition Strategy for Offender Services’.

    • Further competitions in the first year include:

      • Custodial competitions - Further nine prisons to be competed this year

      • Community Competitions - Underway is the competition for community payback services in London. We will hold a competition to replace the existing Electronic monitoring services contracts due to expire in March 2013


    Opportunities l.jpg

    Opportunities

    • The Competition Strategy and the PbR pilots provide us with an opportunity to:

      • Move away from focusing on how providers deliver a particular service, and concentrate on what outcomes are required from a particular service

      • Deliver better outcomes for the taxpayers for less

      • Develop a diverse market of potential providers of Offender services

      • Stimulate providers from all sectors to innovative and better value services


    Innovation longer term l.jpg

    Innovation – longer term

    • Need to consider the policy/operational impacts of other proposals outside of the under 12 month group

    • We have a good understanding of the impact of tackling under 12 month offenders – and we would need to do the same for others

    • We need to do this on a longer timescale and consider the fit with the wider policy and delivery direction

    • We want both to hear your ideas and to engage with you on these proposals


  • Login