1 / 26

APA Planning Academy October 22, 2013 Multi-Family Risk Tolerance John Campanella

APA Planning Academy October 22, 2013 Multi-Family Risk Tolerance John Campanella. Overview. Site availability and cost Allowable multi-family residences Parking requirements Absorption – rental lease-up / sales rate Financial feasibility .

hinto
Download Presentation

APA Planning Academy October 22, 2013 Multi-Family Risk Tolerance John Campanella

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. APA Planning Academy October 22, 2013Multi-Family Risk ToleranceJohn Campanella

  2. Overview • Site availability and cost • Allowable multi-family residences • Parking requirements • Absorption – rental lease-up / sales rate • Financial feasibility

  3. Site Availability and Cost • Existing Use Residential, commercial, vacant • Neighborhood Multi-family, commercial, historic resources • Ownership Private owner, professional company

  4. Allowable Multi-family Residences • Zoning • Residences allowed • Number of stories allowed • Height, set-backs, open space • Size of site / ability to merge sites

  5. Parking Requirements • AUD areas – minimum 1 car per residence Applicant can request more • 1 car per residence lowers cost per unit Reduces structure size, bulk and scale Reduces structure cost Allows for more residences in same structure Allows for more open space

  6. Absorption – Rental Lease-up / Sales Rate • Rentals – lease up period (net expense) Realistic time – rents / number of residences Construction loan funds prior to mortgage • Sales – escrow closings per month What “market bears” --- in a limited time frame 50% multi-family pre-sales for FNMA approval Developer guarantees to repay in 18 to 24 months • Lenders validate up-front or will not finance

  7. Financial Feasibility – Residences Per Acre • Sales – up to 36 residences / acre • Rentals – up to 63 / acre • Employer sponsored sales – up to 63 / acre • Cooperatives – up to 63 / acre • At lower density – likely luxury units Unless owner develops or invest significant equity

  8. Economic Comparison

  9. Economic Comparison

  10. Financial Feasibility – Residence Mix • Rentals – considerations 60% of residences in Santa Barbara are rentals 55% of rentals are one-bedrooms Average number of bedrooms is 1.50 • Sales – considerations 10% of owned residences are one-bedroom Average number of bedrooms is 2.50 • What product do workers want and can afford?

  11. Financial Feasibility – Property Priority • Santa Barbara is a built-out city Underutilized properties are the opportunity • The owners may not want to sell Cash flow with no debt, avoid development risk • Commercial Properties – great opportunity But are expensive (cap rate) / other uses

  12. Financial Feasibility – Mixed Use • AUD allows retention of the commercial SF Can be rebuilt onsite or sold to others • Residential has lower parking requirements • Residential more valuable on upper floors • Commercial more valuable on ground floor • But compatibility issues – usage and size

  13. Financial Feasibility – Horizontal Mixed Use • Redevelop a block / zone of scale • Housing, work space, retail, other commercial • Centralize parking in multi-levels for all uses • A “village” –La Entrada horizontal model? • Creatives stay in Santa Barbara / spend $$$ locally

  14. Discussion – Horizontal Mixed Use • Does this help the production of housing? • Does this help economic development? • Are there other benefits? • Are there similar examples elsewhere?

  15. Cota Street Site CM Zone C D E

  16. Project C – Cota Rental Design Team Detty Peikert Bob Kupiec David Black Cass Ensberg Bonnie Sangster Jaime Palencia Project Statistics 0.99 Acres 56 Units 1,500 s.f. Commercial 59 Surface & Tuck-under Parking 31% Open Space/Landscaping Lessons Covered Parking makes Room for Open Space 56 Units per Acre

  17. Project C - Rental Elevations/perspectives $371,702 per unit or $1300-$2100 rent per month

  18. Milpas Site A B

  19. Project B1 – Milpas Rental Design Team Keith Rivera Ellen Bildsten Susanne Tejada John Moyer Project Statistics 1.54 Acres 79 Units 10,500 s.f. Commercial 79 Surface & tuck-under Res. Spaces 21 Surface & Tuck-under Comm. Spaces 20% Open Space/Landscaping Lessons 3-4 stories = 20% on grade open space 2-3 stories = 0% on grade open space 51 Units per Acre

  20. Project B1 – Milpas Rental $366,400 per unit or $1200-$1950 rent per month

  21. Hotel Santa Barbara

More Related