1 / 31

ANR Update Corn Stalk Value: Feed or Fertilizer

ANR Update Corn Stalk Value: Feed or Fertilizer. Edwin Ritchey Extension Soil Specialist UK-REC. Notice Amount of Residue Remaining. Corn Stover. About ½ of corn plant is not removed during harvest (stalks, leaves, husks, cobs, tassel). Good feed for cattle? Some grain is also left

hilda-warren
Download Presentation

ANR Update Corn Stalk Value: Feed or Fertilizer

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. ANR Update Corn Stalk Value: Feed or Fertilizer Edwin Ritchey Extension Soil Specialist UK-REC

  2. Notice Amount of Residue Remaining

  3. Corn Stover • About ½ of corn plant is not removed during harvest (stalks, leaves, husks, cobs, tassel). • Good feed for cattle? • Some grain is also left • Good loss is 1%, 100 bu/A = 1 bu grain

  4. Value of corn stover to: • Grain Producer • N, P, K, micronutrients, OM • Cattle Producer/Cattle • Beats a snowball? • Emergency feed in dry year • Low quality feed, needs supplementing

  5. Grain Producer • Nutrients contained in stover (lbs/ton) • N (14), P (7), K (29) plus other (AGR-1) • Organic Matter • Builds soil structure, conserves moisture, reduces soil erosion and compaction • Value ($/ton fertilizer) based on 9-24-11 prices • Urea ($625), DAP ($675), KCl ($650) • N ($9.51), P ($3.29), K ($15.71) • Nutrients (N, P, K) per ton = $28.51

  6. Cattle Producer • Baling versus grazing • Baling takes nutrients from field • Loss of N, P, K, OM, and micros • Hard on equipment • Leaves the best stuff for cattle in field (leaves, tassels, shucks) • Grazing leaves nutrients in field (+ grain) • Cattle get what they want/need (not stalks) • Only nutrients removed are in the form of gain • Reallocation of nutrients

  7. Real Numbers/Muhlenberg Co. 2010 • Stalk weights 87.4 g (10 stalk avg. DM weight) • 28,000 stalks / acre • 1 acre stalks = 5,395 lbs cut close to ground • N, P, K = $28.51 / ton of stalks • $28.51 * 2.7 ton/A = $76.91 per acre of stalks

  8. Content of Stover Dry Matter = how much is not water Total Digestible Nutrients = energy (e.g. carbs, fats) Crude Protein = building blocks for protein Source: Nutrition Requirements of Beef Cattle, 6th revised edition.

  9. Nutrition Facts • If forages are less than 8% protein (dry cow) you will need protein supplement 11% (wet) • To bring ration from 5% CP to 8% will cost between $0.40 to $0.75/cow/day ($0.50) • Cow eats approximately 25 lbs/day • From 1000 lb bale = 40 meals (no loss or waste) • Outside storage will lose ≈ 33% grass hay • More for corn stover, 50%?

  10. What the Value? Hay 1000 lbs bale 8% CP, 50% TDN Stover 1000 lb bale 5% CP, 50% TDN

  11. More numbers • Assuming 5,000 lbs stover/A then 5 1,000 lbs bales/acre • Cost per bale (Assuming no loss) • About $0.50 /meal/cow @25 meals/bale = $20 • $10 - ? / bale to roll = $10 • $75 N-P-K/A = $15 • Total cost of bale of stover is $45 • Without including nutrient loss $30/roll

  12. Assuming No Loss From Storage Hay 1000 lbs bale 8% CP, 50% TDN Stover 1000 lb bale 5% CP, 50% TDN $30-45 per roll ??? $ per roll

  13. Removal Rates • Calculated amount of stover per acre • Total amount of stover = 5,000 – 7,000lbs/A • Potential removed = baling vs. grazing • What would be removed? Stalks, husks, leaves, tassels (≈ 50% stalk/50% other) • What is that value? Depends on what you get out of the field

  14. Removal Rates • Amount of stover/A = 5,000 lbs/A • 50% stalk/50% leaves, husks, tassel • 75% stalk/25% leaves, husks, tassel • What is that value? Depends on what you get and what ratio you get out of the field

  15. Cattle • Better than a snowball? • What they need (Energy and protein) • Supplement with protein, vitamins, and minerals • What they get from stover? • How much do they utilize from a bale? • How much is lost due to storage? • How much does alternate feed cost?

  16. Corn Stover - Baling • Do you bale or mow then bale? • Mow = more biomass, more diesel, better bales • Bale = less biomass, less diesel, poorer bales • If baled stover is stored outside expect losses • Greater losses than grass hay • More nutrient losses • When feeding expect losses and a mess • Cattle will selectively “pick” and leave stalks

  17. How Does Drought Influence? • Insufficient water means less growth of: • Pasture/hay/corn • Less pasture/hay = less grazing and more supplemental feeds • Less corn = less stover but higher concentrations of nutrients (e.g. K and nitrates) • Less water probably means more nitrates in stover = more management

  18. Nitrate Poisoning • Leaf area destroyed and cannot convert nitrates into proteins by photosynthesis and are concentrated in stems and stalks • Most nitrates are found closer to the ground, bottom 1/3 of stalk contains the most • Die of oxygen shortage; hemoglobin not able to carry oxygen

  19. Potassium Levels • In dry year, little K leaching from stover so greater K removed from field • High levels of K interfere with Mg uptake • High K, low Mg = grass tetany

  20. Grazing vs. baling • Nutrient removal • Equipment (baler vs hot wire) • Hassle • Feed costs

  21. Grazing Issues • Compaction/mud? • Cost of fencing • Transportation cost • Keeping cattle in fence

  22. Alternatives • Buying Hay $?/roll • Buying Feed $?/ton • Selling Cattle – Good time to cull

  23. Summary • “Free Stalks” are not free • Cost to grain producer (N,P,K, other) • Cost to cattle producer (baling, supplements) • Cost to cattle (low quality feed) • What is value of stalks and supplement • Considerable waste in feeding • Be aware of other issues, (nitrate, K) • What to do? Weigh options closely

  24. Questions ?

More Related