1 / 22

Social psychiatry – new directions The way forward?

Social psychiatry – new directions The way forward?. Prof. Stefan Priebe Queen Mary, University of London. Social Psychiatry. Social: everything that happens between people

hamal
Download Presentation

Social psychiatry – new directions The way forward?

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Social psychiatry – new directionsThe way forward? Prof. Stefan Priebe Queen Mary, University of London

  2. Social Psychiatry • Social: everything that happens between people • A social perspective of mental health and mental disorders: a) A societal movementb) A form of practicec) A field of research

  3. Social factors in mental health • Social inequality • Poverty • Unemployment • Social isolation • War

  4. Psychiatry in crisis? • Problems with recruitment • Complaints about burn out and stigmatisation • Calls for - stronger medical orientation, - focus on neuro-biological knowledge, and - emphasis on research basis • Consistent for about 150 years

  5. Progress in last 30 years • More staff for more patients • Better qualified staff (e.g. clinical psychologists) • Better facilities • More attention in society • More investment

  6. Why? • Different attitude to health and mental health in society • Mental health reforms • Linked to values • More dignified care for people with severe mental disorders • Threatened with profit orientation of provider organisations and social inequality

  7. Contribution of research discoveries • Billions of investment worldwide • Decade of the brain (1990s) • But: • No new and more effective drugs • Hardly any new psychotherapeutic school • No new social interventions • No new service types

  8. Treatment of severe mental illness • No advantage of new antipsychotics • Antidepressants effective only in severe depression • Hardly any difference between drugs • Hardly any difference between psychological treatments • Limited effect sizes • Hardly any predictors for individual treatment response

  9. Cochrane: CBT in schizophrenia • 2000: For those with schizophrenia …. access to CBT is associated with a substantially reduced risk of relapse • 2004: Trial based data supporting the wide use of CBT for people with schizophrenia are far from conclusive. • 2011: Trial based evidence suggests no clear and convincing advantagefor CBT over much less sophisticated therapies for schizophrenia

  10. Methods • Similar types of psychometric scales (some even identical) • Randomised controlled trials as gold standard for evaluating treatments • Systematic reviews and meta-analysis for reaching consensus

  11. Why no progress? (I) • Rules of academic success • Opportunism and short term planning • Drive towards mainstream and fashion –search for external funding, impact factor points and citations; peer review process • Yet, the same rules across medicine

  12. Why no progress? (II) • The paradigm • Disorders are based on operationalised criteria, detached from biography and context • Concept of fundamental research leading to application

  13. Paradigm Real cause Expression Consequence Social - relationship- social function Psychological - experience - symptoms Neuro-biological - genetic disposition - physiological processes Social management Psychological modification Real treatment

  14. Mental disorders as social phenomena • Defined in social interactions, e.g. cultural and societal norms • Occurring in interactions • Related to interactions • Diagnosed in interactions • Treated in interactions

  15. Alternative paradigm of mental disorder Psychological Societal Neuro- biological Social phenomenon

  16. New directions – research (I) • Assessment of interactions in natural relationships, e.g. families • Assessments of interactions in therapeutic groups • Assessment of ‘real life ‘, e.g. for evaluating interventions

  17. New directions – research (II) • Analysis of therapeutic interactions and their role in social context of the patient • Exploring the potentials of new communication technologies for patients social life and for novel treatments • Understanding of non-specific treatment effects

  18. Non-specific effects? TAU or placebo Non-specific or placebo effect symptom levels real treatment treatment effect baseline end of treatment

  19. New directions - practice • Focus on social roles, friendships, societal purpose • Generic socio-therapeutic approaches, e.g. therapeutic communities • Specific socio-therapeutic approaches, e.g. groups using creative activities and body experiences • Emphasis on therapeutic relationship and communication

  20. Individual vs social solutions • Very active children have ADHD and receive medication • Old people with cognitive decline have beginning dementia and receive memory training or medication • Playing with children may stem cognitive decline in old people and help children and increase social cohesion/capital

  21. New directions – concepts • Facilitating improvement in a social context instead of ‘treating’ a patient or a disorder • Resource orientated models of interventions • Considering the role of societal role of psychiatry and psychiatrists • Implications for concepts of neurobiological and psychological dimensions of psychiatry

  22. The way forward? • Different definitions of fundamental and applied research • New perspective in research with unclear outcomes • Focus on psychiatrists as agents in a societal context • Profession based on skills and competence as much as on knowledge • More fascinating job and more impact

More Related