Effective field theory and heavy quark physics
This presentation is the property of its rightful owner.
Sponsored Links
1 / 36

Effective Field Theory and Heavy Quark Physics PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 108 Views
  • Uploaded on
  • Presentation posted in: General

Effective Field Theory and Heavy Quark Physics. Matthias Neubert Cornell University. Sheldon Fest – May 20-21, 2006. Being with Sheldon is fun!. Being with Sheldon is fun!. Penguins are dangerous…. 25+ Years of Heavy-Flavor Physics. Have shared excitement of discovery.

Download Presentation

Effective Field Theory and Heavy Quark Physics

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript


Effective field theory and heavy quark physics

Effective Field Theory and Heavy Quark Physics

Matthias Neubert

Cornell University

Sheldon Fest – May 20-21, 2006


Being with sheldon is fun

Being with Sheldon is fun!


Being with sheldon is fun1

Being with Sheldon is fun!


Penguins are dangerous

Penguins are dangerous…


25 years of heavy flavor physics

25+ Years of Heavy-Flavor Physics

  • Have shared excitement of discovery


25 years of heavy flavor physics1

25+ Years of Heavy-Flavor Physics

  • Many discoveries:

    • Bound states containing heavy quarks

    • Oscillations of neutral B mesons

    • Flavor-changing transitions between the 3rd and 1st generations (t→d, b→u)

    • Penguin-mediated decays (B→Xsγ)

    • CP violation in B mixing and decays


25 years of heavy flavor physics2

25+ Years of Heavy-Flavor Physics

  • Precision physics:

    • CKM elements (|Vcb| at 1.7%, |Vub| at 7%)

    • Quark masses (mb at 1.2%)

    • Fundamental nonperturbative parameters (Λ, μπ2, Isgur-Wise function, shape function, …)


25 years of heavy flavor physics3

25+ Years of Heavy-Flavor Physics

  • Implications for physics beyond the Standard Model

    • Scales probed in flavor physics extend far beyond the reach of high-energy colliders (few - 103 TeV)

    • New physics must be heavier than we’d like it to be, or it must be hidden very well

    • Minimal flavor violation (and extensions thereof)

    • In my view, flavor physics is one of the strongest arguments against low-scale SUSY


Role of effective field theory

Role of Effective Field Theory

  • Exploit that heavy-quark systems are always characterized by (at least) two largely different scales:

  • Systematically separate short-distance physics (perturbative) from long-distance hadronic physics (nonperturbative)

mb» ΛQCD


Role of effective field theory1

Role of Effective Field Theory

  • Main concept:

    • 2 expansion parameters:

      and

perturbative

nonperturbative


Role of effective field theory2

Role of Effective Field Theory

  • Early days:

    • Cn at tree-level or one-loop order

    • Leading terms and 1/mb corrections

  • State of the art:

    • Cn at two- or three-loop order

    • Include 1/mb2 or even 1/mb3 corrections


Role of effective field theory3

Role of Effective Field Theory

  • Scale separation

    • Lets us compute all perturbative effects

    • Often simplifies residual nonperturbative interactions:

      • Reduced matrix elements (Isgur-Wise functions, shape functions, heavy-quark parameters)

      • Universality of hadronic physics (process independence)

      • Applicability of lattice QCD


Effective field theories for heavy quark systems

Effective Field Theories for Heavy-Quark Systems

  • Nonrelativistic QCD (NRQCD)

    • bound states containing two heavy quarks (quarkonia, Bc, but also B physics on the lattice)

  • Heavy-quark effective theory (HQET)

    • bound states containing a single heavy quark (B physics at low recoil)

  • Soft-collinear effective theory (SCET)

    • processes containing soft and energetic partons, including heavy quarks (processes at large recoil)


Effective field theories for heavy quark systems1

Effective Field Theories for Heavy-Quark Systems

  • Roots of these concepts are rather old

    • NRQCD a sibbling of NRQED (studied in 1980s)

    • HQET based on symmetry arguments first written down in 1980

    • SCET based on eikonal approximation familiar from soft bremsstrahlung in classical electro-dynamics


Symmetries and eft

Symmetries and EFT

  • Many EFTs for heavy-quark systems are built on concept of symmetries, which simplify the dynamics

  • Technically, they result from simplifications of QCD Feynman rules (propagators and vertices) in certain limits, e.g.:

= igstavμ

= igstanμ

[see, e.g., G. Sterman, Nucl. Phys. B 281 (1987) 310]


Symmetries and eft1

Symmetries and EFT

  • Absence of Dirac γμmatrices gives rise to spin symmetries of HQET and SCET

  • Independence of hard scales mb, E (after scale separation) can be interpreted as a heavy-flavor symmetry (HQET), or large-recoil symmetry, boost symmetry, scaling (SCET)


Symmetries and eft2

Symmetries and EFT

  • E. Shuryak, Phys. Lett. B 93 (1980) 134:

    94 citations

    “The masses of light (u,d,s) quarks are rather different, but still there is an approximate SU(3) and a more accurate isotopic SU(2) symmetry on their substitution. The reason for this is that these masses are too small to be important. Something similar occurs for heavy quarks (c,b,…), because their masses are too large on the usual hadronic scale. So, some symmetry for their substitution should exist between 0- and 1- mesons, Σ- and Λ-type baryons etc.”


Symmetries and eft3

Symmetries and EFT

  • E. Shuryak, Nucl. Phys. B 198 (1982) 83:

    290 citations

    “In this limit hadrons with one heavy quark resemble the hydrogen atom with its fixed center, and many problems of current models of hadronic structure … are made trivial. Mesons made of one very heavy and one light quark are, in some sense, the simplest hadrons in which non-trivial QCD dynamics is essential, so study of them is of great importance. Of course, mesons made out of two very heavy quarks are simpler, but they are next to trivial.”


Symmetries and eft4

Symmetries and EFT

  • N. Isgur and M.B. Wise, Phys. Lett. B 237 (1990) 527:

    1387 citations

    “The new symmetries allow us to obtain absolutely normalized model-independent predictions in the heavy-quark limit of all the form factors for the Q1→Q2 induced weak pseudoscalar to pseudoscalar and pseudoscalar to vector transitions in terms of a single universal function ξ(t) with ξ(0)=1.”


Symmetries and eft5

Symmetry relations and normalization of Isgur-Wise function can be used to extract |Vcb|

Symmetries and EFT

[MN, Phys. Lett. B 264 (1991) 455]


Symmetries and eft6

Symmetries and EFT

  • Heavy-quark symmetries have many important ramifications in phenomenology

  • In particular:

    • Exclusive |Vcb| determination (spin-symmetry relations among different B→D* form factors)

    • Form-factor relations for heavy-to-light transitions such as B→π,ρ and D→ π,ρ (flavor symmetry), which may help for exclusive |Vub| determination


Symmetries and eft7

Symmetries and EFT

  • In spectroscopy, find relations between level spacings in bottom and charm systems

  • E.g.:

    • mB*2-mB2≈ 0.49 GeV2 vs. mD*2-mD2≈ 0.55 GeV2

    • mB2*2-mB12≈ mD2*2-mD12 ≈ 0.17 GeV2

    • mBs-mB≈ mDs-mD ≈ 0.10 GeV

    • and many more …


Recent applications i factorization in hadronic b decays

Recent Applications: I. Factorization in Hadronic B Decays

  • QCD factorization approach achieves scale separation at leading power in 1/mb for a large class of exclusive hadronic B decays (alternative: pQCD approach)

  • Decay amplitudes predicted model-independently, including their normalization and strong-interaction phases

[Beneke, Buchalla, MN, Sachrajda (1999); Keum, Li, Sanda (2000)]


Recent applications i factorization in hadronic b decays1

Recent Applications: I. Factorization in Hadronic B Decays

  • In language of effective field theory, this is accomplished by matching QCD amplitudes onto matrix elements in SCET

[Bauer, Pirjol, Stewart (2000)]

QCD → SCETI → SCETII (HQET)


Recent applications i factorization in hadronic b decays2

Extraction of γ:

B→PV modes have smaller penguins than B→PP modes

Smaller uncertainties when γ is extracted from time-dependent rates in B→πρ decays

Result:

B→πρ

Old data

New data

B→ ππ

Old data

γ= (62 ± 8)o

New data

Recent Applications: I. Factorization in Hadronic B Decays

[Beneke, MN (2003)]


Applications ii factorization in inclusive b decays

At leading power in ΛQCD/mb, the B→Xsγ decay rate factorizes into a convolution of three objects:

Applications: II. Factorization in Inclusive B Decays

[MN (1993); Bigi, Shifman, Uraltsev (1993); Korchemsky, Sterman (1994)]


Applications ii factorization in inclusive b decays1

Applications: II. Factorization in Inclusive B Decays

  • Master formula for the partial rate:

Γ ~ H(μh) * U(μh,μi) * J(μi) * U(μi,μ0) * M(μ0)

QCD → SCET → RG evolution → HQET → RG evolution → Local OPE

μh ~ mb

μi ~√mbΔ

μ0 ~ Δ=mb-2E0

Perturbation theory

Hadronic physics


Applications ii factorization in inclusive b decays2

Applications: II. Factorization in Inclusive B Decays

  • Master formula for the partial rate:

[MN (2004)]

μh ~ mb

μi ~√mbΔ

μ0 ~ Δ=mb-2E0

Perturbation theory

Hadronic physics


Applications ii factorization in inclusive b decays3

Applications: II. Factorization in Inclusive B Decays

  • After resummation, largest uncertainties are probed by variations of the low scale μ0~Δ≈1 GeV:

NLO

[Becher, MN (in preparation)]

NNLO

F(1.8 GeV) / default

μ0/Δ


Applications iii factorization in collider physics

Applications: III. Factorization in Collider Physics

  • Generic problem in QCD:

    • Resummation for processes with multiple scales

    • Interplay of soft and collinear emissions → Sudakov double logarithms

    • Jet physics: MX2 « Q2

      • Soft: low momentum pμ→0

      • Collinear: p || pX with p2→0

    • Examples: DIS, fragmentation, Drell-Yan, Higgs production, event shapes, inclusive B decays, …

MX


Applications iii factorization in collider physics1

Applications: III. Factorization in Collider Physics

  • QCD factorization formula for DIS (x→1):

    • Most transparent to derive this in SCET: need hard-collinear,anti-collinear, and soft-collinear modes (called “soft” in the literature)

    • Resum threshold logarithms by solving RGEs of SCET in momentum space

[Manohar (2003); Becher, MN, Pecjak (in preparation)]


Applications iii factorization in collider physics2

Applications: III. Factorization in Collider Physics

  • Exact momentum-space formula for resummed structure function F2(x,Q2):

    • Vastly simpler than existing results

    • Free of spurious Landau poles

[Becher, MN (2006)]


Final remarks

Final Remarks

  • We love heavy-quark physics because …

    • it probes a sector of particle physics hiding great mysteries

    • over the past 25 years, it has offered us lots of real data

    • it has been characterized by close collaborations between experimenters and theorists

    • theoretical work is crucial to experimental success


Final remarks1

Final Remarks

  • Look forward to continuing these studies in LHC era, when particle physics moves back to Europe

  • Sheldon will continue to be part on it …


And he will continue to enjoy it

… and he will continue to enjoy it!

LHCb week in Barcelona (September 2005)


  • Login