The tort of defamation l.jpg
Advertisement
This presentation is the property of its rightful owner.
1 / 110

Dfssdf PowerPoint PPT Presentation

ffsadfafsfsd fas asdf

Download Presentation

dfssdf

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript


The tort of defamation l.jpg

The tort of Defamation

Libel and Slander

Chapter 4-5-6


Definition of civil libel l.jpg

Definition of civil libel

Written or printed expression

that tends to damage a person’s standing in the community through words that attack an individual’s character and professional abilities


Tort of defamation l.jpg

Tort of Defamation

  • Libel-published or broadcast defamation

  • Slander-spoken defamation


Kinds of libel l.jpg

Kinds of Libel

  • Civil

  • Criminal


Kinds of libel5 l.jpg

Kinds of Libel

  • Civil: lawsuits for harming reputation

  • Criminal: laws for criticizing government in times of war (rare these days)


Elements of libel l.jpg

Elements of Libel

  • Defamation

  • Identification

  • Publication

  • Falsity/fault


Civil libel slander cases involve l.jpg

Civil Libel & Slander cases involve:

  • Judge

  • Plaintiff

  • Defendant

  • Jury


Can the government sue for libel l.jpg

Can the government sue for Libel?

No!

Chicago v. Tribune Co.

1923


Can the government sue for libel9 l.jpg

Can the government sue for Libel?

But, individual members of government can but they have a hard time winning!


Who can be libeled l.jpg

Who can be libeled?

  • Person? Yes

  • Charity? Yes

  • The Government? No

  • Corporation? Yes

  • Club or group? Yes


Definition of criminal libel l.jpg

Definition of criminal libel

An inflammatory or seditious statement about the government or a government official which might incite rebellion.


Criminal libel l.jpg

Criminal libel

a.k.a. Seditious Libel


Criminal libel13 l.jpg

Criminal Libel

  • Judge

  • State

  • Defendant

  • Jury


Civil libel plaintiff s burden of proof l.jpg

Civil libel:Plaintiff’s Burden of Proof

  • Publication

  • Identification

  • Defamation

  • Falsity

  • Fault


Publication means material was sent in any of the following l.jpg

Publication means material was sent in any of the following :

  • The Print Media

  • Broadcast Media

  • Internet

  • Newsletters


Publication presumes l.jpg

“Publication” presumes:

  • that a “third party” heard/saw/read the defamatory material


Identification l.jpg

Identification:

  • Mistaken Identity is often cause of libel suits against mass media outlets


Identification18 l.jpg

Identification:

  • Person does not have to be identified by “name”...it could be a picture, or they could be identified by a widely known nickname


Group identification l.jpg

Group Identification:

  • No magic number exists to protect media from claim of “identification” when defaming entire groups of people…but


Group identification20 l.jpg

Group Identification:

  • The larger the group the harder it is for them to win a libel suit


Group identification21 l.jpg

Group Identification:

  • So, be especially careful with small groups because it is easier to prove “identification”


Falsity l.jpg

Falsity:

  • “Small errors are usually not actionable” unless…


Falsity23 l.jpg

Falsity:

  • they directly relate to the loss of reputation (defamation).


These can be libelous l.jpg

These can be libelous:

  • Newspapers

  • Broadcasting

  • Photographs

  • Cartoons

  • Paintings


These can also be libelous l.jpg

These can also be libelous:

  • Sculpture

  • Graffiti

  • Effigies

  • Advertising

  • Billboards


Examples of defamatory comment l.jpg

Crime: reporting that someone is a murderer when they have only been charged with the crime.

Occupation: “Dr. Jones is a quack.”

Examples of Defamatory Comment


Defamatory comment l.jpg

Business: “Jones Auto Mart is a rip-off.”

Trade libel: “Tobacco companies are murderers.”

Defamatory Comment


The complexities of fault l.jpg

“Fault” is defined differently depending on whether it the plaintiff is a private or public person

The complexities of “Fault”


Some kinds of public persons l.jpg

All purpose public persons (George Bush)

Limited (President Hoops of USI)

Some kinds of public persons:


Other kinds of public persons l.jpg

Famous entertainers and Athletes (especially pro athletes)

Other kinds of public persons:


New york times v sullivan 1964 l.jpg

made it harder for public persons to win a libel suit…read about NY Times v. Sullivan in both your textbooks!

NEW YORK TIMES v. SULLIVAN (1964):


Cases that clarified new york times v sullivan 1964 l.jpg

Curtis Publishing Co. v Butts (1967) clarified “reckless disregard”

Cases that clarified NEW YORK TIMES v. SULLIVAN (1964):


Curtis publishing co v butts l.jpg

Found that circumstances of reporting including the time element involved in checking facts are important in determining reckless disregard

Curtis Publishing Co. v. Butts:


Associated press v walker 1967 l.jpg

The court said an honest mistake made in a “hot news situation” involving a public figure is NOT reckless disregard for the truth.

Associated Press v. Walker (1967):


Gertz v welch 1974 l.jpg

Gertz claimed he was not a “public figure” so he had only to prove “negligence” not NY Times Malice

Gertz v. Welch (1974):


Gertz v welch 197436 l.jpg

Established the principal that media must be guilty of something beyond a mere falsehood…there had to be a finding of “fault”

Gertz v. Welch (1974):


Remember l.jpg

everyone must prove falsity and fault…but public persons must also prove NYT Malice

REMEMBER:


Remember38 l.jpg

Fault for private person cases is to show “negligence” on the part of the media

REMEMBER:


Remember39 l.jpg

Fault for public figure cases is to show reckless disregard for the truth or that the media published something they knew was untrue (New York Times Actual Malice)

REMEMBER:


Some famous libel cases l.jpg

Cherry Sisters v. Des Moines Leader (1901)

Victory for the right to criticize public performers/performances

Some Famous Libel Cases:


Some famous libel cases41 l.jpg

Carol Burnett v. National Inquirer (1983)

Called her “drunk and rude.” She was awarded $150,000

Some Famous Libel Cases:


Some famous libel cases42 l.jpg

Gen. Westmoreland v. CBS (1984) Deceived the public about Viet Nam?

He sued for $120 million but settled for an apology from CBS ($18-million spent on legal fees)

Some Famous Libel Cases:


Some famous libel cases43 l.jpg

Wayne Newton v. NBC (1990) Mafia ties?

He sued for $5.3 million. He won, but no damages were awarded as it was reversed on appeal.

Some Famous Libel Cases:


Chapter six l.jpg

Libel: Defenses and Damages

Chapter Six:


Defenses against libel l.jpg

Defenses against libel

  • Truth

  • Opinion

  • Privilege

  • Statutes of limitation

  • Consent


Truth as a defense l.jpg

Truth as a defense

  • Normally absolute

  • No time limitations


Opinion as a defense l.jpg

Opinion as a defense

  • Not provably false

  • Figurative language

  • Fair comment


Ollman test l.jpg

OLLMAN TEST

  • Can statement be proved true or false?

  • What is the common meaning of the words?


Ollman test49 l.jpg

OLLMAN TEST

  • What is the journalistic context of the remark?

  • What is the social context of the remark?


Privilege as a defense two types l.jpg

Privilege as a defense: Two types

  • Absolute Privilege

  • Qualified Privilege


Absolute privilege l.jpg

Absolute Privilege:

protects:

  • Government Officials doing their jobs

  • Persons speaking in a legislative or judicial forum


Qualified privilege l.jpg

Qualified Privilege

Protects media when reporting information from a privileged proceeding (court hearing, official meeting, or official document)


Slide53 l.jpg

BUT:

The Report must be fair and accurate to come under qualified privilege protection


Statute of limitations as a defense in a libel suit l.jpg

Statute of Limitations as a defense in a libel suit:

Usually one or two years…two years in Indiana, one year in Illinois and Kentucky


Summary judgment l.jpg

Summary Judgment:

Usually in favor of mass media defendants…


Summary judgment56 l.jpg

Summary Judgment:

Unless the summary judgment is appealed and reversed…there is no trial


What happens l.jpg

What happens

if you lose a libel suit?


If you lose the libel suit l.jpg

If you lose the libel suit:

  • You may have to pay damages


Know the kinds of damages l.jpg

Know the kinds of damages:

  • Actual

  • Special

  • Presumed

  • Punitive


Actual damages l.jpg

Actual Damages:

  • Based on money loss, loss of reputation, pain and suffering, reputation damage etc.


Special damages l.jpg

Special Damages:

  • Usually sought in trade libel cases


Presumed damages l.jpg

Presumed Damages:

  • Usually sought in cases involving a public concern


Punitive damages l.jpg

Punitive Damages:

  • To punish defendants for their actions and to make an example out of them…often BIG BUCKS!


Plaintiff cannot win libel suit if l.jpg

Plaintiff cannot win libel suit if:

  • They gave consent to publication of libelous material


How to prevent getting sued for libel l.jpg

How to prevent getting sued for libel:

  • Handle complaints properly

  • Retractions “may” help

  • Ombudsmen to “smooth things over”


General tips on how to prevent getting sued for libel l.jpg

General tips on: How to prevent getting sued for libel:

  • Handle complaints properly

  • Retractions “may” help

  • Ombudsmen to “smooth things over”


5 goals of libel law l.jpg

5 Goals of Libel Law:

  • Monetary damages for the plaintiff

  • Restoring reputation

  • Make for greater responsibility for speakers


5 goals of libel law68 l.jpg

5 Goals of Libel Law:

  • Punish defamatory speakers

  • To force media to seek the truth


Specific tips on how to avoid libel suits l.jpg

Specific tips on how to avoid Libel Suits

  • Check sources

  • Verify, even if subject is public figure or official

  • Understand criminal procedure and terminology


How to avoid libel suits l.jpg

How to avoid Libel Suits

  • Be cautious when editing

  • Watch for defamatory headlines or promos


How to avoid libel suits71 l.jpg

How to avoid Libel Suits

  • Don’t use generic file footage or photos when reporting on an activity that might be questionable


How to avoid libel suits72 l.jpg

How to avoid Libel Suits

  • Be cautious about defamatory statements made on the air or in letters to the editor


How to avoid libel suits73 l.jpg

How to avoid Libel Suits

  • Be cautious about words connoting dishonest behavior or immorality


How to avoid libel suits74 l.jpg

How to avoid Libel Suits

  • Don’t put anything in your notes that you would not want a court to see


How to avoid libel suits75 l.jpg

How to avoid Libel Suits

  • Remember “allegedly” may not save you from a finding of libel

  • “She allegedly has AIDS” is legally the same as “She has AIDS.”


How to avoid libel suits76 l.jpg

How to avoid Libel Suits

  • Watch how you use attribution.

  • “Police say they have arrested Joe Smith for arson.” (presumes guilt)

  • “Police have charged Joe Smith with arson.” (better)


How to avoid libel suits77 l.jpg

How to avoid Libel Suits

  • Off the record attribution is dangerous in crime coverage.

  • Don’t take anyone’s word for it…check the written record


How to avoid libel suits78 l.jpg

How to avoid Libel Suits

  • Unofficial court documents lacking privilege can be a problem

  • Don’t let yourself be used. Some allegations are false. Report them when the suit is filed, not before.


If confronted by someone threatening a libel suit l.jpg

If confronted by someone threatening a libel suit:

  • Be polite

  • Don’t admit error


If confronted by someone threatening a libel suit80 l.jpg

If confronted by someone threatening a libel suit:

  • Talk to supervisor or your attorney immediately and follow procedures established by your place of employment


The tort of defamation81 l.jpg

The tort of Defamation

Libel

Quick Review


Libel occurs l.jpg

Libel occurs:

When a false and defamatory statement about an identifiable person is published/broadcast to a third party, causing injury to the subject’s reputation.


Civil libel plaintiff s burden of proof83 l.jpg

Civil libel:Plaintiff’s burden of proof:

  • Publication

  • Identification

  • Defamation

  • Fault/Falsity


Publication l.jpg

Publication:

  • Defamatory information is communicated by print or electronic media to someone other than the person defamed


Publication85 l.jpg

Publication:

  • Internet service providers not responsible for libelous information unless they exercise editorial control over content.


Identification86 l.jpg

Identification:

  • Defamatory material must be “of and concerning” the plaintiff or there is no case.


Group identification87 l.jpg

Group Identification:

  • No magic number exists to protect media from claim of “identification”


Group identification88 l.jpg

Group Identification:

  • Be especially careful with small groups because it is easier to prove “identification”


Falsity89 l.jpg

Falsity:

  • “Small errors usually not actionable” unless…


Falsity90 l.jpg

Falsity:

  • they directly relate to the loss of reputation (defamation).


Falsity91 l.jpg

Falsity:

  • in other words, information must be substantially true…absolute accuracy not required


Falsity92 l.jpg

Falsity:

  • Public figures and public officials must always prove “information was false”


Falsity93 l.jpg

Falsity:

  • Private figures must prove “information was false” if information was “a matter of public concern”


Falsity94 l.jpg

Falsity:

  • Media must prove information was TRUE with Private figures when information was “NOT a matter of public concern”


Defamatory comment95 l.jpg

Harm to reputation must be proved by the plaintiff…sometimes a monetary loss is claimed

Defamatory Comment


Most damages awarded l.jpg

Are punitive…to punish the media and to send a cautionary message to other media outlets

Most damages awarded:


The complexities of fault97 l.jpg

Remember: “Fault” is defined differently depending on whether the plaintiff is a private or public person

The complexities of “Fault”


Public persons include l.jpg

Elected officials

Appointed officials who effect policy

Celebrities

Public persons include:


The person is not automatically a public person l.jpg

Just because they have been accused of a crime

The person is not automatically a “Public Person”


The person is not automatically a public figure l.jpg

Just because they are well known

“Everybody around here knows farmer brown” does not make him a public figure

The person is not automatically a “Public figure”


Fault for private person plaintiffs l.jpg

Plaintiff must prove negligence (failure to exercise reasonable care)

“Fault” for private person plaintiffs:


Fault for public person plaintiffs l.jpg

Actual Malice (New York Times Malice) knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard for the truth

“Fault” for public person plaintiffs:


To win a libel suit public persons l.jpg

Must prove “New York Times Malice” with “clear and convincing evidence”

To win a libel suit public persons:


New york times v sullivan 1964104 l.jpg

made it harder for public persons to win a libel suit

NEW YORK TIMES v. SULLIVAN (1964):


Remember105 l.jpg

everyone must prove falsity…but public persons must also prove NYT Malice

REMEMBER:


Defenses against libel106 l.jpg

Defenses against libel

  • Truth

  • Opinion

  • Privilege

  • Statutes of limitation

  • Consent


Remember107 l.jpg

Remember:

  • Qualified privilege (if report is fair and accurate)

  • Consent (unless they are minors or wards of the state)

  • Fair Comment and Opinion (unless presented as fact and is false)


Truth as a defense108 l.jpg

Truth as a defense

  • Normally absolute

  • No time limitations


Privilege as a defense l.jpg

Privilege as a defense

  • Absolute Privilege

  • Qualified Privilege


Statute of limitations as a defense in a libel suit110 l.jpg

Statute of Limitations as a defense in a libel suit:

Usually one or two years…two years in Indiana, one year in Illinois and Kentucky


  • Login