1 / 24

The Universal Declaration of Human rights

The Universal Declaration of Human rights. Yunxi Wang, Annekatrin Nagel. Overview of the Drafting Process. Overview of the Drafting Process. Overview of the Drafting Process. Overview of the Drafting Process. Draft process proceeded rapidly:

gail
Download Presentation

The Universal Declaration of Human rights

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. The Universal Declaration of Human rights Yunxi Wang, Annekatrin Nagel

  2. Overview of the Drafting Process

  3. Overview of theDraftingProcess

  4. Overview of theDraftingProcess

  5. Overview of theDraftingProcess • Draft process proceeded rapidly: • Advantage of the UDHR laying out moral principles and not binding law Discussion focused mainly on word choice and minor changes. • Mrs. Roosevelt's skillful bureaucratic operation

  6. The First Drafts of the Declaration

  7. The First Drafts of the Declaration:John Humphrey’s Draft Outline • Framework of western liberalism incorporating a range of social and economic rights • Rights with legal details implying level of enforcement > rather convention than declaration • Individual protected against state • Right to petition • Critique: Vladimir Koretsky (Representative of the Soviet Union)

  8. The First Drafts of the Declaration:Cassin’s Draft • Kept many of the articles of Humphrey’s Outline • still intended to support implementation although not specific on the mechanisms Next 12 month his draft was discussed and revised: - text shortened - character changed from articles (legal character) to principles

  9. UNESCO interlude

  10. The UNESCO Interlude • 1947 UNESCO project on the issue of Universal Human Rights was started (scholars and cultural theorists from all over the world wrote on the issue) • Complicated Issues such as fundamental differences in the conception of rights and the relationship of individual and state, etc. • The work was completely disregarded and remained unmentioned in the drafting process because of the bureaucratic issue that there was no prior information to the CHR

  11. Some Participants • E.H. Carr, Aldous Huxley • Jacques Maritain • Mohandas Gandhi, HumayunKabir • Benedetto Croce • Richard McKeon, Quincy Wright • Chung-Shu Lo

  12. Negotiating the controversial articles

  13. Negotiating the controversial articles • 1 right to rebellion some countries supported because they attained independence through its exercise BUT ! Britain: feared that it would provide legitimacy to armed insurrection in the colonies US: the respect for human rights obviated the need for revolution

  14. Negotiating the controversial articles • 2 universal basis of human rights What is the original source of these inherent values. Nature? God? > Issue Remained unsolved. • 3 from men to human beings The idea “woman” seems excluded, so became human beings. The item “brotherhood” as well

  15. Negotiating the controversial articles • 4 minority right are not recognized Because of sensitive domestic matters • 5 death penalty Soviet Union PUSH US EU deny, blaming Soviet Union’s hypocrisy • 6 right to social security or justice or insurance

  16. Debating the hierarchy in universal right

  17. Debating the hierarchy in universal right • Whether include economic, social, cultural rights U.S and Britain: not include them but they did not win the debate • Relationship between economic, social, cultural rights and western civil and political right

  18. Abstentions to the universal declaration

  19. Abstentions to the universal declaration • South Africa’s quit: it’s apartheid regime a human rights pariah • Saudi Arabia: secular Eurocentric basis 1 their religious foundations 2 western imperialism

  20. Abstentions to the universal declaration • Soviet bloc: western ideological bias the interdependence between the citizen and the state Human right without state was “empty illusions” • However, UDHR affirmed that individual human rights are transcending national boundaries.

  21. Conclusion: searching for the universal in the declaration

  22. Conclusion: searching for the universal in the declaration • Cultural imperialism Vs. cultural relativism • US predominant influence English dominant • However, the most important obstacle is enforcement

  23. Conclusion: searching for the universal in the declaration • But, at last a positive tone? • “ The Declaration will develop its own implementation.”

  24. Questions?Thank you

More Related