1 / 11

Enforcement – Sharing the Experience 27 th May 2009

AGENDA ITEM - 4. Enforcement – Sharing the Experience 27 th May 2009 Alastair Gilchrist - PiP Management Committee Chairman Clive Burley - PiP Programme Manager. Enforcement – Sharing the Experience.

flann
Download Presentation

Enforcement – Sharing the Experience 27 th May 2009

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. AGENDA ITEM - 4 Enforcement – Sharing the Experience 27th May 2009 Alastair Gilchrist - PiP Management Committee Chairman Clive Burley - PiP Programme Manager

  2. Enforcement – Sharing the Experience • Seminar held on 27th May at City of London to explore current Enforcement procurements and contract issues. • 8 PiP Partners attended – Camden, City of London, Croydon, Enfield, Hackney, Lambeth, RBKC and WCC. • Camden, Ealing, Enfield, Newham, Wandsworth, WCC all procuring.

  3. Enforcement – Sharing the Experience Themes Explored • Supplier relationships • Current state of the market • Procurement strategies • Innovation & Efficiencies • PCN levels & CEO Roles • Future Developments

  4. Enforcement – Sharing the Experience Supplier Relationships • Variable, some good, some bad – even with same supplier. • No consistency by same supplier to different Boroughs. • Simple information not provided, failure to respond to information requests. • Failure to pay on KPIs/Defaults, legal action. • Suppliers have to be ‘micromanaged’ and pushed hard to get results. • PCN/CEO quality variable. • PCNs down – costs stay the same.

  5. Enforcement – Sharing the Experience Current State of the Market • The big three dominate - NSL, APCOA, Vinci. • Newcomers – Mouchel, Mitie. • Others – Town & City, Legion – niche markets. • Profit margins getting slimmer, little room for further efficiencies, large players have achieved economies of scale. • New entrants ‘double whammy’ – higher costs & no track record. • Efficiencies, pressure on wages, increased ‘churn’ with negative impact on PCN quality and overall costs. • KPIs hurt - contract relationships become combative. • PCN levels decreasing, approaching break even point.

  6. Enforcement – Sharing the Experience Procurement Strategies • Contract length varies between 5 and 12 years with extensions. • Standard two stage OJEU approach except WCC using ‘Competitive Dialogue’ for first time with output based approach. • Post TMA shift from PCN targets to Schedule of Rates call off. • Intelligent Deployment, Compliance based, KPI & Default heavy. • Takes two years to procure, ‘red tape’ increasing. • Procurement Units & Delivery Team tensions not helping. • Croydon ‘In House’, wants to link On Street with Back Office performance. • ‘In House’ too costly for most, no going back. • Varied bundled contracts for the most part. • BPA Model contract needs adapting – Hackney, RBKC & Camden.

  7. Enforcement – Sharing the Experience Innovation & Efficiencies • CEOs will TUPE over, only management will change, What are we investing in? Another supplier has to be better than the last one? • Labour supply contract. • Are there any fixed costs left to remove? • Little scope to innovate, scale economies already achieved. • Some increasing CCTV enforcement but not liked by some. • CCTV Head Cams - mixed views, costs & benefit needs working up. • ANPR possible but dependent on effective IT solution. • Annual contract reviews & efficiencies– RPIX, capped, negotiated, open book, profit share. • No year on year % reductions.

  8. Enforcement – Sharing the Experience PCN levels & CEO Roles • PCN levels falling – estimated 15% this year. Congestion Charge. • Some outer Boroughs increasing as develop more CPZs. • PCNs dropped post TMA, no targets. Micromanage CEO productivity. • Higher levels of suspensions, Bay reductions, Car Clubs. • Fair but Firm and Quality drivers. • Who is going to pay for enforcing Olympic Routes? • CEO roles increasing TMA+, Street as a single function. • Some Boroughs doing Street defects, Environmental reporting. • Concern over shift to soft issues not PCNs. Hasn’t worked for some. • Technology concerns about TMA+.

  9. Enforcement – Sharing the Experience Future Developments & Recurrent Issues • Sharing the Back Office, no out-sourcing, retain quality - RBKC & H&F. • Relocate Back Office but stay in-house – Islington. • ALMO type company – not progressed despite interest - WCC. • Greenwich Leisure – management buy out. • PiP Contract - differing needs, timelines and EU legal hurdles? • PCN/CEO quality + Firm But Fair reducing income versus need to maintain revenue streams. • CEO ‘Churn’, Limited market, Delivering quality. • Limited technology solutions, CCTV not for all.

  10. Enforcement – Sharing the Experience Recommendations • Supplier Relationship Management - Establish a NSL User Group as part of the PiP Management Committee to share experience, knowledge and develop common approaches to contract management. Develop capacity for concerted action. • People Dynamics – Progress study into Measuring the Work Related Well-Being Study of CEO Attrition & Absence (Agenda Item 5). • Contract Performance Measures – Initiate project to map Partner Enforcement contract KPIs and Defaults with a view to converge and streamline (Agenda Item 6).

  11. Any Questions?

More Related