National judicial institute judicial education
Download
1 / 55

National Judicial Institute Judicial Education - PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 126 Views
  • Uploaded on

NATIONAL JUDICIAL INSTITUTE ● INSTITUT NATIONAL DE LA MAGISTRATURE. National Judicial Institute Judicial Education. The honourable justice R. james williams. Supreme Court of Nova Scotia. World congress on Family law and children’s rights. March 18, Sydney, Australia.

loader
I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
capcha
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about ' National Judicial Institute Judicial Education' - ferdinand-joshua


An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript
National judicial institute judicial education

NATIONAL JUDICIAL INSTITUTE ●INSTITUT NATIONAL DE LA MAGISTRATURE

National Judicial InstituteJudicial Education

The honourable justice R. jameswilliams

Supreme Court of Nova Scotia

World congress on Family law and children’s rights

March 18, Sydney, Australia


Nji family law judicial education
NJI: Family Law Judicial Education

  • The context of Canadian Family Law

  • The National Judicial Institute

  • Our Audience: Judges

  • Adult Learning Principles Inform Judicial Education

  • Course Planning

  • Family Law Programs and Resources at NJI





Canadian family law
Canadian Family Law

  • 1 National Divorce Act

  • 10 provinces, 3 territories

    • Each has its own legislation concerning:

      Custody access if no divorce involved

      Property division (for marrieds, unmarrieds)

      Child protection

  • Some provinces have Unified Family Courts, some do not

    • Some judges hearing Family Law matters are specialists, some are not

  • Adversarial system… evolving


The national judicial institute
The National Judicial Institute

  • Independent NGO created in 1988

  • By and for judges

    • Board chaired by Chief Justice of Canada

    • Executive Director is a judge

    • Courses designed and presented by judges

  • Sole Canadian institute with exclusive judicial education mandate


Three dimensions of judicial education
Three Dimensions of Judicial Education

  • Knowledge

    • Substantive law – the law and its applications

  • Skills

    • Skills needed to perform the judicial role

  • Social context

    • Judging in a diverse society

  • … and an overarching ethical awareness


Basic teaching principles
Basic Teaching Principles

  • Judicial education should reflect the character and profile of the judiciary in Canada

  • Judicial education should implement adult learning principles

  • Every area of the curriculum should reflect the three dimensions of judicial education

    • Knowledge, skills, social context (and ethical awareness)


Our audience judges
Our Audience: Judges

  • What do they do?

  • What are their attributes?

  • What are their expectations?

  • What are their concerns?


Judges as learners what do judges do
Judges as Learners: What do Judges do?

  • Listen, Assess, and Filter

    • Receive evidence (filtering)

    • Assess credibility

    • Hear legal submissions

  • Speak (Verbal and non-verbal communication)

    • Managing the trial process and beyond

    • Communicating in the courtroom

    • Facilitating dispute resolution (settlement conferencing)

    • Oral judgments


  • Think (intellectual or cognitive skills)

    • Interpret and apply principles of law, procedure

    • Take into account context, exercise discretion

    • Synthesize information

  • Decide

    • Reach a decision (result)

    • Decide on the outcome (remedy)

  • Write

    • Convey decisions with reasons

    • Organize evidence, notes, affidavits in written judgments


Judges as learners attributes
Judges as Learners: Attributes

  • Motivated learners

    • Judging is an isolating job. Judicial education brings judges together to share experience

  • Skillful listeners

    • Accustomed to processing a great deal of information in a short time period

  • Concrete thinkers and problem solvers

    • Do not want “theory” for its own sake, material must be relevant, on point, and practical


Attributes ct d
Attributes (ct’d)

  • Like to be in control

  • Seek positive reinforcement

  • Used to giving advice rather than receiving it

    • People who have succeeded in their chosen profession

  • Skeptical by training, and by instinct

  • Tend to be impatient

  • Have a desire to succeed in tasks


Attributes ct d1
Attributes (ct’d)

  • Have a broad range of interests

  • Like to have fun

    • Sociability and stimulation important in learning environment

  • Reluctant to learn new things in new ways

    • Unless new method has demonstrated tangible results

  • Appreciative of good programs and exchanges

    • Will adopt new approaches if they work/meet their needs


Attributes ct d2
Attributes (ct’d)

  • Diversity of judges in Canadian context

    • Personal diversity, background, family, cultural, race, heritage, community

    • Work in both rural and urban settings

    • Work in regionally distinct areas

    • Work in (differing) multi-cultural contexts

    • Work in an ever-changing social environment


Judges as learners expectations
Judges as Learners: Expectations

  • Want to learn new, relevant, deeper and more engaging things

  • Want topics to relate directly to their work

  • Want to share experiences, to learn from other judges

  • Want faculty to be good presenters and have relevant and convincing experience

  • Want to learn how to make reasoned decisions more than finding the right answer


Judges as learners concerns
Judges as Learners: Concerns

  • Confidentiality and “safe learning space”

  • Judicial independence

  • Prescriptive approaches

    • Will resist “right answer” education, and will be careful about whom they listen and respect

  • Feedback

    • Adverse to criticism and not used to receiving feedback


Adult learning principles inform judicial education
Adult Learning Principles Inform Judicial Education


Adult learning principles
Adult Learning Principles

  • Connect learning to learner’s experiences

    • Link to what judges have done

    • Adults learn best when their experiences are valued

  • Contextualize learning experiences

    • Use learning activities that are close to judges’ realities (role-playing courtroom scenes, giving judgments)

  • Integrate various perspectives in learning activities

    • Encourage learners to be critical thinkers, and to explore and progress at their own pace


Adult learning principles ct d
Adult Learning Principles (ct’d)

  • Provide a “safe space” to learn

    • Judges should remain confident and in control of the learning process, even outside their normal comfort zones

    • Some sessions may need to be “judge-only”

  • Respect judicial authority

    • Frame education as enhancing knowledge and skills rather than “teaching” judges

    • Don’t purport to give the “right answers”

    • Judges lead and control presentation of education


Adult learning principles ct d1
Adult Learning Principles (ct’d)

  • Adult learning is facilitated when learners are actively involved

    • Use a variety of formats

    • Use a “learner-centred model” rather than a “teacher-centred model”

    • Create formats where learners “generate” the knowledge

    • Lectures should be short and tied to activities, rather than being the main event


Experiential learning
Experiential Learning

  • Judges learn better if learning is connected to a task they are required to perform

    • Judges learn to apply their knowledge and abilities in an appropriate environment

  • Learning activities are most effective when they incorporate the judge’s experiences

    • Retention of learning increases when learning is based in the judge’s own experience


I hear and i forget i see and i remember i do and i understand
“I hear and I forget. I see and I remember. I do and I understand.”

  • Confucious


Learning preferences
Learning Preferences

  • All adults have distinct styles and preferences for learning

  • This diversity in learning has to be recognized in the programming

  • Use a variety of learning activities to accommodate a mixture of learning styles



3 dimensions of judicial education
3 Dimensions of Judicial Education dimensions of judicial

  • Knowledge

  • Skills

  • Social context

    …(and ethical awareness)


Experiential learning1
Experiential Learning dimensions of judicial

  • Experiential learning encourages the development of skills and the understanding of social context while at the same conveying knowledge


Planning presenting the three pillars
Planning/Presenting dimensions of judicial The “Three Pillars”

  • A broadly representative group to enhance understanding of issues, quality of content and credibility

    • Judges

    • Academics/Researchers

    • Practitioners/Community-based experts

  • Under judicial leadership (judicial confidentiality being respected)


Course planning
Course Planning dimensions of judicial


Learning objectives
Learning Objectives dimensions of judicial

  • Distinguish from program aim, which describes overall purpose of program

  • Objectives are stepping stones to achieve the aim

    • Provide a framework for proper program development and evaluation

    • Help ensure facilitators and speakers understand their tasks

    • Allow participants to understand what particular knowledge, skills and attitudes they are expected to acquire or develop


Conceptualizing learning objectives
Conceptualizing Learning Objectives dimensions of judicial

  • What education needs will be addressed?

  • What will participants be able to do/do better?

  • What will participants take away from the session?


Accommodating different l earning s tyles
Accommodating Different dimensions of judicial Learning Styles

  • An educational program should include:

    • Ways to connect learners with their Experience (their own and others’)

    • Opportunities for Reflection

    • The necessary Knowledge

    • An opportunity to practice, Application


E r c a learning activities
E.R.C.A. – Learning activities dimensions of judicial

  • Experience

    • Short lecture, case study, remembering past experiences

  • Reflection

    • Panel or small group discussions, demonstrations, videos, brainstorming

  • Conceptualization/Knowledge

    • Lecture, analytical framework, checklist, flowchart, reference guides

  • Application

    • Practical problems, role play, group work


Example nji family law seminar
Example: NJI Family Law Seminar dimensions of judicial

  • Three-day seminar for judges who hear family-related cases

  • Topics alternate over three year cycle:

    • Year 1: Children

    • Year 2: Evidence and Procedure

    • Year 3: Financial and Property Issues


Family law seminar financial and property issues
Family Law Seminar: dimensions of judicial “Financial and Property Issues”

Program Topics:

  • Spousal and child support

  • Reproductive technology

  • Self-represented litigants

  • Marital assets

  • Imputing income


Practice session on reproductive technology
Practice dimensions of judicial Session on Reproductive Technology

  • Topic introduced (experience)

    • Short presentation on emergence of disputes over ownership of frozen embryos upon dissolution of marriage

  • Issue defined (reflect)

    • Is it possible for embryos to be considered marital assets?

  • Framework for problem-solving given (conceptualize)

    • Three approaches presented for resolving these disputes

  • Practice on scenario using framework (apply)

    • Hypothetical presented, and discussed in small groups


Family law seminar children
Family Law Seminar: dimensions of judicial Children

Program Topics:

  • Alienated children

  • Domestic violence, and custody and access

  • Attachment theory

  • Mobility

  • Children and settlement conferences

  • Grandparents, custody and access


Children in settlement conferences
Children in Settlement Conferences dimensions of judicial

  • Topic introduced (experience)

    • Children are central parties in family mediation but their voices are rarely heard

  • Issue defined (reflect)

    • How can judges work with children in settlement conferences and other dispute resolution processes?

  • Framework for problem-solving given (conceptualize)

    • Tips for talking to children provided

  • Practice on scenario using framework (apply)

    • Participants asked what approach they might take to the situation


Innovative a pproaches family law olympics
Innovative dimensions of judicial Approaches:Family Law Olympics

A Debate on Family Law Issues

  • Moderated by a judge

  • Panelists composed of four lawyers, divided by region (East vs. West)

  • Participant feedback:

    • “Made us think outside the box - proves you can entertain and still teach.”

    • “Very funny but also serious - great food for thought. Appreciated the perspective of counsel.”


Innovative approaches managing domestic violence cases
Innovative Approaches: dimensions of judicial Managing Domestic Violence Cases

Skills-based program for judges hearing domestic violence cases in family and criminal courts

  • Knowledge:

    • “Black letter law” – child hearsay, hearsay, records production, credibility assessment

  • Skills:

    • Communication, trial management, crafting orders

  • Social Context:

    • Social science research on a number of related topics


Family law at nji
Family Law at NJI dimensions of judicial

  • Programs

    • Concept of modules – reusable “pieces”

  • Resources

    • Program legacy – Judicial e-library


Family law at nji programs
Family Law at NJI: Programs dimensions of judicial

  • The core: Annual Seminar

  • The emerging: semi-annual programs

  • The focus on skills (3-5 days)

  • The social context (3 days)

  • The on-line programs

  • The collaboration(s)

  • What about me?


Family law at nji programs1
Family Law at NJI: Programs dimensions of judicial

1. The core: Annual Seminar

  • a rotating three-year cycle

    • Year 1: Children

    • Year 2: Evidence and Procedure

    • Year 3: Financial and Property Issues

  • 3 days


Programs ct d
Programs ( dimensions of judicial ct’d)

2. The emerging: semi-annual programs

  • 2-3 day programs that seek to address emerging, “hot” issues

  • For example

    • Managing Domestic Violence Cases in Family and Criminal Court

    • Child Development and Best Interests

    • Responding to Allegations of Estrangement and Alienation

    • Judicial Assistance to Self-Represented Litigants in Family Law Proceedings


Programs ct d1
Programs ( dimensions of judicial ct’d)

3. The focus on skills (3-5 days)

  • Negotiation: The foundation of J.D.R. and Settlement Conferences

  • Communication Skills

  • Judgment Writing

  • Computer Training

  • Sufficiency of Reasons

  • Judicial Ethics

  • Expert Evidence


Programs ct d2
Programs ( dimensions of judicial ct’d)

4. The social context (3 days)

  • Neuroscience in the Courtroom

  • Race Law and Judging

  • Judging and Social Inclusion

  • Judging in the Context of Diverse Truths and Cultures

  • Aboriginal Law


Programs ct d3
Programs ( dimensions of judicial ct’d)

5. The on-line programs

  • Problems in Child Protection

  • Sufficiency of Reasons

  • Child Abuse and the Internet

  • Social Media and Judging


Programs ct d4
Programs ( dimensions of judicial ct’d)

6. The collaboration(s)

  • NJI works collaboratively with a variety of institutions

  • In Family Law → The Federation of Law Societies (of Canada) and their “Summer Program on Family Law”

  • With judges and lawyers


Programs ct d5
Programs ( dimensions of judicial ct’d)

7. What about me?

  • New Judges School

  • The Sophomore Years

  • Look to the Future: Retirement Goals and Strategies


Family law at nji resources
Family Law at NJI: Resources dimensions of judicial

  • Judicial Library (e-library)

  • E-letters (Family Law)

    • Monthly update

  • Electronic Bench Books

    • The Hague Convention

    • Child Witnesses

    • Domestic Violence in Family Law

    • Disability/Accessibility Guide Book


What can we do better
What can we do better? dimensions of judicial

  • From macro to micro:

  • General considerations

  • Innovative program formatting

  • Speakers and topics


Thank you
Thank you dimensions of judicial

For more information:

  • The Honourable Justice R. James WilliamsSupreme Court of Nova Scotia, Family DivisionPhone: +1 (902) 424-7212Email: [email protected]

  • The National Judicial Institute Email: [email protected] Phone: +1 (613) 237-1118 Website: www.nji-inm.ca


ad