CDM BASELINE METHODOLOGIES:
This presentation is the property of its rightful owner.
Sponsored Links
1 / 59

Contents PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 117 Views
  • Uploaded on
  • Presentation posted in: General

CDM BASELINE METHODOLOGIES: The devil is in the details DENR Training Course November 4-6, 2003 Climate Change Information Center Manila Observatory Ateneo de Manila University. Contents. Importance of baselines in CDM Relevant studies needed in a CDM PDD Baseline methodologies

Download Presentation

Contents

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript


Contents

CDM BASELINE METHODOLOGIES:The devil is in the detailsDENR Training CourseNovember 4-6, 2003Climate Change Information CenterManila ObservatoryAteneo de Manila University


Contents

Contents

  • Importance of baselines in CDM

  • Relevant studies needed in a CDM PDD

  • Baseline methodologies

    • Procedures to determine project additionality

    • Procedures for calculating baseline emissions

    • Simplified methodologies for small-scale projects

  • Concluding remarks


I the importance of baselines in cdm

I. The Importance of Baselines in CDM


Cdm project

CDM Project

  • Achieves Sustainable Development objectives for the host developing country

  • Reduces GHG Emissions


Clean development mechanism

Clean Development Mechanism

  • Enables developed countries (known as Annex I countries) to meet their emission reduction commitments in a flexible and cost-effective manner

  • Assists developing countries (non-Annex I countries) in meeting their sustainable development objectives

  • Investors benefit by obtaining Certificates of Emissions Reductions (CERs)

  • Host countries benefit in the form of investment, access to better technology, and local sustainable development


What is the idea of the cdm

What is the idea of the CDM?

  • ReduceGHG emissions in one countryto permit an equivalent quantity of GHG emissions in another country, without changing the global emission balance.

  • Emission Reductions (ERs) must:

    • Createreal, measurable,andlong-term benefits related to the mitigation of climate change. (KP Art. 12.5b)

    • Beadditionalto any that would occur in the absence of the certified project activity. (KP Art. 12.5c)

  • => Integrity and credibility is critical


Basic notion of baselines

CO2 Emissions

Baseline scenarioCO2 emissions (that would occur)

Real, measurable and long-term

Additional CO2emissions reduction

CDM project CO2 emissions (observable)

Years

Basic notion of baselines

baseline study


Cer a special product

CER: A special product

  • CER is a payment for the Project Developer not to produce

    • To reduce GHG emissions

  • Thus, the importance of special requirements

    • Definition of baselines

    • Calculation of GHG emission reductions

    • Monitoring of GHG emission reductions


  • What is a baseline scenario

    What is a baseline scenario?

    • The baseline is the scenario that unfolds in the absence of the project activity

    • In other words, it is an interpretation of “what would have happened otherwise”

    • Presumed counterfactual alternative to the proposed CDM project


    Additionality

    Additionality

    • Additionality is the key eligibility criterion in CDM projects

      • You must do something that you would not have done without the CDM

    • Two types of additionality

      • Project Additionality

      • Environmental Additionality


    Baseline methodologies

    Baseline methodologies

    Evaluate

    • Project Additionality

      • Methodology (Meth) Panel Recommendation to Executive Board (EB), July 2003

    • Environmental Additionality

      • Marrakech Accords CDM Modalities and Procedures (M&P), COP-7, 2001


    Project additionality

    Project Additionality

    • Without the ability to register under the CDM, the proposed project would be, or would have been, unlikely to occur


    Project additionality1

    Project Additionality

    • Baseline methodology evaluates whether or not the proposed CDM project activity would have gone ahead anyway.

    • Baseline methodology assesses why the proposed CDM project activity is less likely to occur than one or more of the other possible scenarios.


    Project additionality2

    Project Additionality

    • A baseline methodology evaluates a priori whether the CDM project activity is the baseline scenario.

    • CDM project should be considered as a possible baseline scenario since the possibility it would have been implemented in the absence of carbon credits (CERs) must be examined to determine whether it is additional

    • Baseline methodology must demonstrate that the CDM project activity is additional and therefore not the baseline scenario.


    Environmental additionality

    Environmental Additionality

    • If the proposed CDM project activity is not implemented, a less greenhouse gas friendly activity would have been initiated or continued instead.


    Environmental additionality1

    Environmental Additionality

    • A CDM project activity is additional if anthropogenic emissions of GHGs by sources are reduced below those that would have occurred in the absence of the registered CDM project activity.

      -CDM M&P para. 43

    Emission Reductions=hypothetical baseline emissions – effective (project) emissions


    Environmental additionality2

    Environmental Additionality

    • Forecast:

      Baseline Emissions– Project Emissions

      ___________________

      = Emission Reductions (must be >0)

    • Environmental additionality: if project is expected to generate a positive quantity of ERs.


    How to measure ers

    How to measure ERs?

    CO2 Emissions

    monitor using

    • time indicators and proxy variables

    baseline emissions

    (hypothetical, partly monitorable)

    monitoring plan & calculation concept

    Additional ERs

    measure directly

    • or using emission indicators

    project emissions

    (actual)

    Years


    Baseline methodologies1

    Baseline methodologies

    Evaluate

    • Project Additionality

      • Methodology (Meth) Panel Recommendation to Executive Board (EB), July 2003

    • Environmental Additionality

      • Marrakech Accords CDM Modalities and Procedures (M&P), COP-7, 2001


    Ii relevant studies needed in a cdm pdd

    II. Relevant Studies Needed in a CDM PDD


    What are the relevant questions

    What are the relevant questions?

    • Project Design Document (PDD) with Annexes:

      • What is the baseline scenario? Baseline Study

      • How to measure the ER? Monitoring Plan

      • How many ER to expect?

         Emissions Reduction Study


    Project design document

    Project Design Document

    • Information on

    • project

    • project context

    • Kyoto Protocol

    • CDM M&P

    • etc.

    Monitoring Plan (MP)

    Project Design Document (PDD)

    Project Activity Summary with Annexes:

    Baseline Study (BLS)

    Emission Reduction Study (ERS)


    Iii baseline methodologies

    III. Baseline methodologies


    How to develop cdm baselines cdm m p

    How to develop CDM baselines?(CDM M&P)

    (45) A baseline shall be established …

    • using approved and new methodologies,

    • in a transparent and conservative manner,

    • on a project-specific basis,

    • using simplified procedures for small-scale projects,

    • taking account of national and/or sectoral policies. (e.g., sectoral reform initiatives, local fuel availability, power sector expansion plans, and the economic situation in the project sector)


    How to develop cdm baselines cdm m p1

    How to develop CDM baselines?(CDM M&P)

    (48)Select baseline method …

    • that is deemed most appropriate,

    • that is consistent with guidance from Executive Board,

    • … and justify the choice.


    Iii a procedures to determine project additionality

    III.A Procedures to determine Project Additionality


    Meth panel recommendations to eb july 2003

    Meth Panel Recommendations to EB, July 2003

    • Baseline methodology must include a procedure to assess “why the proposed project CDM project activity” is less likely to occur than one or more of the other possible scenarios.


    Meth panel recommendations to eb july 20031

    Meth Panel Recommendations to EB, July 2003

    Examples of such procedures

    • Qualitative or quantitative assessment of different potential options and an indication of why the non-project option is more likely to occur

    • Qualitative or quantitative assessment of one or more barriers facing the proposed project activity.

    • Indication that the project type is not common practice (e.g. occurs in less than [<x%] of similar cases) in the proposed area of implementation, and not required by recent/pending legislation/regulations.


    Some methods to determine project additionality

    Some methods to determine project additionality

    • Economic / investment analysis

      • Internal rate of return comparison

      • Least cost comparison (power projects)

    • Scenario / barrier analysis

      • Comparison based on investment risks

    • Control groups


    Investment analysis

    Investment Analysis

    • An established and rigorous methodology

    • An objective method that screens alternatives on the basis of the maximization of the return of investment

    • The baseline would have the highest IRR or NPV or lowest cost, not taking into account any CER-revenues


    Contents

    CDM project

    baseline


    Economic analysis of alternatives

    Economic Analysis of Alternatives

    CERs

    Net Present Value

    0

    CDM Projects

    Baseline

    Options


    Economic analysis of alternatives1

    Economic Analysis of Alternatives

    CDM Project

    Baseline: Lowest Cost

    COST

    Options


    Scenario analysis

    Scenario Analysis

    • Investigates the barriers and risks concerning an investment decision

    • Types of risks: regulatory, market, development, environmental, project & country risks

    • Non-economic constraints are the predominant factors for an investment decision

    • Baseline would be the option with the lowest barriers and risks


    Scenario analysis1

    Scenario Analysis

    • Financial / budgetary barriers

      • Access to capital for project finance

      • Hurdle rates of third-party investors

      • Mismatch between investment costs and energy savings

      • High initial costs and lacking access to credit

      • Lack of access to foreign capital


    Scenario analysis2

    Scenario Analysis

    • Legal barriers

      • Regulatory biases or lack of regulation

      • Unclear ownership rights

    • Technological barriers

      • Higher perceived risks of new technology

      • Capacity to absorb new technologies

      • Lack of trained personnel or technical or managerial expertise

      • Need to make changes to existing infra to integrate technology


    Scenario analysis3

    Scenario Analysis

    • Supply-chain barriers

      • Lack of adequate supply infra for spare parts, fuels, etc

      • Lack of transport infra

    • Market price distortions

    • Informational barriers

      • Lack of awareness about available technologies, products, financial support


    Scenario analysis4

    Scenario Analysis

    • Barriers due to prevailing practice

      • Prevailing practice or existing regulatory or policy requirements would have led to implementation of a technology with higher emissions


    Scenario analysis5

    Scenario Analysis

    • A thorough analysis of the local circumstances need to be made to justify the baseline selection

    • Challenge of this method is to provide data and other information that can be validated


    Scenario analysis6

    Scenario Analysis

    Important to distinguish between:

    • Plans and Policies

      • E.g., Philippine Energy Plan

      • Project may still be additional even if it meets one of the targets of the plans

    • Legal Obligations

      • Project will most likely be not additional if it is carried out to meet legal obligations

    • Enforceability of Legal Obligations

      • Project may be additional if enforcement is non-existent


    Control group method

    Control group method

    • Method searches a comparison group that is not offered the opportunity to sell CERs and use their behavior as reference

    • Finding an appropriate control group is not an easy task, since each group will often face different circumstances.

    • Baseline is the control group, CDM project is the treatment group


    Control group method1

    Control group method

    • Difficulty of finding valid control groups can be overcome if the sample of the control groups is bigger

    • Difficulty of finding groups which are reasonably homogenous


    Combination of methods

    Combination of Methods

    No

    Lower IRR?

    Higher Costs?

    Barriers?

    Not Common Practice?

    No

    Not Additional

    Yes

    Yes

    Additional


    Iii b procedures for calculating baseline emissions

    III.B Procedures forcalculating baseline emissions


    Challenge of calculating baseline emissions

    Challenge of calculating baseline emissions

    • Baseline is a counterfactual

      • What would have happened otherwise if there was no CDM project?

    • How to forecast the emissions which would have occurred?

    • How to forecast the emissions which would have happened otherwise if there was no CDM project?


    Cdm m p para 44

    CDM M&P Para. 44

    • The baseline of a CDM project activity is the scenario that reasonably represents the anthropogenic emissions by sources of greenhouse gases that would occur in the absence of the proposed project activity


    Cdm m p approaches para 48

    CDM M&P Approaches(Para. 48)

    • Existing actual or historical emissions

    • Emissions from a technology that represents an economically attractive course of action, taking into account barriers to investment

    • The average emissions of similar activities, in previous 5 years, in similar social, economic, environmental circumstances, and whose performance is the top 20% of their category


    Meth panel recommendation no 15 july 2003

    Meth Panel Recommendation,no. 15, July 2003

    • Since only one approach should be chosen in accordance with paragraph 48 of the CDM M&P, developers are advised to select the one that most closely reflects the process used for calculating baseline emissions or baseline emission rates.


    Meth panel recommendation no 15 16 july 2003

    Meth Panel Recommendationno. 15 & 16, July 2003

    • Process used for project additionality determination can be different from the approach used for calculating baseline emissions

    • Paragraph 48 of CDM M&P apply to the approach used for calculating baseline emissions


    Iii c small scale cdm projects

    III.C Small-Scale CDM Projects

    Simplified Baseline and Monitoring Methodologies


    Clean development mechanism1

    Clean Development Mechanism

    • Types of small-scale projects that could qualify for fast-track approval procedures

    • Renewable energy projects up to 15 megawatts (MW) of output capacity

    • Energy efficiency improvements that reduce energy consumption on the supply and/or demand side by up to 15 gigawatt-hours (GWh)/year

    • Other project activities that both reduce emissions at source and directly emit less than 15 kilotons (kt) of CO2 equivalent annually


    Type i renewable energy projects

    Type I – Renewable Energy Projects

    • I.A Electricity Generation by the User

      • E.g., solar home systems, solar water pumps, wind battery chargers

    • I.B Mechanical Energy for the User

      • E.g., wind-powered pumps, solar water pumps, water mills, wind mills

    • I.C Thermal Energy for the User

      • E.g., solar water heaters and dryers, solar cookers, energy derived from biomass for water heating

    • I.D Renewable Electricity Generation for a Grid


    Type i energy efficiency improvement projects

    Type I – Energy Efficiency Improvement Projects

    • II.A Supply-side Energy Efficiency Improvements – Transmission and Distribution

    • II.B Supply-side Energy Efficiency Improvements – Generation

    • II.C Demand-Side Energy Efficiency Program for Specific Technologies

    • II.D Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switching Measures for Industrial Facilities

    • II.E Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switching Measures for Buildings


    Type iii other project activities

    Type III – Other Project Activities

    • III.A Agriculture

    • III.B Switching Fossil Fuels

    • III.C Emission reductions by low-greenhouse emission vehicles

    • III.D Methane recovery and avoidance


    Simplified methodologies for small scale cdm projects for environmental additionality

    Simplified methodologies forSmall-Scale CDM ProjectsFor Environmental Additionality

    • Technology / Measure

    • Boundary

    • Baseline

    • Leakage

    • Monitoring


    Iv concluding remarks

    IV. Concluding remarks


    Interpretation of cop 7 guidance

    Interpretation of COP-7 Guidance

    • … is not concrete enough:

      • Mixture of baseline and monitoring concepts

      • Concrete baseline and monitoring methods yet to be agreed / approved

      • When to apply which approach and method?

    • … needs to be interpreted by project developer, Designated Operational Entities, Meth Panel and the Executive Board in light and context of other relevant provisions

    • Depends on concrete project input from project developers and Parties

    • The development of a project baseline and monitoring concept is a highly creative process which must yield conceptually rigorous results. It is currently more an art than a science.


    What is emerging from pcf cerupt

    What is emerging from PCF, CERUPT …

    … is a variety of methods:

    • No single, but a hybrid mixture of methods.

    • Complexity depends on circumstances, project type and design.

    • Methodologies to be approved, “political issues” to be decided by the Parities.

  • Baseline study and MP must “work” together:

    • Method-driven scenario forecast in the baseline study – as a basis for:

    • … monitoring concept and tools for calculating baseline and project emissions in the MP.

  • More experience and discussion is needed

    • Contribution to evolutionary concept for baselines and monitoring.

  • The devil is in the details


  • Contents

    Thank you

    Roberto C. Yap, S.J., Ph.D.

    Environmental Economist

    Climate Change Information Center

    Manila Observatory

    Ateneo de Manila University

    Tel +63 2 426-6144

    Fax +63 2 426-6070

    [email protected]


  • Login