Freehand Drawing System based on Geometric Constraints

Download Presentation

Freehand Drawing System based on Geometric Constraints

Loading in 2 Seconds...

- 166 Views
- Uploaded on
- Presentation posted in: General

Freehand Drawing System based on Geometric Constraints

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Freehand Drawing Systembased on Geometric Constraints

Kaisuke Nakajima

Joint work with Takeo Igarashi

User Interface Research Group

The University of Tokyo

- Introduction to Pegasus
- [Igarashi, UIST 1997 & CHI 1998]

- Improvement attempts
- My current study
- Any comments greatly appreciated!

1. Problem

2. Our Idea & Demonstration

3. Related Work

4. Algorithm

5. Evaluation

6. Ongoing Study

7. Summary

- Diagrams
- In documents, slides, …
- By drawing editors

- Difficult to satisfy geometric relations!

Copy

Flip

Move

- In this case, grids works well, but…

Geometric constraints

The user attempts to

draw a perpendicular line,

GRID

but grid prevents desired placements.

He draws a box separately, and...

ROTATE

rotates it, but fails to get precise angle.

ROTATE

COPY

Better strategy:

copy the slope rotate 90 degrees

Move

Grid

Flip

Copy

Rotate

The user must plan detailed strategy.

Planning overhead

1. Problem

2. Our Idea & Demonstration

3. Related Work

4. Algorithm

5. Evaluation

6. Ongoing Study

7. Summary

Sketch

+ Beautify

- Sketching is easy!
- Sketch Beautify
- Interactive Beautification[Igarashi, UIST 1997]

Draw and...

Draw and...

Satisfied

Constraints

Beautify.

Draw and...

Beautify.

Beautify.

But free strokes are ambiguous.

Generate multiple candidates

Let the user select

In this way,the user can constructprecise geometric diagramswithout any editing commands!!

Prototype System Pegasus

Live Demo

1. Problem

2. Our Idea & Demonstration

3. Related Work

4. Algorithm

5. Evaluation

6. Ongoing Study

7. Summary

[Pavlidis 1985] ...

Batch-based

too many errors!

More Interaction (+ multiple candidates)

[Apple Newton] [SmartSketch] ...

Local context

Local context

Global context

[Sutherland 1963] [Nelson 1985] ...

- Previous work
- Explicitly specify constraints

- Our approach
- Infer constraints

1. Problem

2. Our Idea & Demonstration

3. Related Work

4. Algorithm

5. Evaluation

6. Ongoing Study

7. Summary

Segment coordinates

Constraint Inference

Multiple constraints

Constraint Solver

Multiple candidates

Candidate Evaluation

Primary candidate

Input

Reference segments

(array of (X0, Y0, X1, Y1))

New stroke

(x0, y0, x1, y1)

Output

Possible constraints

(linear equations of (x0, y0, x1, y1))

Perpendicular

const * (x1 – x0) + const * (y1 – y0) = 0

Edge Connection

x0 = const, y0 = const

etc.

(x1, y1)

(x0, y0)

- How?
- Supported constraints

if (distance(point1, point2) < 30)

infer constraint(point1 == point2);

Input

Possible constraints

(linear equations of (x0, y0, x1, y1))

Output

Beautification candidates

(array of (x0, y0, x1, y1))

Perpendicular

Same Length

Edge Connection

Horizontal

Candidate nearest to the original stroke

Primary candidate

1. Problem

2. Our Idea & Demonstration

3. Related Work

4. Algorithm

5. Evaluation

6. Ongoing Study

7. Summary

To confirm the intuition !

“It’s difficult for novice users

to use commands”

“Interactive beautification is good”

Rapidness

How fast?

Precision

Beautiful?

- 18 subjects
- 3 diagrams, 3 editors (9 sessions / person)

- CAD ... AutoSketch(AutoDesk), CAD Software.
- Draw ... SmartSketch(Future Wave), Drawing Editor.
- Pegasus…Our Prototype system.

On AMiTY (a pen computer)

B)

C)

A)

Parallel-1

Symmetric-1

Parallel-1

Parallel-2

Symmetric-2

Parallel-2

Connected

(all Vertices)

Perpendicular

Equal Interval

Vertical and Horizontal

Connected

(all Vertices)

Connected (all Vertices)

Precision

Rapidness

Averaged drawing time

for three diagrams

The ratio of sessions where

all constraints are satisfied

Results

100

600

500

80

400

60

300

40

200

Pegasus outperformed CAD and Draw,

in both rapidness and precision.

20

100

0

0

CAD

CAD

Draw

Pegasus

Draw

Pegasus

- Pegasus cannot do everything
- But: certainly useful in its target domain

CAD

Paint

Geometric diagrams,

rapidly & precisely!

1. Problem

2. Our Idea & Demonstration

3. Related Work

4. Algorithm

5. Evaluation

6. Ongoing Study

7. Summary

- Address limitations of Pegasus
- Only lines
- Too many candidates
- Forgets constraints

Support curves

- Circles, ellipses, arcs,
Bézier curves

- (Experimental demo)

- Challenges with curves
- More ambiguity
- Shape recognition
- Constraint inference

- Complex constraints: how to represent?
- e.g. line tangent to piecewise Bézier curve

- Complex constraints: how to solve efficiently?
- Exponential growth of candidate solutions

- More ambiguity

Overlapping…

Constraint switching interface

- Visualize conflicting constraints
- Enable manual switching

- How to detect conflicting constraints efficiently?

Remember constraints

- Maintain them during manipulation
- Chorus [Hosobe 2001]

Skewed

Stretch!

Stretch!

1. Problem

2. Our Idea & Demonstration

3. Related Work

4. Algorithm

5. Evaluation

6. Ongoing Study

7. Summary

- Pegasus: freehand drawing system
- User study showed promising results

- Geometric constraints play an important role in sketch beautification
- Further improvements to be made

- Papers & demos available at
http://www-ui.is.s.u-tokyo.ac.jp/