Synthesis of doha round implications lessons from trade development poverty linkages study
This presentation is the property of its rightful owner.
Sponsored Links
1 / 14

SYNTHESIS OF DOHA ROUND IMPLICATIONS: LESSONS FROM TRADE-DEVELOPMENT-POVERTY LINKAGES STUDY PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 62 Views
  • Uploaded on
  • Presentation posted in: General

SYNTHESIS OF DOHA ROUND IMPLICATIONS: LESSONS FROM TRADE-DEVELOPMENT-POVERTY LINKAGES STUDY. Pradeep S Mehta, Secretary General, CUTS International UNECA Expert Group Meeting and Workshop On Enhancing Africa’s Participation in the WTO’s Negotiations Process

Download Presentation

SYNTHESIS OF DOHA ROUND IMPLICATIONS: LESSONS FROM TRADE-DEVELOPMENT-POVERTY LINKAGES STUDY

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript


Synthesis of doha round implications lessons from trade development poverty linkages study

SYNTHESIS OF DOHA ROUND IMPLICATIONS:LESSONS FROM TRADE-DEVELOPMENT-POVERTY LINKAGES STUDY

Pradeep S Mehta,

Secretary General, CUTS International

UNECA Expert Group Meeting and Workshop

On

Enhancing Africa’s Participation in the WTO’s Negotiations Process

7 September 2009, Nairobi, Kenya


Presentation plan

PRESENTATION PLAN

  • Introduction to the TDP Project

  • Some statistics

  • Lessons from the TDP Project based on some stylised facts from SSA country experiences

  • Lessons that feed into the negotiations

  • A post-script on the FEATS Project


Introduction to the tdp project

INTRODUCTION TO THE TDP PROJECT

  • Trade, development and poverty reduction experiences from thirteen developing countries capturing macroeconomic impressions as well as sectoral studies

  • Five of the thirteen from Africa – Kenya, South Africa, Tanzania, Uganda and Zambia

  • No one size fits all, and success of trade liberalisation in bringing about development and poverty reduction depends upon ownership by national stakeholders and supply side management, especially through flanking measures

  • More details at http://www.cuts-citee.org/tdp/index.htm


Synthesis of doha round implications lessons from trade development poverty linkages study

Source: Complied from TDP Project country background papers


Tariff reduction in african tdp countries

Sectors studied in African TDP Countries

Tariff Reduction in African TDP Countries

Source: Author’s compilation from TDP country studies and from WTO, 2006, World Trade Profiles

Source: TDP Volume 2


Lessons from tdp i trade growth linkages

LESSONS FROM TDP– I[Trade-growth linkages]

  • No evidence of steadily growing significance of the export sector during the post-liberalisation period

  • Vibrant agriculture sector essential for poverty reduction

    • Industrial exports from Uganda and Zambia declined or stagnated despite reforms

  • No revealed negative association between tariffs and overall economic activity

    • More open Kenya versus Vietnam ( growth of 2% versus 7.3%)

  • Export expansion depends upon domestic support, as in the case of Tanzanian fisheries


  • Lessons from tdp ii need for flanking policies

    LESSONS FROM TDP– II[Need for flanking policies]

    • Liberalisation unaccompanied by flanking policies may actually deepen poverty

      Example: dairy and maize sectors in Uganda

    • Trade adjustment creates winners and losers: need to understand distributional consequences

    • Initial distribution of endowments crucial for poverty reduction.

    • Obstacles to exploitation of positive synergies

      • Supply side constraints: lack of flanking policies and regulatory reforms

      • Demand side constraints: NTBs (TBT, SPS), poorly chosen trade preferences, inadequate mode 4 access


    Lessons from tdp iii trade growth poverty linkages

    LESSONS FROM TDP – III[Trade-Growth-Poverty Linkages]

    • Ground level complexities constrain exploitation of positive synergies among growth, export expansion and poverty reduction

      • Countries like Tanzania and Zambia trapped into slow growth and poverty reduction

  • Policy space crucial -- availability and use

  • Ownership of the policy regime matters

    • Vietnam did better than Kenya with similar regime but much more ownership

  • Governance, facilitated adjustment and monitoring and evaluation are other important factors


  • Lessons from tdp essence

    LESSONS FROM TDP [Essence]

    • Trade liberalisation is potentially beneficial for both economic development and poverty reduction but the potential needs to be harnessed through:

      a)  local ownership of reforms

      b) supply  side capacity enhanced and buttressed by presence of flanking conditions ( good infrastructure, effective trade facilitation, social safety nets and effective competition regime)

      c) liberalisation that takes into account difference in sectoral realities and is therefore selective  in emphasis.


    Tdp feeding into dda i market access

    TDP FEEDING INTO DDA – I[Market access]

    • Tariff liberalisation commitments may not translate into economic growth or poverty reduction automatically

    • Lowering of tariff peaks, tariff escalation and grant of preferential tariffs in sectors of interest by negotiating partners could lead to potential market access opportunities

    • Service sector market access, particularly mode 4, could bring potential gains

    • Additional market opening in agricultural products can bring significant opportunities


    Tdp feeding into dda ii subsidies and standards

    TDP FEEDING INTO DDA – II[Subsidies and Standards]

    • Real reduction of agricultural subsidies by developed countries can open markets for developing country products

    • Rules for reigning in high and changing standards in developed markets can make market access more predictable for developing countries

    • Simpler rules of origin, particularly preferential ones, could make preference schemes work better


    Tdp feeding into dda iii homework

    TDP FEEDING INTO DDA – III[Homework]

    • Addressing supply side constraints crucial to success in leveraging market access (hard infrastructure)

    • Property right reforms, capacity enhancement, better regulation equally crucial (soft infrastructure)

    • Agricultural policies aimed at diversification, value addition and facilitation of standardisation important for SSA

    • All this can be factored into SSA responses to the AfT discourse


    Postscript some lessons from the ongoing cuts feats project

    Postscript – Some lessons from the ongoing CUTS FEATS Project

    • Governance, policy coherence, mainstreaming trade into national development strategies and plans important

    • Increased stakeholder awareness and involvement in policy debate, and better oversight by parliamentarians essential for generating a sense of policy ownership

    • Better consultative mechanisms, information flows and feedback loops for stakeholders needed

    • The three most important sectors for SSA are agriculture, agriculture and agriculture


    Synthesis of doha round implications lessons from trade development poverty linkages study

    THANK YOU


  • Login