1 / 8

Trade Policies

Trade Policies. Free trade vs protectionism. This part is simple: Free trade makes the country as a whole better off, even though it may not make every individual in the country better off Winners gain more than the losers lose The tale of a great inventor

enoch
Download Presentation

Trade Policies

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Trade Policies Free trade vs protectionism

  2. This part is simple: • Free trade makes the country as a whole better off, even though it may not make every individual in the country better off • Winners gain more than the losers lose • The tale of a great inventor • Trade allows us to obtain the goods at lower cost just as superior technology would allow us to obtain the goods at lower cost

  3. “Valid” arguments for protection • Advantages of diversification • What if we have a war? • What if our staple industry becomes obsolete? • May be valid for small countries • Protection for specific groups • Skilled workers vs unskilled workers (with factor endowment induced comparative advantage) • Increase incomes of a group at expense of lower average income • Could be done by other means, better? • These arguments take sides in income vs other objectives tradeoff

  4. “Valid” arguments for protection • Improving terms of trade • Recall, terms of trade = 100 (index of export prices) / (index of import prices) • If a tariff increases export prices more than import prices, terms of trade may improve • May be valid only for large countries • Protection of infant industries • Large economies of scale • Significant learning by doing • Seems to have worked historically • Or did it? • Strategic trade policies • Hoping to “break in” very profitable industries worldwide • These arguments suggest economic gains to a country as whole

  5. Erroneous arguments for protection • Keeping money at home • But you don’t need to, the money always return anyway • Protection against low-wage foreign labour • But this is refusing to obtain goods at low cost • Exports are “better” than imports • Exports EX increase GDP, imports IM decrease GDP • NX = (EX – IM) • But this says income is more important than consumption • Protection creates domestic jobs • It may create jobs for some • But it destroys jobs for others

  6. How does protectionism work? • Tariff (import duty) • The price increases above the world price • Domestic quantity supplied increases • Domestic quantity demanded (consumed) decreases • Total surplus decreases => net effect is negative • Producers gain less than consumers gain • Quota • Can import no more than set amount • Quota reduces our surplus more than “equivalent” tariff does • The difference is: • With tariff, government receives revenue • With quota, foreign producers receive that revenue • Voluntary export restriction VER • A country who sells may prefer self-imposed quota because • With tariff, foreign government receives revenue • With quota, Canadian producers receive that revenue

  7. How does protectionism work? • Tariff (import duty) • The price increases above the world price • Domestic quantity supplied increases • Domestic quantity demanded (consumed) decreases • Total surplus decreases => net effect is negative • Producers gain less than consumers gain • Quota • Can import no more than set amount • Quota reduces our surplus more than “equivalent” tariff does • The difference is: • With tariff, government receives revenue • With quota, foreign producers receive that revenue • Voluntary export restriction VER • A country who sells may prefer self-imposed quota because • With tariff, foreign government receives revenue • With quota, Canadian producers receive that revenue

  8. Current Trade Policies • Read. NOT tested.

More Related