1 / 27

Agreements with Landowners and Local Governments Financing Wind Power: The Future of Energy May 8, 2008, Scottsdale, AZ

Agreements with Landowners and Local Governments Financing Wind Power: The Future of Energy May 8, 2008, Scottsdale, AZ. Matthew S. Moses Nixon Peabody LLP 1100 Clinton Square Rochester, NY 14604 P (585) 263-1306 mmoses@nixonpeabody.com. Introduction.

eleazar
Download Presentation

Agreements with Landowners and Local Governments Financing Wind Power: The Future of Energy May 8, 2008, Scottsdale, AZ

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Agreements with Landowners and Local GovernmentsFinancing Wind Power: The Future of EnergyMay 8, 2008, Scottsdale, AZ Matthew S. Moses Nixon Peabody LLP 1100 Clinton Square Rochester, NY 14604 P (585) 263-1306 mmoses@nixonpeabody.com

  2. Introduction • Wind power projects are essentially real estate projects • Most significant development assets: • site control • right to build • tax agreement • Goal – create financeable project • Objectives: • take care of real estate details at earliest possible time • fix project costs to greatest extent possible, including state and local tax cost

  3. Real Estate Matters • Goal – obtain site control to all project property from turbine to point of interconnection • Landowner Agreements • Potential interests and instruments • Easement • Lease • Fee • License • Option • SNDA

  4. Real Estate Matters (cont’d) • Key issues • Scope • Control of entire farm/ranch – location of improvements determined later • Contemplated improvements • Access roads • Laydown areas • Collection wires • Overhead • Underground • Turbines – foundations and towers • Transformers • Substation/Switchyard • Met towers • Communications towers • Fencing

  5. Real Estate Matters (cont’d) • Payment • Fixed • Pros: easy to calculate and administer; predictable revenue to landowners • Cons: landowners may disfavor • Variable – Royalties • Pros: landowners want to share in wealth • Cons: difficult to calculate; unpredictable; risk of opening books to landowners; government may want similar deal • Signing bonus • Revenue expectation management

  6. Real Estate Matters (cont’d) • Environmental • Land disturbance and restoration • Repair of farm/ranch improvements • drainage tile, farm roads, ditching, irrigation system • Minimal impact on current and future farm/ranch use • Hazardous Substances • protect against activities of landowner • Decommissioning • Standard of decommissioning – what stays and what goes • Security • When funded • Amount – net of salvage value • Form of instrument – bond, letter of credit, fund/escrow account, parent guarantee

  7. Real Estate Matters (cont’d) • Indemnification and insurance • Limit to just project and project-related activities • Taxes • Beware of indemnification for increases in tax on landowner property • Financing issues • Free alienability – no restrictions on assignment or transfer • SNDA – subordination and non-disturbance agreement • Project agreements not subject to foreclosure by a landowner’s lender • Need to work with landowners’ lenders • Project mortgage allowed

  8. Real Estate Matters (cont’d) • Other Real Estate Matters • Title insurance • involve title insurance company early on in process • Municipal franchise and road permits • Substation/switchyard • transfer to utility • Project mortgage • Stands in position of project real estate, ahead of farm/ranch mortgage • Landowners not involved

  9. Real Estate Matters (cont’d) • Trouble Spots • Financing – issues that may stand in the way of closing • Incomplete real estate interests • Power collection system – not all dots connected • Roads – adjacent landowners own to middle of road • Municipal franchises • Underlying land rights but no permit from municipality • Road crossings • Wrong owner – marriage, divorce, death, joint ownership, etc. • Sale of parcel during development • Setbacks – lack of border easement

  10. Real Estate Matters (cont’d) • Construction and Operation of Project • Location of improvements • Hyper-communication with landowners • Build project consistent with Plans and Specs / turbine locations should match locations identified in permits • Construction loan covenants • Construction impacts – remediation • Tax liability on underlying farm/ranch • Release of unnecessary land from project • TV, noise, shadow flicker (landscaping) • beware of adjacent property owners

  11. Agreements Between Developers and Municipalities • Goal – obtain all permits necessary to built and operate project and protect project from uneconomic taxation • Major issues • Permits • What’s in it for me (for local governments) • Effectively a pay-for-permit game • Governmental oversight of project • Taxes • Property (personal and real property), Sales, Mortgage Recording, and Transfer Taxes • Exemptions and abatement programs • Vehicle for property tax agreement (e.g. payment in-lieu of tax agreement (PILOT), host community agreement (HCA), voluntary payment agreement (VPA)) • Appropriate amount in face of high capital cost of project • Amount project can afford to achieve hurdle rate • Local government expectations

  12. Agreements Between Developers and Municipalities (cont’d) • PILOT Agreement • Term • Scope – covers all project improvements • Include transmission line and substation/switchyard • Underwater lands? Offshore? • Payment Amount • Fixed • Assessment-based with percentage abatement • Tax rate risk • Adjustments to Payment Amount • Inflation • Variable payments based on capacity factor, energy prices, etc. • Additions to project • Additional MW – same payment rate • No new MW – no additional payment (e.g. operations building) • Deletions from project • Damage, destruction, condemnation, decommissioning • Reduce payment by MW dropped from project

  13. Agreements Between Developers and Municipalities (cont’d) • Payment split among local governments • municipal concern (unless deal hinges on split) • Payment security • company should not offer security but should be prepared for request from municipality • form of security • Parent guarantee • PILOT mortgage • LC

  14. Agreements Between Developers and Municipalities (cont’d) • Special district taxes • Fire, water, sewer, refuse, ambulance, etc. • Dominance of tax base • How to control • Bells and whistles • Capacity factor kicker • Energy price kicker • Economic development power • Host payments for community/charitable purposes • Historic preservation payments • Transaction fees

  15. Agreements Between Developers and Municipalities (cont’d) • Substation/switchyard • Utility may require ownership of substation/switchyard • Transfer after construction • Interconnection Agreement may require tax indemnification • PILOT should cover substation taxes • Financing issues • Free alienability – no restriction on assignment or transfer • Collateral assignment • Consent to Assignment in favor of lender • Lender right to cure default • Termination – right of company to terminate if project uneconomic

  16. Agreements Between Developers and Municipalities (cont’d) • Approach to PILOT Negotiations • Due diligence on local tax system • Scope of exemption • Statutory scheme and process for obtaining exemption • Model full tax on project to determine municipal revenue appetite • Model amount of tax project can afford • Establish strategy • Portion of full tax • “Competitive” payment with other generators • “Competitive” payment with other wind projects • Portion to tax base

  17. Agreements Between Developers and Municipalities (cont’d) • Build relationship with community leaders • Negotiate terms – plan on multiple meetings • Exchange term sheets to capture ground gained • Approvals

  18. Agreements Between Developers and Municipalities (cont’d) • Host Community Agreement • Non-financial aspects of municipal agreement, but can be brought into PILOT Agreement or used as a substitute for a PILOT Agreement • May help “steer” payment to permitting authority • One document – best if covers all non-tax business dealings with municipality (e.g. road use, municipal costs, decommissioning, etc.)

  19. Agreements Between Developers and Municipalities (cont’d) • Potential provisions • Municipal franchise rights and road permits • Road use • Why needed? • Public use • Limit risk to project for damage to roads caused by project • Repair – not replace – road • Cost advantage of private bid • Separate agreement? • Traffic plan – list of involved roads • Right of access to inspect and improve roads • Agent of municipality • Over-sized vehicles • Construction, operation, repair and decommissioning

  20. Agreements Between Developers and Municipalities (cont’d) • Pre-construction engineer’s inspection to establish baseline condition • Reinforcement activities • Post-construction engineer’s inspection to establish damage needing repair • Repair activities • Municipal acceptance of repair • Costs • Indemnification and insurance • Car wreck – make sure covered by insurance policy • Security (e.g. performance bond)

  21. Agreements Between Developers and Municipalities (cont’d) • Municipal review and oversight costs • Should developer pay? • Separate agreement? • Attorneys’ fees • Engineers’ fees • Escrow account • Initial funding • Draws • Replenishment • Interest • Return of principal

  22. Agreements Between Developers and Municipalities (cont’d) • Building permits • Who reviews application – qualifications • Who oversees construction – qualifications • Permit conditions • Building codes • Plans and Specs • Who issues certificate of completion – qualifications • When can project first sell energy • Operations • Administration of permit conditions • Complaint resolution

  23. Agreements Between Developers and Municipalities (cont’d) • Decommissioning • Standard of decommissioning • Municipal right to decommission in the event company fails to do so • Security • When funded • Amount – net of estimated salvage value • Form of instrument – bond, letter of credit, fund/escrow account, parent guarantee • Insurance and Indemnification • Limit to just project and project-related activities • Approvals

  24. Agreements Between Developers and Municipalities (cont’d) • Other State and Local Taxes • Sales tax • Statutory exemption – production equipment • BOP costs • Discretionary exemption – governmental abatement • Mortgage recording tax • Face value of mortgage • Discretionary exemption – governmental abatement

  25. Q&A

  26. Contact Information Matthew S. Moses Nixon Peabody LLP 1100 Clinton Square Rochester, NY 14604 P (585) 263-1306 mmoses@nixonpeabody.com

More Related