1 / 31

QUALITATIVE RESEARCH METHODS

QUALITATIVE RESEARCH METHODS. CRITICAL TEXTUAL ANALYSIS--TYPES, PART 3 (CRITICAL THEORY/MARXISM & POSTMODERNISM). I. MARXISM/CRITICAL THEORY. A. Marxism refers to theories of economics, politics, & society using ideas from Karl Marx & Fredrich Engles.

deva
Download Presentation

QUALITATIVE RESEARCH METHODS

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. QUALITATIVE RESEARCH METHODS CRITICAL TEXTUAL ANALYSIS--TYPES, PART 3 (CRITICAL THEORY/MARXISM & POSTMODERNISM)

  2. I. MARXISM/CRITICAL THEORY • A. Marxism refers to theories of economics, politics, & society using ideas from Karl Marx & Fredrich Engles. • B. Culture intertwined with class struggle through ideology • C. Ideology conveyed through various institutions (or superstructures) • D. The philosophy is complex & not monolithic.

  3. D. Political Economy • 1. Grounded in the economic analysis of institutions • a. Actions of individuals motivated by self-interest (see Adam Smith) • b. Self-interest leads to greater level of overall wealth in the nation (“the invisible hand”) • 2. In media studies, Political Economy primarily focuses on the economics of mass media production & consumption. • 3. Seeks to understand “how the capitalist class promotes and ensures their dominant position in capitalist society” (Devereux)

  4. E. “Classic Marxism” • 1. Sees culture as “the mirror of social life.” • a. Art (or culture) should be viewed in terms of “realism” • b. True art should subvert ideology & capitalism • 2. The Frankfurt School--flourished in Germany in the 1930's & in the U.S. in the 1940's • a. Sometimes is known as "critical theory" or classic Marxist theory, focusing on problems in the mass media. • b. Theorists argued that mass media had prevented history from working out as Marx had predicted, because it subverted & seduced the masses (through "low art") 

  5. F. The Frankfort School • 1. Pop culture is defined as mass culture, produced by big business for a profit • 2. Pop culture seen as synonymous with low culture • 3. Elitist vs. populist values • a. True elitists scorn popular or low culture as debased & trashy (not really "art“) • c. True populists scorn high art as pretentious & inaccessible

  6. The Frankfort School, con’t. • 3. High vs. low art • a. High art original, serious & complex • 1) Also known as “highbrow” • 2) Includes literary & artistic masterpieces, classical symphonic music, etc. • b. Low art is popular, unoriginal & not complex • 1) Also known as "lowbrow“ • 2) Seen as trashy, garish, crude, or kitschy • 3) Includes popular novels; comic books; mainstream TV shows; Hollywood blockbusters; fashion & fads; etc.

  7. The Frankfort School, con’t. • c. "Middlebrow" is an in-between position • 1) Prefers a safe & non-controversial middle position between high & low art; • 2) Includes popular foreign or independent films; PBS; "lite" classical music; etc. • 3) Many elitists see this position as too safe & sentimental (e.g. Adorno) • 4) Keeps us from recognizing "high art“ because prefer easy listening selections or sentimental favorites instead of the truly avant-garde

  8. The Frankfort School, con’t • 4. Arguments made against popular art by the Frankfort School: • a. Panders to lowest tastes • b. Geared mostly to entertainment & fun • c. Often nostalgic & sentimental • d. Junk is preferred over quality • e. Over-commercial (designed to sell products)

  9. G. Neo-Marxism • 1. More recently, the "classical" position has been modified into Neo-Marxism • a. Collapses the distinction between "high" and "low" art, while also positing a commodified culture. • b. Althusser rejected the Hegelism of western Marxism in favor of a more structuralist approach • 2. Focus on the analysis of everyday culture or “popular art”

  10. Neo-Marxism, con’t. • 3. Pop art revisionism/arguments for pop art: • a. Evocative & can be serious • b. The “literature of the people“ • c. High art/low art an artificial distinction; boundaries eroding in a postmodern world • d. Pop art is a social unifer • 1) Helps with social rituals • 2) Cements community feelings • 3) Reinforces values

  11. Neo-Marxism, con’t. • 4. Ideology is seen in “lived practices” • a. Comprehensive sets of ideas our beliefs about political & social life, what we think is true. • b. All discourses have ideological functions which help support the status quo even if not recognized • c. Ideologies serve the interests of the dominant class, stabilizing society while promoting false consciousness in the workers • d. Yet, not all powerful; can have competing ideologies

  12. Neo-Marxism, con’t. • 5. Interpellation • a. The mechanism by which people are subjected to ideology. It is "the process by which the representations found in a culture . . [seduce, or "hail"] individuals into accepting the ideologies carried by these forms of representation" (Berger, p. 57) • b. Interpellation occurs through discursive, linguistic, & symbolic orders which are necessary to live • c. It is similar to the concept of preferred reading (by S. Hall); it "suggests that we accept ideologies by identifying with characters & situations found in the arts & mass media" (Berger, p. 58), suturing ourselves into the scheme of things

  13. Neo-Marxism, con’t. • 6. Hegemony—what is “taken for granted,” or common sense about the nature of reality” (see Gramsci). • a. Ideological beliefs operate in a hegemonic system • b. We given consent to be governed a paricular way • c. Includes, yet also goes beyond, culture (R. Williams, 1977), dominating (or, as Williams says, saturating) every aspect of our lives, "what goes without saying" • d. Although we can uncover ideologies, it is harder to discover hegemonic domination, because it is ubiquitous & amorphous, concerned with "our lived system of meanings & values" (Williams, p. 110)

  14. Neo-Marxism, con’t. • 7. Base/Superstructure • a. The base is the mode of production, the system of economic relations found in a given society. • b. The base shapes the superstructure, which are the laws & institutions in a society, such as religion, education, art, law, politics, media, etc. • 1) Repressive state apparatuses (RSAs)--coercive forces such as the police which enforce an ideology when threatened by deviance) • 2) Ideological state apparatuses (ISAs)-- the various social institutions that regulate & reproduce ideology on behalf of the dominant class

  15. Neo-Marxism, con’t. • 8. Dialectical struggle • a. Like Hegel, Marx posed a dialectical view of historical evolution, consisting of an underlying struggle between opposing forces (Thesis-Antithesis). • b. To become liberated and/or change the social order, we must become aware of the dialectic of opposing forces in a struggle for power • c. Otherwise, people will remain alienated from one another, “co-opted into their own oppression" (Littlejohn, p. 228) • d. This alienation is known as false consciousness

  16. Neo-Marxism, con’t. • 9. Socioeconomic Class • a. It "refers to categories based on the economic resources of different groups of people in a given society, and the social and cultural arrangements that stem from this division" (Berger, p. 47) • b. U.S. divided into 6 socioeconomic classes: upper-upper, lower-upper, upper-middle, lower-middle (where, traditionally, a third of Americans are), upper-lower (another third are here), & lower-lower • c. For capitalist ideology to work, most of the population must believe they are in the middle class, with the fiction that class is irrelevant in U.S. society--i.e. the Horatio Alger myth, the American Dream). • d. Perceived inequities threaten that fiction

  17. Neo-Marxism, con’t. • 10. Bourgeoisie/proletariat • a. The elites who own & control the modes of production are the bourgeoisie • b. The workers who own relatively little form the proletariat • c. The bourgeoisie controls mass media, using them to carry ideological messages supporting the status quo • d. They are aided by artists, writers, etc. (members of the petite bourgeoisie), who help maintain control of both the economy & the society

  18. Neo-Marxism, con’t. • 11. Alienation/Estrangement • a. Elites are alienated from the working class & the poor, who become exploited and dominated. • b. The proletariat in turn are alienated from their work, from the products of their labors, & from the wealthy, seeing themselves only as a commodity • c. Causes both physical & psychological suffering, esp. an anomie that prevents acting to overcome one's life condition • d. The lack of pleasure in work is displaced to alternative means of gaining pleasure (e.g. TV) which leads to greater alienation, with the contradictions of society repressed

  19. Neo-Marxism, con’t. • I2. Representation • a. The social process & product of making signs stand for their meanings • b. A sense-making process within all signifying systems, often organized & regulated in different ways within different discourses (e.g. different media) • c. Shows the social relations of signification in class society; often condensed so as to refer to the products of those relations (i.e. representative characteristics of a particular class or group, such as stereotypes) • d. Ideology often seen as the practice of reproducing social relations of inequality within the sphere of signification & discourse

  20. Neo Marxism, con’t. • 13. Reproduction • a. Mass media, as an ISA, is based on the ability to "reproduce" reality • b. Often assumed to be an accurate representation of "reality," leading to the fallacy of realism (artificial texts are assumed to be true, thus the ideas in them are naturalized) • c. Originally, the idea was that high culture (e.g. art) had an authority & authenticity that transcended reality--something lost whenever that art is "reproduced" (for example, seeing the Mona Lisa is different from seeing a photograph of the Mona Lisa) • d. In modern industrial society one fear has been that of being "copied"--yet, in an increasingly postmodern & postindustrial world, it is no longer clear what is an original & what is a reproduction--it no longer matters as much (the idea of the simulacra & simulated experience, e.g. "virtual reality")

  21. Neo Marxism, con’t. • 14. Commodity fetishism/consumer culture • a. Idea of the fetish object imbued with mystical, magical power taken from religion • b. Capitalist society mystifies us as to how commodities are created, leading us to ignore their true cost & to believe in magic • c. Fetish also occurs in the displacement of sexual desire from a person to an object • d. Sexual lust becomes displaced onto commodities (consumer lust, e.g. the shopping spree, shopping "addictions”, etc.) • d. Consumer culture ensures alienation--although we possess more material possessions than ever before, we are not happy

  22. Neo Marxism, con’t. • 15. Colonized viewer • a. Creating desire to consume is the purpose of advertising, which creates fashion & style, which substitute for an authentic sense of self • b. When we accept the images & roles given to us by the media (reflecting the beliefs of the dominant group), we become "colonized" • c. Media viewers are part of a vast consumer colony dominated by materialism, capitalism, & a narrow definition of success • d. Late Capitalism not just an economic system, "but a kind of culture in which almost everything is subordinated to consumption" (Berger, p. 55)

  23. Neo-Marxism, con’t. • 16. Cultural imperialism • a. The effects of Westernization on the rest of the world, esp. as disseminated through the ubiquitous U.S. mass media • b. Bourgeois, capitalistic values spread throughout the world • 1) Some positive results (e.g. promoting democracy) • 2) Increased exploitation of workers, esp. in the Third World • c. “The McDonaldization of society“ (Ritzer) leads to the blandness & homogeneity experienced in the U.S.--creating a "universal shopping mall-like plasticity to life everywhere on the planet" (Berger, p. 62)

  24. II. POSTMODERNISM • A. Means many things, ranging from a social condition to a critical perspective • B. The "modern" period occurred during & after the Enlightenment, with the rise of the individual & the beginnings of capitalism & industrialism (though some trace it back to the 15th century, with the invention of the printing press) • 1. Associated with writers like James Joyce, Marcel Proust, T.S. Eliot, & William Faulkner • 2. Connected to artists like Pablo Picasso, Henri Matisse, along with Dadaism & surrealism • 3. In music, modernist composers include Igor Stravinsky & Bela Bartok

  25. Postmodernism, con’t. • C. Postmodern refers to 4 interrelated phenomenon (Denzin, 1991): • 1. An artistic, aesthetic movement called postmodernism (seen in media & architecture, as well as traditional art forms) • 2. A historical transformation of society following World War II • 3. A new form of theorizing about the contemporary historical moment • 4. Social, cultural, & economic life under late capitalism • D. Influential postmodern theorists include Jean Baudrillard, Jacques Derrida, Michel Foucault & Jean-Francoise Lyotard

  26. Postmodernism, con’t. • E. Some key concepts: • 1. Truth & knowledge • a. Postmodernism disavows truth, especially the notion of absolutes & universals. • b. Knowledge is a discourse that becomes an accepted statement of truth, or "metanarrative“ • 1) Metanarratives set their own criteria or standards for what counts as truth (e.g. science). • 2) Must be skeptical about metanarratives • c. Postmodernism also attacks the law of non-contradiction (that an object cannot be both A & not A), seeing it as an instrument for control

  27. Postmodernism, con’t. • 2. History & subject • a. Postmodern society tends toward disconnection & fragmentation--runs counter to the modernist impulse to order & define • b. Postmodernism "eschews history; humans exist in fragmented current moments." (Gill, p. 202) • c. Thus it reflects "the end of history"; or the end of the metanarrative of linear historical progress

  28. Postmodernism, con’t. • d. Postmodernism also argues for the "death of the subject“ • 1) Individuals occupy positions in various language games or "communication circuits," (where we are both sender-receiver) • 2) The self is socially & linguistically constructed, a position which generally denies autonomy & individualism • e. The postmodern critic asserts that the author/artist/creator of discourse has no special privileged status in determining meaning

  29. Postmodernism, con’t. • 3. Embracing low/popular culture. • a. Consists of a “degraded landscape of schlock & kitsch, of TV series & Reader's Digest culture, of advertising & motels, of the late show & the grade-B Hollywood film," with romance novels, murder mysteries, science-fiction, etc. (David Lodge, 1988) • b. Popular culture is integrated with all other culture, with past & present mixed together • c. Gill notes that such art can be "sexually explicit, rebellious…critical of both political & social norms. It also is schizophrenic & disorderly" (p. 203)

  30. Postmodernism, con’t • F. Some postmodern elements: • 1. Simulacra of experience--a type of "virtual reality" or hyperreality, as in video games • 2. Pastiche--a mixture of elements not normally connected; a "crazy quilt" of images, etc. • 3. Self-referential elements--there is a self-consciousness that occurs through multiple allusions & intertextuality • 4. Spectacle--over inflated staging of events, designed to promote euphoria • 5. Overcommodified--focus on clutter & consumption • 6. Contradictory images—paradox is embraced

  31. Postmodernism, con’t • G. Todd Gitlin (1989) offers this perspective on postmodernism: "It self-consciously splices genres, attitudes, styles. It relishes the blurring or juxtaposition of forms (fiction-non-fiction), stances (straight-ironic), moods (violent-comic), cultural levels (high-low) . . . It takes pleasure in the play of surfaces, & derides the search for depth as mere nostalgia." • 1. Postmodern American society offers "culture as garage sale" • 2. Gitlin’s list of postmodern examples include architecture, Andy Warhol's multiple image paintings, Disneyland, Las Vegas, shopping malls (especially mega malls), William Burroughs, Monty Python, science-fiction/action films, MTV, etc.

More Related