1 / 33

Infant Male Circumcision in Botswana as Part of Public HIV-Prevention Efforts

Infant Male Circumcision in Botswana as Part of Public HIV-Prevention Efforts. Rebeca M Plank, MD Botswana-Harvard Partnership 10 June 2010. World Health Organization.

denver
Download Presentation

Infant Male Circumcision in Botswana as Part of Public HIV-Prevention Efforts

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Infant Male Circumcision in Botswana as Part of Public HIV-Prevention Efforts Rebeca M Plank, MD Botswana-Harvard Partnership 10 June 2010

  2. World Health Organization • WHO recommends neonatal circumcision should be a component of prevention campaigns since “neonatal circumcision is a less complicated and risky procedure than circumcision performed in young boys, adolescents or adults [and] countries should consider how to promote neonatal circumcision in a safe, culturally acceptable and sustainable manner (WHO / UNAIDS, 2007).”

  3. 100,157 circumcised 62 local infection 8 bacteremias 83 bleeding (3 transfusions) 20 surgical trauma 20 UTIs No deaths 35,929 uncircumcised 88 UTIs 32 bacteremia 3 meningitis 2 renal failure 2 deaths Neonatal Circumcision: Safety Wiswell et al. Pediatrics 1989;83(6):1011-5

  4. Virtually bloodless No sutures Fast healing ~ 7-10 days Low complication rate No risk of sex before healing By the time an adult decides, he may be infected No loss of time from school or work Infant circumcision about 1/10th cost and time Cost versus discounted savings: Neonatal Circumcision: Safety and Sustainability Binagwaho PLoS Med 2010 19;7:e1000211

  5. Cultural Acceptability: Botswana • Traditional until ~ 1900 in Mochudi, others • Revived in 1975-1982 • Circumcisions done in hospital but expensive • July 2009: 1300 initiates circumcised medically in 10 days • MOH helped with costs • Will be repeated this year

  6. Table 1

  7. Results • Fifty-seven (95%) women reported being tested for HIV within the last year • Twenty-one (35%) reported being HIV+ • Forty-six (77%) had previously heard that male circumcision could affect a man’s chances of becoming infected with HIV • Thirty-one (52%) said they thought male circumcision partially protected a man from being heterosexually infected with HIV • Twenty-six (43%) thought male circumcision completely protected a man from being heterosexually infected with HIV

  8. If it were available, would you be interested in having your new son circumcised at this hospital by a trained doctor? Yes (91.7%) No (6.7%) “Unsure” (1.7%)

  9. Top 3 Reasons for Circ Protect him from future infections such as HIV (98%) Protect him from bladder infections as an infant (82%) Hygiene (71%) Cultural, traditional or religious reasons (36%) Personal preference (9%)

  10. Conclusions / Discussion • Male infant circumcision appears to be highly acceptable in Botswana • Protection from HIV / other infections appears to be a major motivation • The exaggerated perception of the protective benefit of MC and concerns about comfort and safety must be carefully addressed • Assessment of the actual uptake, safety and sustainability of expanded infant MC services deserves urgent attention

  11. Aims of Current Study • Determine the acceptability by actual uptake of infant male circumcision and identify barriers • Estimate the feasibility and safety • Primary outcomes will be rate of significant complications such as bleeding, infection or need for repeat procedure • Estimate what, if any, advantages would exist for sustainable scale up of Mogen Clamp versus Plastibell • Human resources, equipment needs, adverse events and acceptability to parents and providers in Botswana

  12. Gomco Clamp

  13. Plastibell

  14. Plastibell • Standard surgical instruments • Visualize the glans prior to procedure • Little risk of bleeding • Retained ring • Infection (tissue) • Infection (bladder) • Supply chain must be reliable

  15. Mogen Clamp • No retained ring • Higher theoretical risk of bleeding • Could amputate part of glans • Need sterilization or high level disinfection including water and limited by number of clamps

  16. Aim 1: Actual Acceptability • 191/300 babies randomized • In Mochudi 100 mothers brought baby for circumcision (85% of those interviewed and 71% of ALL mothers approached) • In Gaborone 70 have brought baby for circumcision (42% of those interviewed and 19% of ALL mothers approached) • 100% follow-up

  17. Aim 2: Safety (100) • Three cases of minor bleeding immediately following the procedure, all controlled with local pressure • No local infections • No case of damage to urethra or glans • Study physician subjectively dissatisfied with 19 cases • All photos to be reviewed by two pediatric urologists • One case of retained Plastibell removed at day 17 without sequelae

  18. Aim 3: Sustainability • One infant death day of life 3 • Reviewed by 5 regulatory bodies • Thought due to neonatal sepsis NOT related to circumcision • Infant health and implications for scale-up • < 28 days  risk neonatal death • > 28 days  risk bleeding • > day 1 risk of not returning • < 4 weeks exclude those observing confinement • < day ? exclude out of hospital births

  19. Future Directions: Arm 3 • Like the Plastibell, there is a “bell” that protects the glans. • There is also an adjustable foreskin holder that allows positioning and repositioning PRN • The device acts as the clamp and blade • The blade is retained within the device (self-destructs) and prevents reuse

  20. Future Directions: Arm 3 + • The AccuCirc comes in a self-contained kit • Simplifies supply chain • No parts are retained • All items are one-time use (no sterilizing) • These design advantages make it an excellent candidate for task shifting as midwives, nurses and clinical officers could easily learn to perform the procedure safely

  21. Take Home Points • Neonatal circumcision is acceptable • Acceptability can increase with education • Begin active process in ANC • Neonatal circumcision is safe • Plastibell will require active follow-up and well prepared primary providers • Sustainability will depend on timing of procedure with regard to local infant mortality and increased likelihood of follow-up • UNAIDS / WHO Review completed

  22. The best time to plant a tree is 20 years ago. The next best time is now. Thank you

  23. Shahin Lockman Nnamdi Ndubuka Joseph Makhema Janet Mwambona Fatima Hussein Ali Ali Poloko Kebaabetswe Chiapo Lesetedi Mompati Mmalane HUPA CFAR PEPFAR / BOTUSA / CDC NIH K23-AI-084579 ASTMH / Burroughs Wellcome Jane Magetse Magdeline Mabuse Maggie Ngkau Max Essex Roger Shapiro David Bangsberg Ron Bosch Daniel Halperin Barbara Bassil Thank you

More Related