A Polish system for suspension of environmental penalties as a mechanism promoting environmental inv...
This presentation is the property of its rightful owner.
Sponsored Links
1 / 13

Krzysztof Wójcik – Regional Inspectorate for Environmental Protection in Lodz PowerPoint PPT Presentation

  • Uploaded on
  • Presentation posted in: General

A Polish system for suspension of environmental penalties as a mechanism promoting environmental investments . Krzysztof Wójcik – Regional Inspectorate for Environmental Protection in Lodz Malta 2013 – 1 – 4 October. Environmental penalties in Poland.

Download Presentation

Krzysztof Wójcik – Regional Inspectorate for Environmental Protection in Lodz

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript

Krzysztof w jcik regional inspectorate for environmental protection in lodz

A Polish system for suspension of environmental penalties as a mechanism promoting environmental investments

Krzysztof Wójcik – RegionalInspectorate for EnvironmentalProtection in Lodz

Malta 2013 – 1 – 4 October

Environmental penalties in poland

Environmentalpenalties in Poland

  • Fines (given by environmentalinspectors) -maximum of about 250 euro or 1250 euro ifimposed by a court;

  • Financial administrativepenalties (imposed by regionalinspectorates) – evenseveralthousands of euro;

  • Otheradministrativepenalties (such as halting of installationsimposed by


Environmental penalties in poland1

Environmentalpenalties in Poland

  • Fines: minor infringements of environmental law;

  • Imposed by aninspectoror by a court;

  • Ifimposed by aninspector – no possibility of avoidance.

Environmental penalties in poland2

Environmentalpenalties in Poland

  • Otheradministrativepenalties – halting of aninstallation;

  • Seriousinfringements, e.g.:

  • operatingwithoutanenvironmentalpermit,

  • operatingthatcauses a threat to the environment orhumanhealth.

Environmental penalties in poland3

Environmentalpenalties in Poland

  • Financial administrativepenalties;

  • Generally - imposed for excessiveemissions (thanemission limit valuesstated in environmentalpermits);

  • Obligatory (aninspectoratehas no possibility to dissent from them);

  • Administrativeprocedure – possibleappeal from a decision of a regionalinspectorate to the ChiefInspectorate and even to anadministrativecourt;

Financial administrative penalties examples

Financial administrativepenalties - examples

  • Supposethat ELV for emission of dustis 88 kg/ hour;

  • Aninstallationemits 100 kg/hourwhichisconfirmed by monitoring;

  • They emit 12 kg over the limit and operateallday for about 220 days per year;

  • It meanstheyhave to pay 0,14 euro x 12 kg x 220 whichis 369 euro per year.

Financial administrative penalties examples1

Financial administrativepenalties - examples

Emission of noise above 6 decibels of the Polish standard during nights means that an operator is to pay about 35 euro per day – if it operates 200 working days per year, the penalty reaches 7 000 euro.

Financial administrative penalties examples2

Financial administrativepenalties - examples

  • Therewerehugepenaltiesimposed in the 90’s and at the beginning of XXI century on sewagetreatmentplantsthatweresuspended and not payedatall(evenseveralhundreds of euro).

  • Thisisbecause of a suspension mechanism in the Polishenvironmental law.

Financial administrative penalties suspension

Financial administrativepenalties - suspension

  • Ifan operator applyto itsregionalinspectoratewith an application in which he/she obliges himself/herself to modernise the installation in such a way it will no longer break the emission limit values, payment of the penalty will be suspended for a maximum period of 5 years.

Financial administrative penalties suspension1

Financial administrativepenalties - suspension

  • After that period, if standards are not broken, the penalty is lowered by deduction from its total amount the amount of money spent for modernisation. It also means that there might be no penalty at all – if the amount of money spent for modernisation is higher than the amount of penalty.

  • If an operator does not realisemodernisation on time, he/she has to pay the total amount of the penalty + official interest rates.

Financial administrative penalties summary

Financial administrativepenalties - summary

  • In 2012:

  • RegionalInspectorate for EnvironmentalProtection in Lodzimposed 104 financialpenalties of the totalamountabout 833 000 euro;

  • 6 penaltiesweresuspended of the totalamount 592 000 euro – most of the sum for one sewagetreatment plant in a city of Piotrkow.

Financial administrative penalties summary1

Financial administrativepenalties - summary

  • Is the system fair?

  • One of commentsheard in a radio: „theypollutedheavily and theywillpaynothing”;

  • It promotes environmental investment – all in all the target is to be in line with ELVs;

  • The money from penaltiesareredistributed for accounts of Polishfunds of environmentalprotection and water management and thanks to iteven a single homeownermaybuysolarpannels for itshouse.

Thank you for attention

Thankyou for attention

[email protected]

  • Login