1 / 12

Philosophical Chairs

Philosophical Chairs. The Theory Behind It. For effective learning to occur, students must become explicitly aware of their own (mis) conceptions about a particular topic. Student "errors" should be illuminated rather than avoided and "contradictions" explored rather than ignored.

darlinew
Download Presentation

Philosophical Chairs

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Philosophical Chairs

  2. The Theory Behind It • For effective learning to occur, students must become explicitly aware of their own (mis) conceptions about a particular topic. • Student "errors" should be illuminated rather than avoided and "contradictions" explored rather than ignored. • Students can resolvecognitive dissonance brought about by exposure to alternative perspectives or errors in thinking.

  3. How It Works • Upon entering class, students will receive an article to read on a controversial topic.

  4. How It Works • The topic should elicit a mixed response. • Some people agree whole-heartedly while others vehementlydisagree with the premise for many reasons. • Still others will reserve judgment until or unless they hear something to persuade them one way or the other.

  5. How It Works • Students will have a chance to argue the merits of the topic and will be seated according to their views. • Sitting on one side of two rows of facing chairs indicates one's total support of the topic. • Sitting at the other side signals a student’s total disagreement. • Students who have undecided views or have questions to ask sit behind or at the end of the two rows

  6. How It Works The Moderator • Job is to insure everyonegets a chance to speak. • May be the teacher or a student. • They should allow participants to address a statement made by a particular person • Be careful that the "pros," "cons," and "questions" are equally represented • Make sure the discussion is not dominated by a few eager students.

  7. How It Works • Students are able to move about the room during the discussion, similar to a game of musical chairs. • Participants can symbolize their willingness to adopt a different point of view — even if temporarily — by moving in the direction of that view and assuming a new location. • To insure that movement takes place, students can receive "credit” for participation or taking multiple viewpoints.

  8. Suggested Rules 1. Be open-minded. Listen to all statements made and consider both sides. 2. Move to the other side if a particular statement or argument seems to sway your thinking. Experience the "other side." 3. No one acknowledges any move. This is not a team game. 4. Do not raise hands or speak while another person is speaking Rules

  9. Tips • Statement should be written on the board • The mediator must be neutral • When necessary, mediator paraphrases or restates statements for clarification (in an unbiased manner) • Modify the statement or switch topics when discussion becomes stagnant • For closure, allow each student thirty seconds to express an opinion • Assign a writing activity for follow-up

  10. Sample Topics • Movies should not be rated. • All schools should require uniforms. • Couples should not be allowed to have more than two children. • Drug & alcohol treament should be free. • Abortion should/should not be legal. • There is more bad than good in the world. • Women who damage their babies (before birth) should go to prison. • No marriage until you’re both 21.

  11. Tips • Smoking should be illegal. • People should wait until the age of 21 to get married. • Most people on welfare are lazy. • Parents should have to pay a fine when their kids skip school. • Everyone would be better off without TV. • Minors should always be tried as adults. • Parents who do not put seatbelts on their children should go to jail.

  12. Designedby The AVID Team

More Related