Price signals and metering
This presentation is the property of its rightful owner.
Sponsored Links
1 / 30

PRICE SIGNALS AND METERING PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 83 Views
  • Uploaded on
  • Presentation posted in: General

Conservation or CRISIS A Northwest Choice. Conservation or CRISIS A Northwest Choice. PRICE SIGNALS AND METERING. “Retail Rate Issues” Steve Shurbutt GDS ASSOCIATES, INC. RETAIL RATE ISSUES Overview. Traditional Rate Structures Innovative Rate Structures

Download Presentation

PRICE SIGNALS AND METERING

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript


Price signals and metering

Conservation or CRISIS

A Northwest Choice

Conservation or CRISIS

A Northwest Choice

PRICE SIGNALS AND METERING

“Retail Rate Issues”

Steve Shurbutt

GDS ASSOCIATES, INC.


Retail rate issues overview

RETAIL RATE ISSUESOverview

  • Traditional Rate Structures

  • Innovative Rate Structures

  • BPA Innovative Rate Pilot Program

    • Purpose

    • Targeted Customer Classes

    • Parameters

    • Results

GDS Associates, Inc.


Traditional rate structures decades of change

TRADITIONAL RATE STRUCTURESDecades of Change

  • 1960’s – Promotion (growth)

  • 1970’s – Inflation ( conservation)

  • 1980’s – Marketing (utility aggressive)

  • 1990’s – Competition ( customer aggressive)

  • 2000’s – Survival ( ? ? ? )

GDS Associates, Inc.


Traditional rate structures standard rate components

TRADITIONAL RATE STRUCTURESStandard Rate Components

  • Customer Charge

    • Metering and Billing ($3.00)

    • Minimum Distribution System ($15.00)

  • Demand and Energy Charges

    • Generation

    • Transmission

    • Distribution

    • Return

GDS Associates, Inc.


Traditional rate structures demand pricing alternatives

TRADITIONAL RATE STRUCTURESDemand Pricing Alternatives

  • Non-Coincident Peak

    • Monthly

    • Seasonal

    • Ratcheted

  • Time-of-Day

  • Coincident Peak

  • Interruptible

GDS Associates, Inc.


Traditional rate structures energy pricing alternatives

TRADITIONAL RATE STRUCTURESEnergy Pricing Alternatives

  • Declining Block

  • Flat

  • Inverted Block

  • Time-of-Season

    • Winter Months

    • Summer Months

  • Time-of-Day

    • On-Peak Hours

    • Off-Peak Hours

GDS Associates, Inc.


Innovative rate structures current and future

INNOVATIVE RATE STRUCTURESCurrent and Future

  • Demand (Commercial and Industrial)

    • Curtailment

    • Buy Back

    • Real-Time Pricing

  • Energy (Residential)

    • Conservation Credit

    • Inverted Block

      • Base Rates

      • Power Cost Adjustment

    • Time-of-Use (seasonal, daily)

    • Renewable Resources

    • Real-Time-Pricing

GDS Associates, Inc.


Bpa pilot program purpose

BPA PILOT PROGRAMPurpose

  • Promote Conservation via Retail Rate Price Signals

  • Enhance Retail Utilities’ Knowledge

    • General Understanding of Rate Structures

    • Awareness of PNW Rate Structures

  • Introduction to Innovative Rates

    • Benefits

    • Barriers to Implementation

  • User-Friendly Innovative Rate Evaluation Tool

    • Revenue Impacts

    • Demand Impacts

GDS Associates, Inc.


Bpa pilot program targeted customer classes

BPA PILOT PROGRAMTargeted Customer Classes

  • Residential

  • Small Commercial

    • Less Than 50 kW

      Note: Many programs are already in place for individual customers, irrigation customers, etc.

GDS Associates, Inc.


Bpa pilot program parameters

BPA PILOT PROGRAMParameters

  • Promote Conservation

    • Peak Demand

    • High-Priced Energy

  • Immediate Implementation

    • Standard Metering

    • Existing Billing Systems

  • Relatively Easy to Administer

    • Retail Utility Staff

    • Customer Education

GDS Associates, Inc.


Bpa pilot program results

BPA PILOT PROGRAMResults

  • Spreadsheet Model Developed

    • Structures: Inverted, Time-of-Season, Time-of-Day

    • Energy Use Data from BPA ELCAP Study

    • Elasticities from US DOE/EIA

  • Innovative Rate Examples Developed

    • Based on Sample Utility Data

    • Achieve Material Demand Reductions

      • Static 2000 Price – Before 2001 BPA Rate Increase

      • Status Quo Price – Uniform ¢/kWh WPC Recovery

      • Innovative Rate Price

GDS Associates, Inc.


Determination of inverted block rates residential kwh

Determination of Inverted Block RatesResidential (¢/kWh)

GDS Associates, Inc.


Residential inverted block alternative 1

Residential Inverted BlockAlternative 1

GDS Associates, Inc.


Residential inverted block alternative 11

Residential Inverted BlockAlternative 1

GDS Associates, Inc.


Residential inverted block alternative 2

Residential Inverted BlockAlternative 2

GDS Associates, Inc.


Residential inverted block alternative 21

Residential Inverted BlockAlternative 2

GDS Associates, Inc.


Determination of time of season rates residential kwh

Determination of Time-of-Season RatesResidential (¢/kWh)

GDS Associates, Inc.


Residential time of season alternative 1 on peak

Residential Time-of-SeasonAlternative 1 – On-Peak

GDS Associates, Inc.


Residential time of season alternative 1 off peak

Residential Time-of-SeasonAlternative 1 – Off-Peak

GDS Associates, Inc.


Residential time of season alternative 1

Residential Time-of-SeasonAlternative 1

GDS Associates, Inc.


Residential time of season alternative 2 on peak

Residential Time-of-SeasonAlternative 2 – On-Peak

GDS Associates, Inc.


Residential time of season alternative 2 off peak

Residential Time-of-SeasonAlternative 2 – Off-Peak

GDS Associates, Inc.


Residential time of season alternative 2

Residential Time-of-SeasonAlternative 2

GDS Associates, Inc.


Determination of time of day rates residential kwh

Determination of Time-of-Day RatesResidential (¢/kWh)

GDS Associates, Inc.


Average residential price

Average Residential Price

GDS Associates, Inc.


Average commercial price

Average Commercial Price

GDS Associates, Inc.


Residential demand alternative 1

Residential DemandAlternative 1

GDS Associates, Inc.


Residential demand alternative 2

Residential DemandAlternative 2

GDS Associates, Inc.


Residential change to status quo alternative 1

Residential % Change to Status QuoAlternative 1

GDS Associates, Inc.


Residential change to status quo alternative 2

Residential % Change to Status QuoAlternative 2

GDS Associates, Inc.


  • Login