Social elites the aristocracy and the bourgeoisie
This presentation is the property of its rightful owner.
Sponsored Links
1 / 34

Social elites: The aristocracy and the bourgeoisie PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 57 Views
  • Uploaded on
  • Presentation posted in: General

Social elites: The aristocracy and the bourgeoisie. Dr Chris Pearson. Social classes in 19 th century France. Elites (week 3) Working classes (week 4) Peasants (weeks 5 and 7). How do we define these classes and membership of them?

Download Presentation

Social elites: The aristocracy and the bourgeoisie

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript


Social elites the aristocracy and the bourgeoisie

Social elites: The aristocracy and the bourgeoisie

Dr Chris Pearson


Social classes in 19 th century france

Social classes in 19th century France

  • Elites (week 3)

  • Working classes (week 4)

  • Peasants (weeks 5 and 7)


Social elites the aristocracy and the bourgeoisie

  • How do we define these classes and membership of them?

  • Did members of the class self-consciously see themselves as e.g. working class or bourgeois?

  • How unified were the classes and how did they change over the course of the nineteenth century?

  • What was the relationship between the different classes? Antagonistic? Co-operation? Fear?


An important question

An important question!

  • Is class a “natural” given – determined by income and other socio-economic factors or is it something that is created (or constructed)?


Lecture outline

Lecture outline

  • Defining the elite

  • The aristocracy

  • The bourgeoisie


Grands notables landed magnates

Grands notables (landed magnates)

  • Pay over 1,000 francs a year in tax and ‘the great magnate has possessions, has knowledge, has connections, has a family, has an office which gives him part of public authority… he has a name and often a title, he is a notable as a function of what he has.’

    André-Jean Tudesq, Les Grands notables en France, vol 1. p. 457


Defining the elite

Defining the elite

  • Financial (certain level of income and property)

  • Political (access to power – voting, law-making, ensuring its own interests are met)

  • Cultural (shared attitudes and way of life - formed, in part, through education)


The aristocracy

The aristocracy

  • Ancien régime: approximately 1 in 200 of the population (25,000 families, approx 125,000 members).

  • Owned one third of land property, dominated society


Seigneurial dues

Seigneurial dues

  • Regular payments of cash or produce (crops) made by farmers who lived and worked on the aristocracy’s land.

    Champart - one-twelfth or one-sixth of major crop given to the nobility


Aristocracy and the french revolution 1789 onwards

Aristocracy and the French Revolution (1789 onwards)

1,518 or 0.6% of nobles executed

16,000 or 8% emigrated

Half of aristocratic families lost land

BUT:

Still owned 20% of land

Remained amongst France’s ‘grands notables’

Still dominated peasants, esp in the Vendée


Aristocrats and the first empire 1804 1814

Aristocrats and the First Empire (1804-1814)

Napoleon: ‘I offered them ranks in my army, but they did not want them, offices in my administration, but they refused them. But I opened the antechambers of my household, and they rushed in’


Social elites the aristocracy and the bourgeoisie

  • 1808 Emperor Napoleon creates ‘imperial nobility’ which numbered 3,364 by 1815

  • Attempt to fuse ancien régime and revolutionary elites

  • By 1814, 43% of prefects were nobles


Social elites the aristocracy and the bourgeoisie

Mathieu-Louis Molé


The restoration an indian summer for the aristocracy

The restoration: An Indian summer for the aristocracy?

  • The “White Terror”

  • Nobles take key posts in administration and seek revenge on regicides

  • By 1829, 75% of prefects are nobles

  • Emigrés return

  • 1825 compensation law

  • Nobles continue to exert an influence with the Catholic clergy


Map of noble electors 1820 gibson p 18

Map of noble electors (1820), Gibson p.18


Social elites the aristocracy and the bourgeoisie

They contribute ‘nothing directly’ to society - Henri de Saint-Simon


Delacroix liberty leading the people 1830

Delacroix, Liberty leading the people (1830)


The aristocracy post 1830

The aristocracy post-1830

  • Some fight back: Duchesse du Berry’s (failed uprising) of 1832

  • Some retreat to their estates and try to recreate the ancien régime: e.g. Comte Théodore de Quatrebarbes (Vendée)


Th odore hersant de la villemarqu 1815 1895

Théodore Hersant de La Villemarqué (1815-1895)


Political survival

Political survival

  • Fear of Political violence and upheaval

  • 1848 revolution and declaration of Second Republic

  • Some nobles react by forming the ‘Party of order’ with conservative bourgeois e.g. Molé, Charles de Falloux, Charles de Rémusat


Charles de r musat

Charles de Rémusat


Reinventing themselves

Reinventing themselves

  • Embracing capitalism: Benoit d’Azy owned a metal works in Alais

  • But some fears of degrading themselves by making money

  • Internal migration and agricultural modernization on some estates


Social elites the aristocracy and the bourgeoisie

Links with the bourgeoisie

  • Greater links with the bourgeoisie – marrying into money (some bourgeois keen to marry into nobility, others added a ‘de’ before their surname)

  • But also attempts to preserve aristocratic lifestyles – ‘conspicuous consumption,’ hunting, houses in cities and country

  • Low rates of intermarriage


The aristocracy under the third republic

The aristocracy under the Third Republic

  • 1873 – comeback?

  • No, as the Third Republic is consolidated

  • Gibson: the ‘easy-going, paternalist and often charitable’ nobles lost ‘hearts and minds of Frenchmen,’ especially of the peasantry

  • Outdated worldview

  • Waning economic power: ‘the basis of power, the land… betrayed the notables at a time of agricultural crisis’ Christophe Charle


The bourgeoisie

The bourgeoisie

  • ‘Bourgeois’ – originally meant inhabitant of urban area (but confusingly was also sometimes used to describe rural elite)

  • 12-15% Paris’ population who could afford to pay for their own funeral, had at least one servant, paid certain level of tax (Adeline Daumard’s definition in Les Bourgeois de Paris au XIXe siecle [1970])


Bourgeois diversity

Bourgeois diversity:

  • Haute bourgeoisie – rich financiers and merchants

  • Bonne bourgeoisie – modest lawyers, middling business men, middle-ranking civil servants

  • Petite bourgeoisie – small employers, shop keepers

  • Plus: political, religious, regional differences (see Theodore Zeldin, France 1848-1945)


Creating bourgeois identities

Creating bourgeois identities

  • Carol Harrison in The Bourgeois Citizen in Nineteenth Century France (1999) : bourgeois identity cultural and created (or performed) rather than determined by economic background

  • Cercles [learned societies]: places in which bourgeois male identity was consolidated – provided a way for bourgeois men to enter public sphere and exclude women and others


Common bourgeois values

Common bourgeois values

  • An emphasis on family values and female domesticity

  • Defence of property rights

  • Individualism

  • Respect for education

  • Sobriety

  • Cleanliness

  • Hard work

  • Order (in the public and private spheres)


Gustave flaubert 1821 1880

Gustave Flaubert (1821-1880)


Honor daumier mocks the bourgeoisie

Honoré Daumier mocks the bourgeoisie


Social elites the aristocracy and the bourgeoisie

‘I want neither the commotions nor the popular excesses of a republican government; nor do I want the divine right which claims France as its patrimony, and which wants to smother the progress of reason with the tyranny of aristocracy and absolutism’

Henri-Joseph Gisquet (Paris Prefect of Police in the 1830s)


Did the grande bourgeoisie monopolize power

Did the grande bourgeoisie monopolize power?

  • No, because of:

  • Continuing influence of aristocracy

  • Bourgeoisie too diverse to dominant society (Zeldin)

  • Third Republic more democratic and represented interests of the nouvelles couches sociales (lower middle classes)


Social elites the aristocracy and the bourgeoisie

BUT!!

  • Majority of wealth continued to be held by the few (10% of Lille’s population held 90% of its wealth)

  • Upper bourgeois dominated grandes écoles, administration, and parliament

  • Powerful lobby groups formed to defend capitalists interest i.e. Comité des forges


  • Login