1 / 13

textuality and orality

textuality and orality. cursory remarks. 拜拜. today’s gathering: why these invitees only some modest attempts to generalize 萊頓大學,漢學研究院. long term project. when data are sparse=>long term trends more revealing

cheng
Download Presentation

textuality and orality

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. textuality and orality cursory remarks

  2. 拜拜 • today’s gathering: why these invitees • only some modest attempts to generalize • 萊頓大學,漢學研究院

  3. long term project • when data are sparse=>long term trends more revealing • China scholars connect developments to dynastic boundaries=> find other factors for measuring change, ignore dynasties • processes of change rather than so-called origins=>inventions just the start of something, not the end

  4. materiality • what we really know (in historical sequence): • oracle bones: thrown away • bronze inscriptions: on the inside of vessels with sacrifice • oath slips: buried as sacrifice/testimony • bamboo slips: graves, only later in former archival contexts • wooden slips: archival contexts, communication • silk: graves, probably also for public display and prestige • inscriptions in stone • Qin: invisibly on mountains • Eastern Han: publicly in grave cults, before city gate etc. • metal, pottery : in graves • fibres=> paper: replaces wood for archive and communication; replaces silk much later

  5. the person who writes • prestigious & few & hidden (Shang until mid 4th century BCE) • professional & writing down prestige contents (late 4th century BCE – 1st century BCE)=> scribes~historians≠thinkers • professional & management (3rd century BCE onwards)=> scribes • writing as elite identity (slowly from 1st century CE onwards)

  6. identifying the writer • remarkably late (SimaQian—maybe, mostly second half 1st century BCE) • from “traditions” (not texts) to “canonical books” (of necessity with invented authors) • self-identification as author • stimulated by phenomenon of the written memorial? • author as owner books (late 1st century BCE, think of Ban family)

  7. identifying books • confusion about non-existence of “closed books” before Han=>stories of destroyed books (from the Qin censorial memorial in Shiji) and their discovery • crucial efforts Liu Xiang, Liu Xinc.s. • need: timeline when pre-Han books start being closed down into a canonical version (Lunyuexample)

  8. owning texts/books • patrons • ownership of texts (until after Shiji)=> creation little libraries in “bookform” (Lüshichunqiuonwards, including Shiji) • ownership of single, titled books individuals as owners • what do we know?

  9. but • existence texts or their improved version books is not yet the whole history • is a text communication or record • is it an ultimate record or just a record • groups ideas to personal ideas • are texts read and/or only learned for oral usage • where is the ultimate truth: in the text or in the oral tradition • what happens to the oral • who read, when, where, why • how do texts change the tradition

  10. Wang Mang: questions & claims • uninteresting questions • usurper: and so what, he was more competent and certainly more intelligent than most predecessors • socialist: anachronistic label • Confucianist: what does it mean in the first place? • successful: bad luck of worst Yellow River flooding in centuries • my claim • he reflects a new approach to textuality that presages Confucian/clasicist/Daoist traditions of the following millennia • pace Kang Youwei, he has far more in common with Wang Mang than with Confucius

  11. Wang Mang: precursors • late 1th century BCE recognition “classical” books (≠traditions) as basis political debate • creation first catalogue of discrete objects (Liu Xiang& Xin) instead of ideas or lineages (Sima Tan) • new types of quotations (Lunyuand so on) • first revealed text

  12. Wang Mang’s innovations • based empire on the plan of a quasi-old text (zhouli) instead of new policies for new times • written propaganda distributed to actual people (compare inscriptions Qin) • first consciously incomplete quotation (A 至於 B) • analysis of 劉 • belief in power of renaming • creating fictional portents (from texts) on new scale • large scale upgrading classical scholarship in terms of personnel (later retrospectively ascribed to Emperor Wu)

  13. continuation Wang Mang • Liu Xiu regime • Daoist traditions • classical scholars

More Related