1 / 18

2 Why Government?

2 Why Government?. Why Government?. People generally complain about government So why do we have it? Because anarchy (i.e. Mad Max ) is even worse. Freedom v. Order. We want the freedom to do our own thing But we can’t provide everything for ourselves

Download Presentation

2 Why Government?

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. 2Why Government?

  2. Why Government? • People generally complain about government • So why do we have it? • Because anarchy (i.e. Mad Max) is even worse

  3. Freedom v. Order • We want the freedom to do our own thing • But we can’t provide everything for ourselves • We need to coordinate actions with others to achieve collective goals • We need a certain degree of order to solve the problem of collective action

  4. Collective Action • Collective action is defined in your text as: • Coordinated group action designed to achieve a common goal that individuals acting on their own could not otherwise obtain • What types of things can we do through government that we can’t do on our own? • Do people do these things spontaneously out of the goodness of our heart?

  5. Collective Action and Security • The primary role of Collective Action is to provide Security • What is security? • The ability to protect something of value

  6. The Problem • The problem is that there is a mismatch between the rewards for the individual and the collectivity • If we rely on the individual, we will not achieve our collective result • This is one type of a “Free Rider Problem” • Need to move the decision from the individual to the collectivity

  7. The Solution • 1. Governmental action with enforcement • 2. Exhortation, social/moral pressure • Which is likely to work better?

  8. Structural Problem • Relying on exhortation is only likely to work in a small collectivity with a small cost differential • Typically these are structural problems which require structural solutions

  9. Morality • But we can’t ignore morality completely • “Capitalism only works as long as the values taught by capitalism don’t catch on” (Fred Hirsch, British Banker & Socialist) • What did Hirsch mean? • We may be individually self-interested but we can’t ignore the demands of the community of which we are a part

  10. Examples • If people know the potential result and would rather forego the benefit, is no longer a collective action problem • What other CAP examples can you think of? • Road system, unionization, dumping of wastes, building levees, religious tolerance taxation, boycotts, conservation problems, worker protections, public TV, population growth • How are these collective action problems?

  11. Why Government? • We need government, on behalf of the people, to force people to act collectively • Necessary to overcome our individualistic nature and culture • Government provides the rules by which citizens must play • Policy reflects the interests of those who participate

  12. Anarchy • Anarchy refers to an absence of any kind of overarching authority or hierarchy • This can lead to chaos and violence but need not necessarily do so • Many anarchists (i.e. Thoreau/Rousseau) believe that humans are capable of peacefully intermingling without formalized governmental structures • In a hierarchical situation, the freedom and the power of the individual is constrained

  13. Anarchy and Power • Generally, anarchy is depicted (i.e. Mad Max) as something horrific that never persists for long • In an anarchical environment, power is the ultimate resource • Anarchy can be thought of as the source of government • The collective pursuit of security provides an escape from the threat of anarchy

  14. An Impetus for Government • Many (i.e. Hobbes) believe that rational individuals would prefer even an unpleasant government than none at all • Others (i.e. Locke) believe rational individuals should only surrender those rights that are absolutely necessary for government to protect people’s “natural rights” • Still others (i.e. Rousseau) believe it is society and it’s hierarchy that leads to individual self-interest, inequality and a lack of compassion • Rather, we should reject social inequality by placing the common good or the general will above our own personal interests and then we can be “forced to be free” • Which model do you endorse?

  15. Context of Hierarchy • When societies form governments, they form institutionalized hierarchies • In a hierarchical situation, the coercive power of the authority structure can protect the weak from the strong • Different contexts employ different hierarchies: sometimes you’re the pigeon, other times you’re the statue.

  16. Alliances • Individuals or groups combine resources and abilities in alliances that benefit the individual members of the alliance • The basics of alliance formation can illuminate how governmental structures emerge. • The alliance that is ultimately successful will form a group • Government results from the group’s need to institutionalize its power  

  17. Group Identities • The degree to which members identify with a group and identify who is not part of that group can affect the group’s strength, cohesiveness, and survival • Group membership can often be amorphous • However, you can absolutely define who is not in your group by instigating a conflict with them (the “other” or enemy) • The degree to which people consider themselves part of a group increases when that group is engaged in conflict with another group • Can lead to the “Rally ‘Round the Flag” effect

  18. Leadership Interests • Groups usually form for a specific purpose, but they also tend to continue even after they have accomplished the purpose • Leaders of such groups have made tremendous investments building the group and derive benefits from the group • They subsequently have an interest in the continued existence of the group • Much of what groups – or governments – do is determined by the interest of the leaders • To understand politics, simply ask “who benefits?”

More Related