Poverty and social impact analysis distributional issues in policy reform
Download
1 / 21

Poverty and Social Impact Analysis Distributional Issues in Policy Reform - PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 148 Views
  • Uploaded on

Poverty and Social Impact Analysis – Distributional Issues in Policy Reform. Renate Kirsch Nairobi, Dec 2006. This presentation. Where does it come from What is it and what does it try to achieve How it has been applied in Africa How is relates to the PRSP How it is used at the World Bank

loader
I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
capcha
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about 'Poverty and Social Impact Analysis Distributional Issues in Policy Reform' - bowie


An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript
Poverty and social impact analysis distributional issues in policy reform

Poverty and Social Impact Analysis – Distributional Issues in Policy Reform

Renate Kirsch

Nairobi, Dec 2006


This presentation
This presentation in Policy Reform

  • Where does it come from

  • What is it and what does it try to achieve

  • How it has been applied in Africa

  • How is relates to the PRSP

  • How it is used at the World Bank

  • What are the challenges we face


The context
The Context in Policy Reform

  • PRSPs have given greater impetus to the understanding of impacts of policy reforms on the poor to underpin development strategies

  • PSIA emerged in the context of reforms likely to be supported by PRSC and PRGF operations

    • Includes macroeconomic, structural and sectoral reforms

    • Although the Bank has comparative advantage in poverty analysis, PSIA involves shared responsibility between Bank, IMF and other partners

  • Poverty analysis is not new, recognition that prior ESW was less focused on impacts of specific reforms – systematic application

  • Call for providing policy options to reforms


What is psia
What is PSIA? in Policy Reform

  • PSIA is the analysis of intended and unintended consequences of policy interventions (ex-ante, during implementation, and ex-post) on the well-being of different social groups, with a particular focus on the poor and vulnerable.

  • PSIA focuses on

    • distributional impacts on different stakeholders

    • positive and negative impacts, intended and unintended impacts

    • income and non-income dimensions.


Psia helps
PSIA helps in Policy Reform

To inform the design of reforms:

  • To understand the impact of policy reforms and public actions on different social groups and poverty

  • To analyze tradeoffs between social costs and benefits of reform by assessing opportunities, constraints and social risks

  • To design appropriate mitigating measures and risk management strategies for the reform program, when adverse impacts and risks are unavoidable

    To inform the policy dialog:

  • To underpin policy reforms with empirical evidence

  • To keep a pro-poor focus in policy reform

  • To open space for policy dialogue and enhance transparency and accountability in reform process

  • To build country ownership of policies by informing a public debate on the trade-offs between policy choices


Psia in a policy process
PSIA in a policy process in Policy Reform

Policy Dialogue

Selection of reform for PSIA

Analysis

Monitoring

Recommendation

Policydesign


The dual function of psia
The dual function of PSIA in Policy Reform

  • Approach to support due diligence for donor operations

    • Developed by WB with support from several bilateral agencies

    • Institutional Anchor: Operational Policy for Development Policy Lending

  • Approach to inform national policy making and foster ownership for reform implementation

    • Analytical results can help to change public perceptions and create political space

    • Aims at developing options and scenarios

    • Informs the design of reforms and the implementation process

      Risk of becoming a box ticking exercise if not owned and demanded by national stakeholders


Psias in africa a wide range of reforms
PSIAs in Africa - a wide range of reforms in Policy Reform

  • Agriculture, Rural Development, NRM Reforms

  • Cotton (Mali, Chad, Benin)

  • Tobacco Marketing (Malawi)

  • Maize prices (Kenya)

  • Tea sector privatization (Rwanda)

  • Groundnut sector liberalization (Senegal)

  • Crop boards (Tanzania)

  • Land reform (Zambia)

  • Fertilizer subsidy reform (Zambia)

  • Livestock sector reform (Botswana)

  • Agriculture market closures (Malawi)

  • Agriculture services (Madagascar)

  • Cocoa/coffee taxation (Cote d’Ivoire)

  • Forestry sector (DRC)

  • Coffee liberalization (Burundi)

  • Decentralization, Public Expenditure, Service Delivery Reforms

  • Health service delivery (Madagascar), and user fees (Kenya)

  • Education – public expenditure distribution (Malawi)

  • Primary schools fees (Mozambique)

  • Rural roads (Zambia)

  • Service delivery (Madagascar)

  • Road construction (Ethiopia)

  • Public expenditure prioritization (Cote d’Ivoire)

  • Public sector reform (DRC)

  • Utility Reform/ Privatization

  • Energy/electricity sector privatization/reforms (Ghana, Malawi, Lesotho, Eritrea)

  • Water sector (Mauritania)

  • Mining services (Mauritania, DRC)

  • Rural electrification (Lesotho)

  • Macro Reforms

  • PAMS modeling (Benin, Mauritania, Rwanda, Guinea))

  • Growth and poverty linkages (Cameroon, Burkina Faso)

  • Tax Reforms

  • Local government taxation (Tanzania)

  • VAT and utility sector (Cape Verde)

  • Labour Markets + Social Protection

  • Pension reforms (Kenya)


Ghana electricity pricing
Ghana Electricity Pricing in Policy Reform

Reform Context:

New GOG electricity pricing policy with automatic increases + lifeline protection for the poor; request from GOG to evaluate the poverty impact of reform.

Focus of PSIA

(1) Inform PRSC2 on whether lifeline tariff policy an effective mechanism to protect poor consumers; (2) assess if subsidies an effective means of reaching the poor;

Tools and methods

(1) Consumer and social impact assessments of tariff changes (small-scale household surveys); (2) analysis of nationally representative study on consumer response; (3) stakeholder analysis; (4) social risk analysis /w key informant interviews + focus groups.

Process

Multi-stakeholder steering committee – with diverse interests – to guide process.

Impact

(1) Confirmation of PRSC1&2 reliance on a lifeline to protect poor consumers; (2) discredited assumptions of the reform; (3) lending approved to include off-grid and renewable energy options appropriate for poorer Northern regions.


Drc mining sector reform
DRC Mining Sector Reform in Policy Reform

Reform Context

Retrenchment of 50% of employees of bankrupt state mining company, potential for future privatization to grant foreign investors access to mineral resources + revitalize sector.

Focus of PSIA

(1) Analysis of direct/indirect social costs of reform and monitoring framework; (2) initial focus on impact of retrenchment but subsequently highlighted broader set of issues (e.g. differential impact for remote areas, impacts on those highly dependent on mine services).

Tools and Methods

(1) Stakeholder analysis; (2) social impact analysis using existing baseline data; (3) participatory focus groups in each town; (4) supplementary module on vulnerability/social capital integrated into exit survey for retrenchees.

Process

(1) Collaboration with local university, incl. TOT; (2) local multi-stakeholder consultative groups; (3) substantial dialogue; (4) design of mitigation mechanisms for most severe impacts.

Impact

(1) Assistance to keep 50,000 students in school in order to keep teachers from striking; (2) ongoing dialogue with sectors on mgt options for schools and clinics; (3) creation of local-level information centers; (4) proposal for ring-fenced social services in mine policy paper; (5) local level consultative committee formed to bring in broad set of stakeholders; (6) raised awareness with other active partners (UNICEF) and other stakeholders on severe impacts of reform


Psia relation to prsp
PSIA relation to PRSP in Policy Reform

PSIA an important analytical underpinning of PRS

  • PRSP and MDGs put poverty reduction at the center

  • Increased demand for prior understanding of impacts of policy reforms on different groups

  • PSIA should be part of PRSP process

  • Good institutional home for PSIA is the PRS secretariat

  • Caveat: PSIA can address most individual reforms but cannot address programs such as the PRS


Psia in the prs cycle
PSIA in the PRS-Cycle in Policy Reform

Ex ante

monitoring

Poverty Diagnostic

Strategy design

Monitoring

during implementation

Implementation of reforms


Evolution of psia in the wb
Evolution of PSIA in the WB in Policy Reform

  • Development of approach 2001 with great support from bilateral development agencies

  • Pilot phase 2002 (6 PSIA by WB and 6 by DfID)

  • Founding of PSIA donor network in 2003 (process, participation)

  • Scaling up 2003 -2006, supported by $ 4.5 Mio extra funds (154 PSIA in 72, of which 50 are PRSP countries, in 15 sectors)

  • Institutional anchor via new OP on Development Policy Lending

  • Production of a wide range of knowledge sharing and learning instruments to build capacity

  • 2006 shift in focus towards country led PSIA and launch of capacity building initiative


Where does psia fit in the wb

TA in Policy Reform

  • CapacityBuilding

  • Increasedlocalparticipation

Where does PSIA fit in the WB?

Lending andPolicy Dialogue

ESW

  • Upstream

  • Analysis

  • CEM, PA, CSA

CAS

(PRSP)

Country Level

PSIA

Development

Policy Lending

Program andPolicy Level

Investmentprojects

Economic & SocialAppraisal

Project Level


Psia features
PSIA Features in Policy Reform

  • Average cost: $140,000

    but considerable variation ($40,000 - 200,000)

  • Around 60% PSIA complete analytical work in less than one year; dissemination and policy dialog often continues in second year


Challenges
Challenges in Policy Reform

  • Influencing policy

    • Translating analytical findings into relevant policy recommendations to inform reform design

    • Alignment and link to PRSP process to be more effective

    • Embedding the approach into national policy cycles: PSIA needs an institutional home to incorporate results into the policy process – in most PRSP countries this has been the PRSP secretariat

    • Building on existing systems to contribute to development of national poverty monitoring system, Integrating results into national M&E


Challenges ii
Challenges II in Policy Reform

  • Awareness how PSIA assist in policy reform

  • Capacity to identify when it is needed

  • Capacity to commission and supervise such work

  • Capacity to conduct rigorous analysis


A 10 step approach to psia
A 10 Step approach to PSIA in Policy Reform

1. Selecting the Reform

2. Identifying stakeholders

3. Understanding transmission channels

4. Assessing institutions

5. Gathering data and information

6. Analyzing impacts

7. Enhancing design and compensatory schemes

8. Assessing risks

9. Establishing monitoring and evaluation systems

10. Fostering policy debate and feedback into policy choice


1 selecting the reform and mapping out research questions
1. Selecting the reform and mapping out research questions in Policy Reform

  • Criteria for selection of reform

    • Expected size and direction of impacts

    • Prominence of issue in the government’s policy agenda

    • Timing and urgency of policy or reform

    • Level of national debate surrounding the reform

  • Formulating the key questions

    • Identify key problems/constraints that policy will address

    • Make development objectives explicit

    • Formulate causal hypotheses linking objectives to actions to likely short-term and long-term impacts

  • Define the alternative (other option, status quo)


Upstream or downstream
Upstream or Downstream in Policy Reform

  • Upstream: Assessing the reform issues in a sector to start a discussion over reform options

  • Downstream: Assessing winners and losers of a very specific reform proposal – Risk: narrows space for national debate, mere mitigation of previous policy decision


Operational lesson 1 identify reforms
Operational lesson 1: identify reforms in Policy Reform

  • Need for PSIA should emerge from PRS

    • Identifying reforms for PSIA should be part of national PRS process (no duplication)

    • In practice, work in progress. Selection should strengthen broader process, not undermine/duplicate it

  • Selectivity/prioritization essential

    • Costly and time consuming

    • PSIA most meaningful and effective when applied to specific reforms


ad