1 / 23

April 18, 2007

Draft - for discussion purposes only. CVCA – Top Tips for Underperforming Companies. Exit Strategies – Restructuring, Sale or Wind-down. April 18, 2007. Jamey Gage, McCarthy T é trault LLP John McKenna, PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP. 1. Introduction. 1. 2. Restructuring. 6. 3.

azana
Download Presentation

April 18, 2007

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Draft - for discussion purposes only CVCA – Top Tips for Underperforming Companies • Exit Strategies – Restructuring, Sale or Wind-down April 18, 2007 • Jamey Gage, McCarthy Tétrault LLP • John McKenna, PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP

  2. 1 Introduction 1 2 Restructuring 6 3 Going Concern Sale 12 4 Wind-down and Liquidation 15 5 Summary 19 Agenda Page

  3. Section 1 Introduction 1

  4. Section 1 - Introduction Introduction 2 • Premise: Company in financial difficulty and cannot continue to operate under status quo • Focus: Practical observations about the basic alternatives available and related decision-making process for the Company

  5. Section 1 - Introduction A very frequent problem 3 • Lack of recognition of severity of issue until its too late, due to: • denial/not accepting failure: • trade way out • “tomorrow will be a better day” • last man standing strategy • management agenda conflicts with what’s right for company

  6. Section 1 - Introduction Threshold Question: Can business be made viable if restructured? 4 • Operational restructuring: • headcount reduction • closure/sale of one or more business lines • renegotiation of key contracts • new money for capital investment • Balance sheet restructuring: • re-align stakeholders with their financial reality • “shore-up” balance sheet • Basic alternatives if it cannot be restructured: • going concern sale • wind-down and liquidation

  7. Section 1 - Introduction Operating in the Zone of Insolvency – Factors to Consider 5 • Director and Officer duties and liabilities: • fiduciary duty to company not creditors or shareholders • nevertheless must take into account interests of other stakeholders • statutory personal liabilities • Liquidity Management: • plan ahead; do not wait for the crisis • cost reduction opportunities • managing suppliers and “trading while insolvent” concerns

  8. Section 2 Restructuring 6

  9. Section 2 - Restructuring Practical Considerations in Planning a Restructuring 7 • Does management have experience and credibility with stakeholders to lead restructuring? • Chief Restructuring Officer • Professional advisers • Investigate all realistic restructuring alternatives • Flesh out cost cutting measures • Develop sustainable business plan and strategy to get there • Analyse available liquidity and liquidity management strategies and line-up additional funding • Develop stakeholders’ communication plan • Minimize D&O exposure

  10. Section 2 - Restructuring Informal vs Formal Restructuring - factors to consider 8 • Number of stakeholders and willingness to compromise: • senior and subordinated lenders • trade creditors • employee groups • Time available: • existing liquidity • creditor and other pressures (defaults, maturities, litigation, etc.) • Need for additional liquidity • Cross-border issues

  11. Section 2 - Restructuring Advantages of Formal Restructuring - CCAA 9 • Stays creditors, litigation and other proceedings • Company can reject contracts or try to renegotiate them • Limitations on termination of contracts by counterparties • Facilitates restructuring on large groups of creditors • Brings parties to negotiating table • Directors and officers better protected • Financing can be more easily obtained during restructuring In other words, it maximizes the chance the company has to restructure

  12. Section 2 - Restructuring Advantages of Informal Restructuring 10 • CCAA filing publicity can have negative impact on customers, suppliers and employees • Can be quicker and less expensive • Less impact on value of assets to be disposed • Avoid cross defaults of non-filing entities triggered by a filing • Company’s activities and business plan not subject to same level of challenge or opposition

  13. Section 2 - Restructuring Overview of CCAA 11 • CCAA has eligibility requirements • Main steps in the CCAA process: • Pre-filing preparation • Court application for initial CCAA order • Filing of a CCAA restructuring plan • Creditor meetings to vote on CCAA plan • Court hearing to sanction CCAA plan • Implementation of CCAA plan

  14. Section 3 Going Concern Sale 12

  15. Section 3 - Going Concern Sale Issues to consider re going concern sale 13 • Structure of transaction • Marketing approach • Net realizations • Timing • Holding it all together: • liquidity • employees • customers • suppliers • lenders

  16. Section 3 - Going Concern Sale Is court “assistance” required to facilitate the sale? 14 • Factors to consider: • obtain “DIP” financing • stay enforcement proceedings by creditors • avoid termination of contracts • provide D&O protection • repudiate contracts/leases • buyer protections (vesting order, avoidance of subsequent claims) • formal process to distribute proceeds of sale • Often a “dual” track approach is pursued in CCAA – going concern sale as alternative to restructuring

  17. Section 4 Wind-down and Liquidation 15

  18. Section 4 - Wind-down and Liquidation Direction? 16 • Company vs. creditor controlled process: • Company controlled: • “informal” wind-down • liquidating CCAA • Creditor controlled – receivership: • privately appointed receiver • court appointed receiver • Impact of TCT decision • Receivership may also require bankruptcy: • assists secured lenders • but can cause D&O problems & additional scrutiny of prior activities

  19. Section 4 - Wind-down and Liquidation Practical issues that effect the wind-down/liquidation direction 17 • Holding it all together: • management • employees • customers • suppliers • lenders • liquidity

  20. Section 4 - Wind-down and Liquidation Is court “assistance” required? 18 • Advantages of court proceedings: • facilitates additional financing • stay enforcement proceedings by creditors • counter the actions of employees • can provide buyer protections (vesting order, avoidance of subsequent claims) • provides formal process to distribute proceeds of sale and deal with competing claims • provides D&O protection and can be used to create D&O claims process

  21. Section 5 Summary 19

  22. Section 5 - Summary Summary 20 • There are likely going to be a greater number of distressed companies • There are many ways to deal with distressed companies to maximize value/recovery • Critical to identify the issue early and select the right option • And, of course, retain the right professionals!

  23. Section 5 - Summary Contact details 21 John McKenna, PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP • Tel: (416) 941-8314 • E-mail: john.p.mckenna@ca.pwc.com Jamey Gage, McCarthy Tétrault LLP • Tel: (416) 601-7539 • E-mail: jgage@mccarthy.ca

More Related