1 / 25

Journal RFPs

Journal RFPs. Cara S. Kaufman, Partner, Kaufman-Wills Group www.kaufmanwills.com CSE , 2010. Overview. KWG’s professional experience with RFPs Role of the consultant in the RFP process Pros and cons of contract publishing What publishers need to know to prepare proposals

Download Presentation

Journal RFPs

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Journal RFPs Cara S. Kaufman, Partner, Kaufman-Wills Group www.kaufmanwills.com CSE, 2010

  2. Overview • KWG’s professional experience with RFPs • Role of the consultant in the RFP process • Pros and cons of contract publishing • What publishers need to know to prepare proposals • How to streamline management of the RFP process

  3. Pertinent professional experience

  4. Sampling of RFPs handled by KWG • American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry • American Anthropological Association • American Association of Anatomists • American College of Allergy, Asthma & Immunology • American Dairy Science Association • American Society of Nuclear Cardiology • American Society for Investigative Pathology • American Society for Mass Spectrometry • American Society for Reproductive Medicine • American Urological Association • International Anesthesia Research Society • Gerontological Society of America • Orthopaedic Research Society • The Society of Thoracic Surgeons

  5. Consultants and RFPs

  6. Why do organizations use consultants for RFPs?

  7. Consultant’s role in RFP • Prepare and distribute the RFP • Introduce structure and method to process • Help identify appropriate publishers • Gather information about publication • Prepare documents for approval • Develop and monitor timeline • Evaluate publisher proposals • Respond to publishers’ questions • Compare proposals • Prepare narrative, tables, and spreadsheets • Discuss with client/identify any outstanding issues • Questions, revised offers • Arrange for presentations • Set expectations for society • Moderate discussion following presentations • Inform publishers • Provide feedback • Assist in contract discussions

  8. Qualitative and quantitative analyses

  9. Summary comparison of offers: apples to apples

  10. Pros and cons of contract publishing

  11. Division of responsibilities

  12. Self-publishing

  13. Contract publishing

  14. Typical reasons for transitioning to contract publishing • Lack resources • Infrastructure • Knowledgeable staff • Online capability • International reach • Institutional sales • Pressure from leadership • Begins as an exercise • Financial • Want to show that they can do better • Want to show that they can’t do better • Worried • Revenue trends • Print to e-only transition • Consortia sales • Global reach • Open Access • E-publishing investment • Want information • Learn from process • Acquire ideas

  15. What do publishers need to know to prepare proposals?

  16. RFP elements • Production • Frequency • Number of issues, supplements • Print and online text , society pages • E-platforms • E-features • Marketing/sales • Members • Authors • Subscribers • Industry sales • Communication • Reporting • Consultation • Philosophy • Financials • Transition • Introduction • Society objectives • Deliverables and due dates • Editorial • Editorial mission • Types of content • Peer review • Bibliometrics Size and scope of journal/s Society requirements Information available Society/ consultant preference

  17. Common publisher questions • Journal’s current revenues / costs • Journal’s current and recent circulation by segment • Current consortia or multi-site sales, pricing • Stance on • Print versus e-only • OA • Industry sponsorship • Editorial budget, personnel • Number/percentage of • Author fees waived • OA fees paid • Talk or meet with editor/society? • Editor’s vision? • What’s most important to society? • Seriously considering changing?

  18. Instructions to publishers • Address all the questions posed in the RFP • Order? • Include a brief, easy-to-read summary • Clearly state components of offer • Cover all functional areas • Print and electronic • Single Word or PDF document • Excel file with projections if requested Remind publisher to customize proposal

  19. Streamlining the RFP process

  20. The process at-a-glance

  21. What happens after publisher receives RFP?

  22. Evaluating proposals

  23. Evaluating presentations • The publishing company • Do you believe that the publisher’s mission is aligned with your mission? • Will the publisher’s presence in the field be helpful to the journal? • Are the publishers’ office locations around the world well situated? • The people • Are the individuals with whom you will be working knowledgeable? • Did the presenters work as a team? • Can you envision yourself working with them? • Do you think they would be communicative and responsive? Pointers we give societies to help them evaluate publishers during presentations

  24. Continued… • Editorial and production • Will the publisher uphold your high quality standards? • Is their vision for the journal aligned with yours? • Is the publisher’s e-platform state-of-the-art? • Is publisher’s preferred manuscript management system ok? • Marketing and sales • Did the publisher provide a convincing plan to build awareness, usage, subscriptions, and industry sales? • Is the publisher expert in global institutional sales? • Are you satisfied with how the journal would be treated vis-à-vis the publisher’s other titles? • The Financial Offer • Will you receive complete and regular financial reporting of revenues and costs? • Is the financial offer easy to understand? • Are appropriate rights retained during and after the agreement period? • Are there changes you would like to negotiate? • Can they deliver?

  25. Q&AThank you!

More Related