1 / 117

Cora Lee Wetherington, Ph.D. Women & Gender Research Coordinator National Institute on Drug Abuse

Cora Lee Wetherington, Ph.D. Women & Gender Research Coordinator National Institute on Drug Abuse National Advisory Council on Drug Abuse September 20, 2006. The Pervasiveness of Sex/Gender Differences in Drug Abuse. Gender Differences in Drug Abuse. The Numbers Animal Models

asparks
Download Presentation

Cora Lee Wetherington, Ph.D. Women & Gender Research Coordinator National Institute on Drug Abuse

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Cora Lee Wetherington, Ph.D. Women & Gender Research Coordinator National Institute on Drug Abuse National Advisory Council on Drug Abuse September 20, 2006 The Pervasiveness of Sex/Gender Differences in Drug Abuse

  2. Gender Differences in Drug Abuse • The Numbers • Animal Models • Menstrual Cycle • Predictors • Prevention • Brain Imaging • Prenatal Drug Exposure • Treatment

  3. Gender Differences in Drug Abuse • The Numbers • Animal Models • Menstrual Cycle • Predictors • Prevention • Brain Imaging • Prenatal Drug Exposure • Treatment

  4. Gender Differences: The Numbers Prevalence Data • Drug Use • Drug Dependence

  5. “Any Illicit Drug Use” among Ages 12 & Older Is Higher among Males than Females An exception: Prescription Drug Abuse where Past Month rates are similar 60 Males Females 50 40 Percent 30 20 10 0 Lifetime Past Year Past Month Prescription Drug Abuse 2004 National Survey on Drug Use and Health, SAMHSA, 2005

  6. Gender Differences: The Numbers Prevalence of Drug Dependence:greater for males than females • 9.2% Males • 5.6% Females (1994 Nat’l Comorbidity Survey)

  7. Gender Differences: The Numbers Prevalence of Drug Dependence: greater for males than females • 9.2% Males • 5.6% Females (1994 Nat’l Comorbidity Survey) Arefemales less vulnerable to drug abuse than males?

  8. Gender Differences: The Numbers • Population prevalence • vs • Conditional prevalence

  9. Opportunity to Use Drugs 70 60 Male 50 Female 40 Percent 30 20 10 0 Marijuana Cocaine Hallucinogens Heroin Van Etten et al. (1999) -- 1993 NHSDA

  10. Percent Use Given an Opportunity Van Etten et al. (1999) -- 1993 NHSDA

  11. Gender Differences: The Numbers Calculate Dependence Only among Users: • Males and females = likely to become dependent on cocaine tobacco heroin inhalants hallucinogens analgesics Anthony et al. (1994) Data Source: National Comorbidity Survey

  12. Gender Differences: The Numbers Calculate Dependence Only among Users: • Males more likely than females to become dependent on marijuana alcohol Anthony et al. (1994) Data Source: National Comorbidity Survey

  13. Gender Differences: The Numbers Calculate Dependence Only among Users: • Females more likely than males to become dependent on the cluster of drugs • anxiolytics sedatives hypnotics Anthony et al. (1994) Data Source: National Comorbidity Survey

  14. Gender Differences: The Numbers All Age Groups vs. Adolescents

  15. Gender Differences: The Numbers Monitoring the Future Survey 1975 - Present Annual prevalence of “illicit drug use other than marijuana” • 12th graders: > for boys than girls • (exceptions: 1975 & 1981 girls > boys) • 10thgraders: > for girls than boys (since 1991) • 8th graders: > for girls than boys (since 1991)

  16. Gender Differences: The Numbers Dependence Among Adolescents Users Aged 12-17 Alcohol: boys = girls Marijuana: boys = girls Nicotine: boys = girls • Cocaine : girls > boys 17.4% vs. 4.7% Kandel et al. (1997 ) Data Source: 1991, 1992, 1993 NHSDA

  17. Gender Differences: The Numbers Why do adolescent girls have higher rates of cocaine dependence than boys? • They use cocaine more frequently • They use a greater quantity of cocaine • They report more symptoms at low use frequency Chen & Kandel (2002) Data Source: 1991, 1992, 1993 NHSDA

  18. Gender Differences: The Numbers Risk of Becoming Cocaine-Dependent within 24 Months of First Use Females were 3-4 times more likely than males to become dependent within 24 months of cocaine use onset. O’Brien & Anthony (2005) Data Source: NHSDA 2000-2001

  19. Gender Differences: The Numbers Girls Develop Tobacco Dependence Symptoms Faster than Boys • Time from onset of monthly use to symptoms: • Girls: 3 weeks • Boys: 6 months • # Symptoms among monthly users • Girls: 5.7 • Boys: 4.0 DiFranza et al. (2002)

  20. Gender Differences: The Numbers • Are females are less vulnerable to drugs than males? • If given the opportunity, females are as likely as males • to use drugs • to become dependent • Adolescent females, compared to males, • in 8th and 10th grades are more likely to use “any illicit • drugs other than marijuana” • are more likely to become dependent on cocaine • use more cocaine • use more frequently • develop nicotine dependency symptoms faster

  21. Gender Differences in Drug Abuse • The Numbers • Animal Models • Menstrual Cycle • Predictors • Prevention • Brain Imaging • Prenatal Drug Exposure • Treatment

  22. Gender Differences: Animal Models Do data from animal behavioral models suggest that males are more vulnerable to drugs than females?

  23. Gender Differences: Animal Models • Drug Self-Administration Studies: • Amount of Drug Self-Administered • Reinforcing Effectiveness • Speed of Acquisition of Self-Administration • “Prevalence” of Self-Administration

  24. Gender Differences: Animal Models • 1. Amount of Drug Self-Administered • Females compared to males, self-administer more • alcohol Hill, 1978; Lancaster & Spiegel, 1992 caffeine Heppner et al., 1986 cocaine Morse et al., 1993; Matthews et al., 1999; Lynch & Carroll,1999; Hu et al., 2004 fentanyl Klein et al., 1997 heroin Carroll et al., 2001 morphine Alexander et al, 1978; Hill, 1978; Cicero et al, 2000 nicotine Donny et al., 2000

  25. Gender Differences: Animal Models • 2. Reinforcing Effectiveness (cocaine & nicotine) ·Females reach higher progressive ratio breakpoint for  cocaine (Roberts et al., 1989)  nicotine (Donny et al., 2000) ·Females acquire stronger cocaine-induced conditioned place preference quicker and at lower doses (Russo et al., 2003a; Russo et al., 2003b)

  26. Gender Differences: Animal Models • 3. Speed of Acquisition of Self-Administration • Females acquire self-administration faster than males ·cocaine- approx 1/2 the # sessions (Lynch & Carroll, 1999) ·heroin- approx 2/3 the # sessions (Lynch & Carroll, 1999) • ·nicotine- at lowest dose only (Donny et al., 2000)

  27. Gender Differences: Animal Models • 4. “Prevalence” of Self-Administration (SA) ·More female rats acquire cocaine SA: 70% females vs. 30% males(Lynch & Carroll, 1999) ·More female Rhesus monkeys acquirePCP SA: • 100% females vs. 36.4% males(Carroll et al., 2000) • Similarpercentage of female rats acquire heroin SA: • 90.0% females vs. 91.7% males(Lynch & Carroll, 1999)

  28. Gender Differences: Animal Models • Drug Self-Administration Studies: • Amount of Drug Self-Administered • Reinforcing Effectiveness • Speed of Acquisition of Self-Administration • “Prevalence” of Self-Administration

  29. Gender Differences: Animal Models • Drug Self-Administration Studies: • Amount of Drug Self-Administered • Reinforcing Effectiveness • Speed of Acquisition of Self-Administration • “Prevalence” of Self-Administration • Escalation of Cocaine Self-Administration

  30. Gender Differences: Animal Models • Biological Basis? • Circulating Gonadal Hormones • Estrogen  • Progesterone 

  31. Gender Differences: Animal Models • Biological Basis? • It’s more than circulating gonadal hormones • Gonadectomized rats: Females (vs Males) • acquire cocaine self-administration faster • self-administer more cocaine • Hu et al. (2004)

  32. Gender Differences: Animal Models • Biological Basis? • If not circulating gonadal hormones, then what? • Sexual dimorphism in brain organization during early development: • driven by gonadal hormones • driven by non-hormonal factors

  33. Gender Differences: Animal Models • Biological Basis? • Non-hormonal factors • e.g., in mice & rats chromosomal sex (XX vs XY), not gonadal secretions, determines sexual dimorphism in embryonic mesencephalic dopamine neurons • Reisert et al. (1990) • Kolbinger et al. (1991) • Carruth et al. (2002)

  34. Gender Differences: Animal Models • Biological Basis? Emerging research suggests that study of sexual dimorphismin • brain organization • gene expression • knockout mice are very promising areas to pursue.

  35. Gender Differences in Drug Abuse • The Numbers • Animal Models • Menstrual Cycle • Predictors • Prevention • Brain Imaging • Prenatal Drug Exposure • Treatment

  36. Hormonal Changes During the Menstrual Cycle

  37. Gender Differences: Menstrual Cycle • SMOKED COCAINE • Repeated doses smoked cocaine (0, 6, 12.5 or 25 mg) • In follicular phase (v. luteal phase) • Higher ratings of “high” • Higher ratings of “good drug effect” Evans et al. (2002)

  38. Gender Differences: Menstrual Cycle • ORAL d-AMPHETAMINE • Positive subjective effects > follicular than luteal: • > feeling of “high” • > euphoria (ARCI MBG) • > energy & intellectual efficiency (ARCI BG) • > liking the drug • > wanting the drug • Justice & de Wit (1999)

  39. Gender Differences: Menstrual Cycle Can these findings be capitalized on in treatment settings?

  40. Gender Differences: Menstrual Cycle NICOTINE

  41. Difference Scores in Cue-Induced Craving C R A V I N G S C O R E p < .04 All Males Females F = Follicular L = Luteal F L On a scale of 1 to 10, how much do you desire a cigarette at this moment? Franklin et al. (2002)

  42. Gender Differences: Menstrual Cycle • Nicotine: In the luteal phase • More smoking • More cue-induced craving • During short-term abstinence • more withdrawal symptoms • more depressive symptomatology • more desire to smoke • more desire to relieve negative affect • more weight gain • Quitting during luteal phase produces poorer • short-termabstinence (preliminary data) Implications: Quit smoking during the follicular phase

  43. Gender Differences in Drug Abuse • The Numbers • Animal Models • Menstrual Cycle • Predictors • Prevention • Brain Imaging • Prenatal Drug Exposure • Treatment

  44. Gender Differences: Predictors • Aggressiveness: • Predictor of drug use by boys, but not girls (Ensminger, 1992) Conduct Disorder: • Stronger predictor of drug use and dependence by female than by male adolescents (Costello et al., 1999)

  45. Gender Differences: Predictors Smoking during pregnancy: • associated with smoking by preadolescent female offspring, but not male (Kandel et al., 1994; Weissman et al., 1999) Cigarette use: • stronger predictor of progression to illegal drug use by girls than by boys (Kandel et al., 1992,1998)

  46. Gender Differences: Predictors Family characteristics more predictive of drug use in females than males: • Maternal • alcoholism (Boyd et al., 1993) • drug abuse (Boyd et al., 1993) • Low parental • attachment (Ensminger et al., 1982; Brook et al., 1993) • monitoring (Krohn et al., 1986) • concern (Murray et al., 1983) • Unstructured home environment (Block et al., 1988) • Dysfunctional family (Chatham et al., 1999)

  47. Gender Differences: Predictors Peer Difficulties & Parental Stress: Predictors of Monthly “Bursts” in Use of Tobacco, Marijuana & Alcohol 181 Oregon youth ages 11-14 in 1- vs. 2-parent families • RESULTS: Gender-Specific • Peer Difficulties • Predictor for boys (in both family types) • Not a predictor for girls • Parental stress • Predictor for girls in 1-parent, but not 2-parent, families • Not a predictor for boys • Dishion & Skaggs (2000)

More Related