Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon
This presentation is the property of its rightful owner.
Sponsored Links
1 / 35

SSA 13 : Thau Lagoon “Managing the microbiological contamination of the Thau Lagoon” PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 105 Views
  • Uploaded on
  • Presentation posted in: General

SSA 13 : Thau Lagoon “Managing the microbiological contamination of the Thau Lagoon”. S cience and P olicy I ntegration for CO astal S ystem A ssessment.

Download Presentation

SSA 13 : Thau Lagoon “Managing the microbiological contamination of the Thau Lagoon”

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript


Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

SSA 13 : Thau Lagoon

“Managing the microbiological contamination of the Thau Lagoon”

Science and Policy Integration for COastal System Assessment

José A. Pérez Agúndez, Annie Fiandrino, Johanna Béganton, Rémi Mongruel , Thierry Laugier, Valérie Derolez, Ludovic Cesmat, Ophélie Serais

Hélène Rey-Valette, Sébastien Roussel,François Valette

Gilles Brocard

(NB: GEYSER, in charge of mediation with stakeholders, has retired from SPICOSA)

SAF cluster meeting, 20-21 October 2009, Thessaloniki


Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

Content

  • Introduction : policy issue, scenarios, socio-economic dimensions and structure of the system to be modelled

  • Building the model with Extend (modular use, connections)

  • Watersheds and the Water treatment system

  • Microbiological contamination: monitoring and law enforcement

  • Economic assessment

  • Conclusion : state of work ; interactions with stakeholders


Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

A coastal zone close to thecities of Montpellier and Sète


Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

The detailed structure of the Thau watershed


Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

An overview of the policy issue

  • The general problem : because of rapid local demographic growth and also the importance of tourism, the watersheds of the Thau lagoon are subject to pollution. In particular, events of microbiological contamination may affect the lagoon, with direct consequences on human activities in the Lagoon and also feedbacks to the overall development pattern of the region.

  • The microbiological contamination raises four basic questions:1) What are the impacts of microbiological contamination on shellfish farming and other human activities in the lagoon ?

  • 2) What are the main contamination sources ?

    3) What is the efficiency of the current water treatment system as regards microbiological contamination ?

    4) Which management options would reduce the impacts of MC in a way which would be coherent with the more global local policy objectives ?

  • Another research project, OMEGATHAU (to be completed by the end of 2010), which has been conducted jointly with the local public organisation in charge of Thau Lagoon water management (SMBT), has addressed the 2 first questions. Our approach for the SPICOSA SSA work in the Thau Lagoon is to rely on OMEGATHAU results in order to explore questions 3 and 4.


Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

Policy context : two corresponding management plans

SAGE

The local water management plan,which defines the water policyfor the Lagoon and its watersheds

Coherence of

- perimeters- diagnosis- objectives

A shared diagnosis

SCOT

The territorialmanagement plan,whose perimeter iscoherent with theone defined forthe water policy


Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

The current policy debate and theexpectations from the SPICOSA experiment

  • The local policy framework, which has been set up during the preparation of the Territorial Management Plan (SCoT) gives the general objectives:

    - economic development, including tourism and thermal industry- environment preservation, including water quality and ecosystems protection- maintaining of the cultural patrimony, including traditional activities (shellfish farming, professional fisheries in the lagoon, recreational activities, etc.)

    NB: of course, these objectives generate internal conflicts

  • The local water management plan (SAGE) defines several specific objectives related to the environment policy. One specific objective is the reduction of the water microbiological contamination. The current political debate focuses the ways of translating these objectives into operational management options.

  • In this context, the main purpose of our SPICOSA experiment is twofold:- to assess the efficiency and the costs of new water treatment systemsCost-effectiveness analysis(1: restricted)- to estimate the impacts of various operational management options on the traditional activities and the local economyMulti-criteria analysis (2: extended)


Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

Scenarios definition and system assessment

The definition of scenarios and the assessment of the resulting states of the system will contribute to the local political debate in three different ways.

  • Designing the Water Policythe objective of the MC reduction has to be translated into operational objectives, in particular as regards the sanitary classification of the Lagoon (A or B) and the occurrence of commercial bans for the shellfish farming industry, according to the trends of the system (forcings)definition of scenarios = trends, operational objectives, technical options

  • Searching for the more efficient water treatment systems

    the assessment of possible new water treatment systems (technical options), as regards their costs and their ability to reach one particular operational objectivescosts/effectiveness analysis of simple management options

  • Assessing the impacts of one operational policy objectives- on the regional economy, through the financial analysis of impacted sectors and the induced effects on the other industries and activities- on the broader development concerns (as set up by the SCOT), considering eventually additional management options for traditional activities

    selection of indicatorsmulti-criteria analysis of more complex management options


Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

The economic dimensions

Economic dimension 1:cost-effectiveness analysis of the water treatment systems, according to different technical options.

Approach = investment and running costs of water treatment settlements, considering local public budget constraints

Economic dimension 2: economic dynamics in the shellfish farming industry.

Approach = financial analysis and the vulnerability of businesses to the closures of the shellfish farming area (period during which sales are forbiden)

Additional management options to be tested in complex scenarios = re-allocation of the production capacity of the farms which stop their activity

Economic dimension 3: a regional economy matrix will be used so as to provide macro-economic drivers and indicators at the site scale.

Approach = incorporating direct (pressure and impacts) and indirect (induced effects) relationships between the environment and the macro-economic dynamics of the Thau Lagoon territory (economic feedback loops)


Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

The system and its components


Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

The structure of the Extend Model


Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

The watershed ecological modules


Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

First results of OMEGA-THAU project

  • Investigations to :

  • Identify main E.coli sources (on watershed & onto the lagoon)

  • Estimate for each source (on watershed) E.coli daily load

The watershed ecological modules

  • Every day permanent (and/or seasonal) populations & activities produce E.coli pollutions

  • These E.coli loads can be reduced (or not) by specific treatments

  • These reduced (or not) E.coli loads discharge into the lagoon via local streams

What we need to achieve this goal in extend model ?

To identify Main types of E.coli source on watershed

To formulate (in an analytic way) E.coli daily load for each type of source


Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

The watershed ecological modules

In Extend model (in order to be as well generic as possible) we distinguish these 3 steps

3 different modules

E.coli pollutions production blocks

E.coli pollutions treatment blocks

E.coli pollutions transfer blocks


Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

Permanent population

/seasonal population

.

Daily Produced E.coli load (Cell/d)

.

… During rainfall events

Storm sewers SRC5

Dysfunctioning of sewage network system SRC6

The watershed modules

E.coli pollutions production blocks

Parameters read in Database

For each town on watershed

Nb. of Perm. Inh.

Nb. of tourists

living in houses connected to WWTP SRC1

% of pop. connected to WWTP

Nb. of house with ind. WWT System

living in houses with their own septic tanks SRC2

Seasonal population living in campings with their own WWT systems SRC3

Nb. of tourists in campings during summer

Farming (poultry, horse,…) SRC4

Nb. of farms & Nb. of animals in each farm

1 Eq. Inh = 5,7x10 10 E.coli/d

.

For each type of SRC

State variable saved in Database


Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

The watershed modules

E.coli pollutions treatment blocks

Parameters and state variables read in Database

For each SRC on watershed

Daily Produced E.coli load

Daily Produced E.coli load

E.coli Abatement techniques (or not)

Parameters for treatment method

Daily Treated E.coli load

</=

Daily Produced E.coli load

State variable saved in Database

Empirical values for

abatement in each WWTP depends on :

For instance

SRC1 Daily E.coli load produced by pop. connected to WWTP

  • Season (treatment is more efficient in summer)

  • Meteorological condition (by-pass during rainfall events)

.


Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

The watershed modules

E.coli pollutions transfer blocks

Parameters and state variables read in Database

For each SRC on watershed

Daily Treated E.coli load

Daily Treated E.coli load

Abatement in local stream depends on :

E.coli Abatement due to natural processes during transfer in the local stream (from point source to the lagoon)

  • Distance from point source to the lagoon

  • Season (T90 in stream is higher in summer)

  • Meteorological condition (speed of stream higher during rainfall event)

Daily Transferred E.coli load

</=

Daily Treated E.coli load

State variable saved in Database

.


Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

The watershed modules

E.coli pollutions transfer blocks

In Watershed Database

Number of tables (containing fields associated to Daily Produced,Treated and Transferred E.coli load)

=

numbers of SRC on the watershed

Custom block

Re-arrange daily E.coli load & create one Dynamic_Database per outlet that contains

Total Daily E.coli load (sum of all E.coli load of all SRC on this watershed) and each component of this total load


Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

The water treatment module

  • There are infinite technical ways for reaching the objectives fixed by stakeholders

    • creating new water treatment structures

    • modifying existing structures (size, technology)

    • improving the collection nets

    • management of punctual treatment under-capacity (storms)

  • But the aim of the model is to explore prospective scenarios, not to optimize a public policy


  • Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

    The cost – efficient analysis

    v


    Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

    Operational use of the water treatment module

    by Extend

    • The water treatment module, associated with the hydrologic component, is integrated in the model following two complementary steps

    • 1st → Restrictive model : comparative assessment of water treatment options (several runs)

      • Selection of best possibilities considering general constraints :

        • total budget (operational and investment costs), land availability, opportunity costs, etc.

      • Comparative assessment of water treatment options

      • Hierarchical classification of each option by considering costs and abatement efficiency

    • 2nd → Global model: integration of the selected water treatment options in the prospective model

      • Strategic planning at long run in terms of investments

      • Estimation on global impacts in the model depending of selected scenarios


    Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

    20 local streams on the watershed

    What is the impact of daily E.coli load discharges by each local stream on lagoon water quality ?

    First step : Simulate impact of E.coli discharge

    into the lagoon

    At each time step, at each REMI station (i = 1,9)

    ?

    20

    [E.coli] i = Fctn (S Daily E.coli load,

    Meteorological conditions)

    j=1

    Lagoon contamination module

    INTO THE LAGOON

    National monitoring network (REMI) controls microbiological quality of oysters and mussels to determine category of shellfish production areas.

    9 monitoring stations

    are sampling every first Monday of the month

    If E.coli concentration in shellfish passes a legal level, administration can decide to temporarily forbid shellfish harvesting

    Second step : Simulate surveillance procedure

    and regulation rules


    Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

    Vent faible de secteur S-SE

    Lagoon contamination simulation using 3D model

    First step : Simulate impact of E.coli load discharge into the lagoon by each local streams

    using results of 3D-hydrodynamics model coupled to a biological module that simulate transport, dispersion, mortality of E.coli cells in water lagoon

    100 m x 100 m grid

    10 s level along vertical direction

    Calibration and validation of this 3D model achieve in the framework of OMEGA-THAU project


    Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

    Load 1

    load 1

    load 2

    load 1 & 2

    [E.coli]c1 + [E.coli]c1 = [E.coli]c1

    Load 2

    Lagoon contamination simulation using 3D model

    Sensitivity studies with 3D- model shown

    1) [E.coli] in water can be summed

    2) High impact of wind conditions on [E.coli] in water

    No wind

    Daily E.coli load = 13 Log

    Wind conditions

    O-NO, 36 km/h

    5 characteristics wind conditions are retained :

    315N, 330N, 90N, 150N / 10m/s, No wind)


    Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

    Pallas stream flow (m3/s)

    hours

    Lagoon contamination simulation using 3D model

    Sensitivity studies with 3D- model shown

    3) High impact of temporal distribution of stream flow on [E.coli] in water

    Daily E.coli load = Stream flow x [E.coli]stream

    [E.coli] x Stream Flow = [E.coli] x Stream

    High x Low

    Lowx High

    E.coli discharge during dry weather

    E.coli discharge during rainfall event

    Daily E.coli load = 13 Log

    Wind conditions

    N-NO, 36 km/h

    2 characteristics meteorological conditions are retained :

    dry period, rainfall event : 70 mm in one day


    Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

    Lagoon contamination module


    Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

    The governance module : regulation of sanitary risks due to the microbiologic water charge


    Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

    The governance module : monitoring and regulation

    Risk of contamination

    (rainfall, incident, etc..) ?

    MONITORING

    ALERT

    Level 0

    J = 1er Monday of the month

    If all values < Threshold

    (9/9)

    9 sampling (REMI)

    Alert

    MONITORING J+1

    If 1 value > Threshold (1/9)

    J = J détection du risque

    9 sampling (REMI)

    ALERT

    Level 1

    MONITORING J+2

    If all values < Threshold

    (9/9)

    J = J+ 2

    9 sampling (REMI)

    If 1 value > Threshold (1/9)

    Alert Level 2

    MONITORING

    J = every monday

    All values (9/9),

    Must have 2 values

    < threshold (9/9)

    9 sampling (REMI)

    If 1 value > Threshold (1/9)


    Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

    The Shellfish farming module (1/3)

    • - Figuring the shellfish farming sector

    • Thau lagoon is the principal shellfish farming production area of the French Mediterranean

    • There are globally 540 companies that represent locally a source of direct employment for 2,000 workers (fulltime equivalent estimates). The global production can be estimated slightly higher than 20,000 tons by year and distributed into 60% of oysters and 40% of mussels

    • Companies are segmented into three categories depending on their production capacity. This capacity is directly linked to the number of concessions they own:

      • - Small companies (owning until 4 tables)

      • - Medium companies (owning 4-8 tables)

      • - Big companies (owning more than 8 tables)


    Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

    The Shellfish farming module (2/3)

    - Rationale of the approach

    . No bioeconomic model (such as in SSA10)

    . Each commercial ban potential economic losses

    . Linking the production capacity by type of company, their representative market distribution structure and the selling prices practiced, it is possible to estimate the global revenue obtained by class of company in a “normal” year.

    . A normal year can be considered as an annual economic period with no sanitary closure events. Consequently, it translates the maximum revenue which can be obtained by shellfish companies in the absence of sanitary events.


    Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

    The Shellfish farming module (3/3)

    • Expected output of the shellfish farming module

    • . The shellfish farming box of the model evaluates the economic impacts directly supported by companies due to microbiological water overcharge

    • . Estimation of the economic losses associated to commercial bans due to microbiologic peaks. Effects at short-run: determined by intra-annual economic dynamics and sanitary rules in the governance box

    • . Effects at mid and long-un: image impacts, economic sensibility of companies


    Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

    The macro-economic module


    Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

    The tourism industry

    • There are two ways to integrate the tourism industry in the model

    • (this question is actually under discusion)

    • - Endogenously (feed back): the site attractiveness generates a tourism demand

      • . The objective is to calibrate a function comparing data series of tourism frequentation and an indicator of water quality (sanitary closures as a proxy)

      • . Problem : in water quality other environmental components are included. Separability question

    • - Exogenously : if problems to assess an attractiveness function, the dynamics of the sector can be forced in the scenarios box


    Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

    Conclusion: state of work

    • The modeling activities are going on

    • The model is not complete at the whole but some associated blocks are starting to run

    • Some modules of the model need to be quickly developed

    • High efforts have been made in restructuring the model, programming and integrating

    • We have some incertitude about additional information required for some processes but globally the structure of the model seems enough robust

    • Interaction with local stakeholders will be assured by our Spicosa colleagues participating to the expertise requirements of “Scot” and “Sage”


    Ssa 13 thau lagoon managing the microbiological contamination of the thau lagoon

    Thank you for your attention


  • Login