1 / 8

Ethics & Health Care Reform

Ethics & Health Care Reform. Is there a right to health care? What's right? If there is a right to x , then there is an entitlement to x. If there is a right to x , then society has an obligation to protect or enhance x .

annelise
Download Presentation

Ethics & Health Care Reform

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Ethics & Health Care Reform • Is there a right to health care? • What's right? • If there is a right to x, then there is an entitlement to x. • If there is a right to x, then society has an obligation to protect or enhance x. • In the case of health care, if there is a right to health care, then how much health care is there a right to, and how much of that can we afford to support?

  2. Ethics & Health Care Reform • Rights: Positive and negative sides • e.g. Right to free speech: • Positive: I can speak freely in appropriate situations • Negative: I cannot be prevented from speaking freely in appropriate situations • e.g. Health Care: • I have a right to health care at a certain level provided by the state, i.e., a public health care system • I am not prevented from participating in, nor others from offering, a health care system, i.e. private health care

  3. Ethics & Health Care Reform • Where do rights come from? • God, e.g., Declaration of Independence: Life, Liberty, Happiness • Nature • Social Contract • Government creation

  4. Ethics & Health Care Reform • Rights: • de jure: by law • de facto: by practice • e.g., education • We have the right • We must exercise that right • Government pay and requires education • Why a de facto right? • Economic consequences • Required by a functioning democracy

  5. Ethics & Health Care Reform • Rights are often checked by other rights. • e.g., abortion • Freedom of speech • Rights can have limits. • e.g., Because of cost • Right to health care: Why? • Are education and health care parallel to one another? • Health care enhances equality of opportunity • Health care allows citizens to fully participate in democratic institutions

  6. Ethics & Health Care Reform • Current health care concerns • 42+ million Americans uninsured, many underinsured • Corporations reducing their support for health care • Lack of insurance for pre-existing conditions • Rising costs • Rising paperwork • Maldistribution of physicians and health care institutions

  7. Ethics & Health Care Reform • Current health care concerns • Socialized medicine • e.g., the V.A. • National Health Insurance, government is sole payer, e.g., Canada • Insurance reform or regulation • e.g., Require to cover pre-existing conditions • Government is insurer of last resort • Managed care, HMOs, PPOs, etc. • Main goal: cost control

  8. To a Young Physician • For those patients, tablets of frailty • Storied bodies stretched out before you • Needs upon needs • Look on them with your heart • Let their story - not their history - merge with yours • Touch them with your hands and your words • Let their skin rub on your in concern • Embrace them in their loneliness and anxiety • Let that connect with your own • Hold them in your heart and in your mind • Let their beat rhythm your own • Teach then the causes of their frailty • And let them teach you the causes of your own • Love them as part of a bond • The vulnerable and the wounded • Mercy's kind intent and love's rich content • Be with them for they are your being

More Related