Lecture demonstrations and the force concept inventory
This presentation is the property of its rightful owner.
Sponsored Links
1 / 71

Lecture Demonstrations and the Force Concept Inventory PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 68 Views
  • Uploaded on
  • Presentation posted in: General

Lecture Demonstrations and the Force Concept Inventory. Brian Andersson Physics Education Seminar 3/25/05. Motivation. I was curious to see how demos impact student learning. Is there any reason to believe demos have an impact on FCI scores? Is there enough data to say one way or the other?.

Download Presentation

Lecture Demonstrations and the Force Concept Inventory

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript


Lecture demonstrations and the force concept inventory

Lecture Demonstrations and the Force Concept Inventory

Brian Andersson

Physics Education Seminar

3/25/05


Motivation

Motivation

  • I was curious to see how demos impact student learning.

  • Is there any reason to believe demos have an impact on FCI scores?

  • Is there enough data to say one way or the other?


Overview

Overview

  • To determine if there is any correlation between Phys 1301 FCI results and demo usage

  • Start with the large picture

  • Work down to individual questions


Previous work

Previous Work

  • Sokoloff and Thornton have been working on Interactive Lecture Demonstrations (ILD)

  • Gains on the Force and Motion Conceptual Evaluation are reported to be significantly higher for students taking lectures involving ILDs

    American Journal of Physics65:1, 14 (1997)


Differences

Differences

  • ILDs require an entire class period to perform.

  • Very few demonstrations are actually used.

  • I am looking at standard lecture demonstrations (0-10 demos per lecture, duration 1-5 minutes)

  • Presentation of demos vary from one instructor to the next


Analysis first pass

Analysis - First Pass

  • I looked at the total number of demonstrations used in a semester versus two results from the FCI

    • Average Post Test %

    • Average Relative Gain

  • Analysis covers 1301 classes from Fall Semester 1999 to the present (33 sections)


Initial impressions

Initial Impressions

  • Very messy. No correlation.

  • Try limiting analysis to instructors who have taught 1301 at least 4 times since fall 1999.

  • There are three: Profs X, Y, and Z.


Second pass

Second Pass

  • Again, very little correlation.

  • Previous analysis includes demos not relevant to FCI (rotational dynamics, SHM, etc...)

  • Second analysis involves matching existing demonstrations (FCI demos) to specific FCI questions.

  • Once matches are made, compare usage to Post Test % and RG


Fci demo list

FCI Demo List

QuestionsDemo(s)

1 1C20.10, .15, .16

3 1C20.15, 1D60.05

41H10.13

6 1D55.10, .11

7 1D50.15

8, 9, 10, 11 1N20.40

12 1D60.60, .65

13 1D60.05

14 1D60.10

17 1G20.60

18 1D50.37, .38

25, 26, 27 1K20.10, .15, .20, .30

28 1H10.10, .12


Examples of fci demos

Examples of FCI Demos

  • Question 1 involves two balls identical in appearance but differing in mass by a factor of 2

  • Existing demo involves plastic and steel balls


Fci demos

FCI Demos

  • Some demos do not match to questions exactly, but convey the idea

  • An example is question 28


Third pass

Third Pass

  • The previous plots show little, if any, correlation between FCI demos and the FCI over a wide range.

  • The next step was to focus my analysis on the three instructors who have taught 1301 at least 4 times since 1999

  • I assumed that their teaching style changed little over the years.

  • It was hoped that changes in demo usage might be reflected in FCI scores.


Fourth pass

Fourth Pass

  • Still no convincing data.

  • The next step was to analyze individual instructors and terms.

  • Looked at the Post Test % and RG for each question.

  • Would using FCI demos increase these scores compared to questions not associated with a demo?


Final pass

Final Pass

  • My final analysis involved the comparison of the three instructors on a question by question basis.

  • Also, compare results for each term taught by each instructor.

  • Do FCI demos help?


Lecture demonstrations and the force concept inventory

Prof X

Prof Y

Prof Z


Lecture demonstrations and the force concept inventory

Prof X

Prof Y

Prof Z


Lecture demonstrations and the force concept inventory

Prof X

Prof Y

Prof Z


Lecture demonstrations and the force concept inventory

Prof X

Prof Y

Prof Z


Lecture demonstrations and the force concept inventory

Prof X

Prof Y

Prof Z


Lecture demonstrations and the force concept inventory

Prof X

Prof Y

Prof Z


Lecture demonstrations and the force concept inventory

Prof X

Prof Y

Prof Z


Lecture demonstrations and the force concept inventory

Prof X

Prof Y

Prof Z


Conclusions

Conclusions

  • Do we have enough data to conclude that demos have an effect (positive or negative) on the FCI?

  • The charts seem to say one of two things:

    • There is little, if any, correlation between demos and the FCI

    • Or, there is not enough data


Future work

Future Work

  • Look at data and modify FCI demos that may need improvement

  • Develop new demonstrations to match other questions on FCI

  • Expand analysis to 1101 and 1201 classes

  • Continue collecting data from 1301 classes

  • Analyze multiple choice and final test scores.


Aapt abstract

AAPT Abstract

Students often comment that they find lecture demonstrations interesting. But, do these “interesting” demonstrations help students understand physics, or are they just something cool to see? Using readily available data, can we determine any connection linking lecture demonstrations to student learning? In this talk, I will discuss my search for relationships between different measures of student understanding and the use of standard lecture demonstrations in large introductory physics classes.


  • Login