New Alternatives for Estimating Net Migration to the United States Using the American Community Surv...
Download
1 / 33

Alexa Kennedy-Puthoff David Dixon Sonya Rastogi Dean Judson - PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 172 Views
  • Uploaded on

New Alternatives for Estimating Net Migration to the United States Using the American Community Survey. Alexa Kennedy-Puthoff David Dixon Sonya Rastogi Dean Judson Population Division, U.S. Census Bureau. Presented at the United Nations Expert Group Meeting on

loader
I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
capcha
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about ' Alexa Kennedy-Puthoff David Dixon Sonya Rastogi Dean Judson' - agrata


An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript

New Alternatives for Estimating Net Migration to the United States Using the American Community Survey

Alexa Kennedy-Puthoff

David Dixon

Sonya Rastogi

Dean Judson

Population Division, U.S. Census Bureau

Presented at the United Nations Expert Group Meeting on

Measuring International Migration, December 2006.


Estimates of international migration to the united states

Estimates of International Migration to the United States States Using the American Community Survey


Population estimates
Population Estimates States Using the American Community Survey

  • The U.S. Census Bureau produces annual estimates of the population and demographic components of change (births, deaths, and migration). These estimates are published at the national, state, and county level.

  • Estimates are used in: federal funding allocations, as denominators for rates time series, and as survey controls.

  • One component of the population estimates is net international migration, defined as the net movement across U.S. (50 states and the District of Columbia) borders.*

    * The movement of U.S. military personnel across U.S. borders and the in-migration of native U.S. citizens who are not members of the military are included in the population estimates separately from the net international migration component.

    http://www.census.gov/popest/estimates.php


Estimates of net international migration 1990 2006
Estimates of Net International Migration, States Using the American Community Survey1990-2006

(in thousands)

*


Net international migration nim
Net International Migration (NIM) States Using the American Community Survey

  • The Net International Migration component of the population estimates consists of three parts:

    1. Net migration of the foreign-born population (NFB)

    2. Net movement between Puerto Rico and the U.S. (50 states and D.C.) (PR)

    3. (Net) emigration of native population (NEMIG)

    NIM = NFB + PR – NEMIG

  • NFB accounts for over 90 percent of the total NIM component. This research focuses on the construction of this component.


Using acs data to estimate net international migration

Using ACS Data to Estimate States Using the American Community SurveyNet International Migration


What is the american community survey acs
What is the American Community Survey (ACS)? States Using the American Community Survey

  • Replaces census sample data (long-form questionnaire)

  • Content similar to census long form

  • Samples every year and spreads sample over 12 months

    • Monthly data collection

    • Annual estimates

    • Low levels of geography


Acs questions
ACS Questions States Using the American Community Survey

Citizenship Status

Residence One Year Ago

Native

Foreign born

Year of Entry


Weighted estimates of the population
Weighted Estimates of the Population States Using the American Community Survey

(in thousands)

Citizenship Imputation Rates

universe: total population

Source: American Community Survey, 2000-2004


Single year change current method

Single Year Change States Using the American Community Survey(Current Method)


Single year change

- States Using the American Community Survey

Single Year Change

Change in FB population during interval.

SYC = FB t2 – FB t1

Deaths

Deaths to FB population during interval

PR

Net migration between the U.S. (50 states and D.C.) and Puerto Rico

NEMIG

Native emigration

NIM

Net International Migration

+

+

=

Single Year Change

  • The current method used to estimate net migration of the foreign born

  • Based on the change in the number of foreign born counted in ACS in time 1 compared with time 2, with an adjustment for deaths to the foreign born during the period


Single year change estimates and bounds
Single Year Change: States Using the American Community SurveyEstimates and Bounds

universe: total foreign-born population, t1 and t2

(in thousands)

* Data for 2000-2002 were re-weighted to a consistent series of population estimates.The bounds shown here represent a 90-percent confidence interval.

Source: American Community Survey, 2000-2004


Problems with nfb estimates based on single year change
Problems with NFB Estimates Based on Single Year Change States Using the American Community Survey

  • High standard errors

  • Sensitive to changes in survey population controls

  • Annual reweighting of ACS data required to provide consistent series of NFB estimates


Year of entry

Year of Entry States Using the American Community Survey


Year of entry was prior calendar year
Year of Entry Was Prior Calendar Year States Using the American Community Survey

  • Estimates utilize data on the year of U.S. entry of the foreign born

  • The “Year of Entry Was Prior Calendar Year” universe for NFB contains those who indicated they entered the U.S. in the year prior to the survey

-

-

Year of Entry Was Prior Calendar Year

Foreign born who have a year of entry that is the year prior to the survey.

FBEMIG

Emigration of the foreign-born population during interval

PR

Net migration between the U.S. (50 states and D.C.) and Puerto Rico

NEMIG

Native emigration

NIM

Net International Migration

+

=


Year of entry was prior calendar year estimates and bounds
Year of Entry Was Prior Calendar Year: States Using the American Community SurveyEstimates and Bounds

universe: foreign-born population, entered in year prior to the survey

(in thousands)

* Data for 2000-2002 were re-weighted to a consistent series of population estimates.The bounds shown here represent a 90-percent confidence interval.

Source: American Community Survey, 2000-2004


Year of Entry: States Using the American Community SurveyImputation Rates

universe: foreign-born population

(in percent)

universe: foreign-born population, entered in year prior to the survey

(in percent)

Source: American Community Survey, 2000-2004


Problems with nfb estimates based on year of entry
Problems with NFB Estimates Based on Year of Entry States Using the American Community Survey

  • High imputation rates for Year of Entry

  • Conceptual ambiguity / survey question interpretation difficulties

  • Method requires an estimate of foreign-born emigration


Residence one year ago

Residence One Year Ago States Using the American Community Survey


Residence one year ago was abroad
Residence One Year Ago Was Abroad States Using the American Community Survey

  • Estimates utilize data on the residence of the foreign born in the year prior to the survey

  • The “Residence One Year Ago Was Abroad” universe for NFB contains those who indicated they were abroad (outside the U.S. or U.S. outlying areas) one year ago

-

-

Residence One Year Ago Was Abroad

Foreign born, who were “abroad” one year ago.

FBEMIG

Emigration of the foreign-born population during interval

PR

Net migration betweenthe U.S. (50 states and D.C.) and Puerto Rico

NEMIG

Native emigration

NIM

Net International Migration

+

=


Residence one year ago was abroad estimates and bounds
Residence One Year Ago Was Abroad: Estimates and Bounds States Using the American Community Survey

universe: foreign-born population, residence one year ago was abroad

(in thousands)

* Data for 2000-2002 were re-weighted to a consistent series of population estimates.The bounds shown here represent a 90-percent confidence interval.

Source: American Community Survey, 2000-2004


Residence One Year Ago: States Using the American Community SurveyImputation Rates

universe: foreign-born population

(in percent)

universe: foreign-born population, residence one year ago was abroad

(in percent)

Source: American Community Survey, 2000-2004


Problems with nfb estimates based on residence one year ago
Problems with NFB Estimates Based on Residence One Year Ago States Using the American Community Survey

  • No residence rules for prior residence

  • Method requires an estimate of foreign-born emigration


Comparisons

Comparisons States Using the American Community Survey


Residence one year ago and year of entry based inflows and single year change net movement
Residence One Year Ago- and Year of Entry- Based Inflows, and Single Year Change (Net Movement)

(in thousands)


Differences in quality and robustness among estimates
Differences in Quality and Robustness Among Estimates and Single Year Change (Net Movement)

  • SEROYA<SEYOE<<SESYC

  • For the foreign born, imputation rates of place of residence one year ago are lower than those of year of entry


Next steps

Next Steps and Single Year Change (Net Movement)


Components of nim warranting further investigation
Components of NIM Warranting Further Investigation and Single Year Change (Net Movement)

  • Emigration

  • Coverage

  • Puerto Rico


Ideas for estimating emigration
Ideas for Estimating Emigration and Single Year Change (Net Movement)

  • Record Linking Methods

    • Current Population Survey (CPS) method

    • Administrative Records (ADREC) method

  • Multiplicity Survey Methods

  • Data Exchange Methods


Ideas for estimating emigration1
Ideas for Estimating Emigration and Single Year Change (Net Movement)

  • Residual Methods

    • 10-year

    • 1-year ACS using foreign-born population counts

    • 1-year ACS using internal migration information


Sources of undercoverage of the foreign born
Sources of Undercoverage of the Foreign Born and Single Year Change (Net Movement)

  • Complex Housing Arrangements

  • Irregular Housing Units

  • Language Barriers

  • Fear of Government and Immigration Authorities

  • High Degrees of Mobility

    • ACS Two-Month Residency Rule


Estimation of undercoverage of the foreign born
Estimation of Undercoverage of the Foreign Born and Single Year Change (Net Movement)

  • Various Methods and Assumptions

  • Wide Ranging Estimates for Segments of Foreign Born

    • Example - Range of 10 to 50 percent undercount for unauthorized


  • Immigration Statistics Staff and Single Year Change (Net Movement)

  • (301) 763-2411

  • Dean H. Judson, Chief

  • http://www.census.gov/population/www/socdemo/foreign.html


ad