E N D
1. Highway Construction Costs – The Potential Impact on SAFETEA-LU and MPOs William R. Buechner, Ph.D.
Vice President, Economics and Research, ARTBA
AMPO Spring Conference
March 14, 2006
2. How Does SAFETEA-LU Guaranteed Funding Compare to TEA-21?
3. What Will SAFETEA-LU Mean for MPOs? A solid foundation for growth of highway investment, but …
Highway construction costs are rising rapidly, which…
Will play havoc with the TIP unless you are very careful about estimating future project construction costs
4. Best Measure of Highway Construction Costs-- BLS PPI for Highways & Streets
Covers prices of materials and services used directly or indirectly in highway construction from more than 180 industries – weights based on input-output tables
Timely – one-month delay
Does not cover labor or overhead
National only – no state or regional data
5. Until 2004, Highway Material Costs Were Well-behaved, 12-Year Avg. Inc. of 1.8%
6. In 2004, Major Price Increases Involved Steel and ….
7. Diesel Fuel
8. Impact Major increase in cost of construction using steel
Affected bridge, guardrail fabricators
Could have led to defaults, delays on major bridge projects, inc. Woodrow Wilson Bridge
Some states aided fabricators
9. In 2005 --- Cost increases spread to core highway construction materials
Impact more wide-spread
Construction costs rose even more sharply than in 2004
10. PPI for Hot Rolled Steel Bars & Structures Level After 45% Rise in 2004
11. Diesel Fuel Up 47.5% in 2005 Following 27% Increase in 2004
12. PPI for Crushed Stone Increased 3.5% in 2004, Rose 6.8% in 2005
13. PPI for Ready-Mix Concrete Increased 5.2% in 2004, Up 12.1% in 2005
14. PPI for Asphalt Paving Mixtures Rose 1.6% in 2004, Rose 8.3% in 2005
15. Highway Material Costs Rose 12.5 Percent in 2005
16. Other Costs Rising Less than Materials –ARTBA Index up 5.4% in 2004, 7.7% in 2005
17. What Is Causing the Cost Increase? – Strength of Construction
18. Combined with Limited Supply Little if any new capacity in aggregates, cement, asphalt production
Some possible relief from Mexican cement imports – but cement mfgs. raised prices in January
Hurricanes disrupted petroleum supplies, rebuilding will add to demand
19. Outlook Continued upward pressure on material costs
Major risks –
Iran cuts off oil exports
China, India growth accelerates
Cost-push cycle where owners accelerate projects to beat cost increases
20. Impact of Rising Material Costs Bids higher than expected as contractors protect against unpredictable prices
Erosion of state and local highway construction & maintenance budgets
Some projects postponed or canceled
Deterioration of conditions
21. Possible Relief Housing market slows
Fed continues to raise rates to point where U.S. economy slows
Rest of world slows down
Long-term – new capacity and supplies
22. Highway Construction Costs in 2004 - 2005 Cut Real Growth to Under 1/2%
23. Largest Increases in Guaranteed Funding , FY 2009 vs. 2003
24. Smallest Increases in Guaranteed Funding , FY 2009 vs. 2003
25. Outlook for Federal Highway Funding in FY 2007 – FY 2009 President’s budget requests RABA bonus of $842 million FY 2007
Will Congress honor?
Will some be used for research? Katrina repairs?
Most for donor states
DOTs assuming future ob limits = 91% of CA, but overlooks earmarks in appropriations legislation
26. SAFETEA-LU Earmarks Meant Big Bonuses to Some States
27. …But Appropriators Also Add Earmarks
28. Impact of SAFETEA-LU on Highway Construction SAFETEA-LU provides 4-year predictability to federal highway & transit construction funding but less funding growth than under TEA-21
Will let state and local DOTs get “back-burner” projects underway – possible short-term boost to highway/bridge construction
Probably an uptick for design/study consultants
State and local funding will become more critical
29. Is There Any Good News? State and local highway construction budgets are improving after some tight years
Economy stronger
Tax revenues up
Value of construction work on highways and bridges rose to record levels in 2005
30. Value of Pavement Construction Has Been Flat Since 2001, Rose 14.2 Percent in 2005
31. Bridge Construction Resumed Strong Growth in 2005, Rose 9.6 Percent
32. Value of Airport Runway Construction Grew 18.4% in 2005, Topped $6 Billion
33. Awards for Pavement Construction Have Been Level, but Rose 5.9% This Year
34. Bridge Awards Were Down 13.1% in 2004, Rebound 11.3% in 2005
35. States Budgets Improving, Many Increased Spending for Highways and Bridges in FY 05
36. Conclusion Highway and bridge construction should remain a strong market in 2006
But if other construction markets also remain strong,
Will continue to put upward pressure on costs of construction materials