Terje aven university of stavanger
Download
1 / 42

Terje Aven University of Stavanger - PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 145 Views
  • Uploaded on

Black swans in a risk context. Terje Aven University of Stavanger. JRC, ISPRA 21 June 2013. Talking about black swans. Aven (2013) On the meaning of a black swan in a risk context. Safety Science. Creates a lot of enthusiasm Hard negative words from some researchers.

loader
I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
capcha
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about ' Terje Aven University of Stavanger ' - abraham-nichols


An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript
Terje aven university of stavanger

Black swans

in a risk context

Terje Aven

University of Stavanger

JRC, ISPRA

21 June 2013


Talking about black swans
Talking about black swans

Aven (2013) On the meaning of a black swan in a risk context. Safety Science

Creates a lot of enthusiasm

Hard negative words from some researchers


Professor dennis lindley
Professor Dennis Lindley

Taleb talks nonsense

He lampoons Taleb’s distinction between the lands of Mediocristan

and Extremistan, the former capturing the placid randomness

as in tosses of a coin, and the latter covering the dramatic randomness that provides the black swans

No need to see beyond probability


Nassim N. Taleb


Lindley example
Lindley example

A sequence of independent trials with a constant unknown chance p of success (white swan)

Lindley shows that a black swan is almost certain to arise if you are to see a lot of swans, although the probability that the next swan observed is white, is nearly one.



Prior density for p: the chance of a white swan

1

What is the probability that p=1?

1


Prior density for p: the chance of a white swan

1

What is the probability that p=1?

It is zero!

1


Prior density for p: the chance of a white swan

1

There is a positive fraction of black swans out there !

1


The probability-based approach to treating the risk and uncertainties is based on a background knowledge that could hide critical assumptions and therefore provide a misleading risk description


Prior density for p: the chance of a white swan uncertainties is based on a background knowledge that could hide critical assumptions and therefore provide a misleading risk description

0.8

x

x

0.2

0.99

1


Prior density for p: the chance of a white swan uncertainties is based on a background knowledge that could hide critical assumptions and therefore provide a misleading risk description

0.8

x

x

0.2

0.99

1

the probability of a

black swan occurring is

close to zero


Depending on the assumptions made, uncertainties is based on a background knowledge that could hide critical assumptions and therefore provide a misleading risk description

we get completely different conclusions about the probability of a

black swan occurring


Lindley’s example also fails to reflect the essence of the black

swan issue in another way

In real life the definition of a probability

model and chances cannot always be justified

P(attack)


Main problems with the probability based approach
Main problems with the probability based approach black

1

Assumptionscanconcealimportantaspectsof risk and uncertainties

2

Presumeexistenceofprobabilitymodels

3

The probabilitiescan be the same buttheknowledgetheyarebuiltonstrong or weak

4

Surprises occur


Risk perspective black

Probability-based

Historical data

Knowledge dimension

Surprises

+

+


P(head) = 0.5 black

P(attack) = 0.5

Strong

knowledge

Poor knowledge


John offers you a game throwing a die
John offers you a game: throwing a die black

What is your risk?

”1,2,3,4,5”: 6

”6”: -24


Risk black

(C,P):

  • 6 5/6

  • -24 1/6

    Is based on an important assumption – the die is fair


Background knowledge
“Background knowledge” black

Assumption 1: …

Assumption 2: …

Assumption 3: …

Assumption 4: …

Assumption 50: The platform jacket structure will withstand

a ship collision energy of 14 MJ

Assumption 51: There will be no hot work on the platform

Assumption 52: The work permit system is adhered to

Assumption 53: The reliability of the blowdown system is p

Assumption 54: There will be N crane lifts per year

Assumption 100: …

Model: A very crude gas dispersion model is applied


Risk perspective black

Probability-based

Historical data

Knowledge dimension

Surprises

+

+


Black swan taleb 2007
Black swan black(Taleb 2007)

Firstly, it is an outlier, as it lies outside the realm of regular expectations, because nothing in the past can convincingly point to its possibility.

Secondly, it carries an extreme impact.

Thirdly, in spite of its outlier status, human nature makes us concoct explanations for its occurrence after the fact, making it explainable and predictable.


Aven 2013 questions whether a black swan is
Aven (2013) questions whether a black swan is black

  • A surprising extreme event relative to the expected occurrence rate

  • An extreme event with a very low probability.

  • A surprising, extreme event in situations with large uncertainties.

  • An unknown unknown.


Black swan aven 2013
Black swan (Aven 2013) black

A surprising extreme event relative to the present knowledge/beliefs.

Hence the concept always has to be viewed in relation to whose knowledge/beliefs we are talking about, and at what time.


Unforeseen surprising events
Unforeseen/surprising events: black

  • Events that were completely unknown to the scientific environment (unknown unknowns)

  • Events that were not on the list of known events from the perspective of those who carried out a risk analysis (or another stakeholder)

  • Events on the list of known events in the risk analysis but found to represent a negligible risk



Threats
Threats black

Known unknowns

Unknown unknowns, black swans

(A’, C’, Q, K)


It is not about assigning correct probabilities
It is not about assigning correct probabilities black

  • But to provide

    • a proper understanding of the total system

    • means to identify many of these B and C events

    • measures to me meet them, in particular resilient measures

    • means to read signals and warnings to make adjustments


Statfjord A black

Do we have black swans here?


How to confront black swans
How to confront black swans black

Improved Risk Assessments

Robustness

Resilience

Antifragility


How to confront black swans1
How to confront black swans black

Taleb: propose to stand our current approaches to prediction, prognostication, and risk management

Improved Risk Assessments

Robustness

Resilience

Antifragility


Petromaks project improved risk assessments to better reflect the knowledge dimension and surprises
PETROMAKS project: blackImproved risk assessments- to better reflect the knowledge dimension and surprises


Unforeseen surprising events1
Unforeseen/surprising events: black

  • Events that were completely unknown to the scientific environment (unknown unknowns)

  • Events that were not on the list of known events from the perspective of those who carried out a risk analysis (or another stakeholder)

  • Events on the list of known events in the risk analysis but found to represent a negligible risk



2

Mindfulness

(Collective)

2

Quality management

New way of thinking about risk

1

Risk analysis and management

1

Concepts and principles

Aven and Krohn (2013) RESS.


Analysis black

Management

Risk analysis

Describing

uncertainties, …

Management

review and

judgment

Decision

Risk-informed decision making


Extra black


Risk black

(A,C,U)

(C,U)

A: Event, C: Consequences

U: Uncertainty


Risk description
Risk description black

(A,C,U)

(C,U)

Q

K

C’

Q: Measure of uncertainty (e.g. P)

K: Background knowledge

C’: Specific consequences


Subjective knowledge based probability
Subjective/knowledge-based probability black

K: background knowledge

  • P(A|K) =0.1

  • The assessor compares his/her uncertainty (degree og belief) about the occurrence of the event A with drawing a specific ball from an urn that contains 10 balls (Lindley, 2000. Kaplan and Garrick 1981).


Analysis black

Management

Risk analysis

Cost-benefit analysis,

Risk acceptance criteria

Management

review and

judgment

Decision

Risk-informed decision making


ad