Impact evaluation design for padyp benin jocelyne delarue afd
Download
1 / 23

Impact evaluation design for: - PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 380 Views
  • Updated On :

Impact evaluation design for: PADYP Benin Jocelyne Delarue - AFD. NONIE design clinic 1 Cairo April, 2009 1 Original format and presentation developed by the World Bank SIEF. Section A : Presentation of project. Project background & context.

loader
I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
capcha
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about 'Impact evaluation design for: ' - Sharon_Dale


An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript
Impact evaluation design for padyp benin jocelyne delarue afd l.jpg

Impact evaluation design for: PADYP BeninJocelyne Delarue - AFD

NONIE design clinic1

Cairo April, 2009

1Original format andpresentation developed by the World Bank SIEF

Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation


Section a presentation of project l.jpg

Section A: Presentation of project

Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation


Project background context l.jpg
Project background & context

  • Objective : Develop agricultural productivity through farming system management

  • Second phase of the project : scaling up

    • Expansion from 3 000 to 18 000 members

    • Expansion in new communes, new zones and new farming systems (12000 cotton farmers, 3000 non cotton farmers)

  • Activities (2009 – 2013) :

    • training of 75 new advisers and 525 key farmers (KF)

    • Every adviser supports 60 members and 140 more through KF (20 m/KF)

    • Prepare sustainability (participation of farmers to service payment)

  • Counterfactual situation : classical extension services recently extended by Benin government

  • The project is financed by AFD (10 M. €), cotton cooperatives (3.4 M.€) and Benin State (1.4 M.€)

Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation


Slide4 l.jpg

RESULTS CHAIN

Xxx Impact indicator

Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation


Key research questions l.jpg
Key research questions

  • Is the farming system management (FSM) service more efficient than top-down extension service to enhance agricultural productivity ? (cf. the causal chain)

  • Who are the members ?

  • Are there spill over effects on non members ? (networks effects)

  • What are the effects at a more aggregated level (village, value chain)?

  • Operational questions

    • How to succeed the scaling up

    • How to involve durably the farmers cooperatives in this service provision

Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation


Outcome indicators l.jpg
Outcome indicators

  • Number of farms which use farming system management tools/methods

    • Activity planning

    • Stock management

    • Cash management

    • Credit management

  • Number of farms who apply new cropping techniques

  • Number of farms who adopt new crops and activities

    Impact Indicators

  • Yields, Costs, Productivity for each crop

  • Prices obtained for crops sold

  • Food security in the family

  • Income

Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation


Identification strategy method l.jpg
Identification strategy/method

  • Use the expansion of the program (pipeline method ? Instrumental variable ?)

  • Comparison with a counterfactual situation : top-down extension services, currently extended also

  • Combination of qualitative and quantitative methods

Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation


Sample and data 1 l.jpg
Sample and data (1)

Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation


Sample and data 2 l.jpg
Sample and data (2)

Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation


Sample and data 3 l.jpg
Sample and data (3)

Monitoring system of the project (activities, number of advisers, key farmers, members, method use…)

Members’ farming systems caracteristics and economic results

Secondary data : census, market prices, …

Probably : Available data on crop productivity without farming system management

Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation


Time frame work plan l.jpg
Time frame/work plan

  • Impact evaluation : 2009 - 2012

Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation


Sources and finances l.jpg
Sources and finances

  • AFD

  • CIRAD

Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation


Section b impact evaluation of project l.jpg

Section B: Impact evaluation of project

Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation


Evaluation framework and context l.jpg
Evaluation framework and context

  • [Insert text on framework and context here]

Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation


Evaluation questions l.jpg
Evaluation questions

  • [Insert text on evaluation questions here]

Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation


Evaluation audience and policy it is trying to influence if appl l.jpg
Evaluation audience and policy it is trying to influence (if appl.)

  • [Insert text on audience and policy here]

Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation


Evaluation design l.jpg
Evaluation design appl.)

  • [Insert text on evaluation design here]

Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation


Challenges and risks l.jpg
Challenges and risks appl.)

  • [Insert text on evaluation challenges risks here]

Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation


Methodology l.jpg
Methodology appl.)

  • [Insert text on evaluation methodology here]

Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation


Evaluation implementation l.jpg
Evaluation implementation appl.)

  • [Insert text on evaluation implementation here]

Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation


Management l.jpg
Management appl.)

  • [Insert text on evaluation management here]

Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation


Expected results l.jpg
Expected results appl.)

  • [Insert text on expected evaluation results here]

Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation


Expected conclusions l.jpg
Expected conclusions appl.)

  • [Insert text on expected evaluation conclusions here]

Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation


ad