Higher education finance and access in comparative perspective
Download
1 / 12

Higher Education Finance and Access in Comparative Perspective - PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 342 Views
  • Uploaded on

Higher Education Finance and Access in Comparative Perspective. D. Bruce Johnstone, SUNY Buffalo Expanding Access: Lessons from Abroad ACE Annual Meeting February 2007. Financial Problems of Higher Education Worldwide.

loader
I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
capcha
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about 'Higher Education Finance and Access in Comparative Perspective' - Roberta


An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript
Higher education finance and access in comparative perspective l.jpg

Higher Education Finance and Access in Comparative Perspective

D. Bruce Johnstone, SUNY Buffalo

Expanding Access: Lessons from Abroad

ACE Annual Meeting February 2007


Financial problems of higher education worldwide l.jpg
Financial Problems of Higher Education Worldwide Perspective

  • Trajectory of costs (per-student and total) increasing faster than revenues (at least public)

  • Austerity: overcrowding, deterioration of quality, loss of faculty & morale

  • Tuition fees and other expenses rising (inflation+)

  • Diminishing relative priority of H. Ed.

  • Diminished confidence of governments in higher education –especially in faculty & management


Limitations on higher ed access participation worldwide l.jpg
Limitations on Higher Ed. Access & Participation Worldwide Perspective

  • Losses at middle and secondary levels

  • Limitations in higher educational capacity

  • Limited free or low fee places (dual tuition)

  • Persisting link between measured ability & aspiration and family class / privilege

  • Losses or freezing of grant aid

  • Limited student loans


The hazards of generalization countries vary greatly in l.jpg
The Hazards of Generalization: Countries vary greatly in: Perspective

  • Per-capita GDP

  • Rate of Growth of GDP

  • Capacity, cost-effectiveness, and progress-ivity of additional taxation

  • Population growth

  • % completing academic secondary school

  • Capacity and diversity of post-secondary options


Hazardous variations continued l.jpg
“hazardous variations” continued Perspective

  • Variations in the political and cultural acceptability of:

    • Tuition fees

    • Private higher education

    • Parental financial responsibility for post-secondary education of children


The perfect storm financial limitations on accessibility l.jpg
The Perfect Storm: Financial Limitations on Accessibility

  • Low GDP: per capita and low rate of growth

  • Very low tax capacity: Marginal taxation cost-ineffective, regressive, and detrimental to growth

  • Substantively & politically compelling queue of competing public needs ahead of higher education

  • Rapid increase in birth rate & h.s. participation rate  veryrapid growth of higher ed. aspirants

  • Political culture of entitlement and fear of student movements: great resistance to cost-sharing

  • Limited capacity for targeting or for lending


Things are easy l.jpg
Things are Easy…

  • Substantial additional progressive tax capacity

  • Substantial tuition-dependent private sector

  • Acceptance of appropriateness of tuition fees and philanthropy in public sector

  • Substantial and diversified H Ed. Capacity

  • Near saturation of participation [?]

  • low rate of growth of secondary school leavers

  • Well-developed systems for grants and loans


Us comparative advantages why we get the more higher education capacity for the tax l.jpg
US Comparative Advantages …(Why we get the more higher education capacity for the tax $)

  • Diversified system (multiple entry points & “horizontal” transfer possibilities)

  • Substantial private sector

  • Acceptance of parental financial responsibility for children’s higher ed.

  • Tradition (and partial subsidization) of philanthropy: public as well as private


Us comparative advantages why we get more higher educational access for the tax l.jpg
US Comparative Advantages …(Why we get more higher educational access for the tax $)

  • Financial Assistance [$134 Billion 2005-06]

    • Ability to target assistance (on decline)

    • Abundant loans, minimally subsidized

    • Ability to tap private capital markets for loans

  • Capacity & competition: “client seeking”

  • Recognition of link between privilege and measured academic readiness (GPA / SAT)

  • Recognition that “race & ethnicity matter” (although on decline)


But we can learn l.jpg
But We Can Learn …

  • Better relate repayments to level of income (Australia,UK, Canada, the Netherlands)

  • Better control of loan defaults through appropriate use of co-signatories

  • Institute bi-lateral & multi-lateral agreements on student loans

  • Assure greater transparency on institutional “quality”


Summary finance and access four worldwide trends l.jpg
Summary: Finance and Access …Four Worldwide Trends

  • Cost-sharing & other forms of revenue Diversification

  • Sector Diversification

  • Budget Reform / Autonomy

  • Privatization

    Others [modularizing curriculum, shortening time & conforming 1st degree, enhancing internationalization,]


For more information l.jpg
For More Information:

  • For additional information, country studies, and papers on international comparative tuition and financial assistance policies, visit the Website of the International Comparative Higher Education Finance and Accessibility Project:

  • http://www.gse.buffalo.edu/org/IntHigherEdFinance

  • Bruce Johnstone

  • University at Buffalo, [email protected]


ad