1 / 16

Use and value of technical reports

Use and value of technical reports. Katy Sidwell University of Leeds c.a.sidwell@leeds.ac.uk. Use and value of technical reports. Views from the literature use of reports factors determining use reason for use how reports are found value of reports MAGiC impact study

Philip
Download Presentation

Use and value of technical reports

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Use and value of technical reports Katy Sidwell University of Leeds c.a.sidwell@leeds.ac.uk

  2. Use and value of technical reports • Views from the literature • use of reports • factors determining use • reason for use • how reports are found • value of reports • MAGiC impact study • methodology and results MAGiC - use and value of technical reports

  3. Use of technical reports • Evidence from surveys • 81% of 3,106 engineers had used reports in the previous year • AAES, 1986 • 83% of 872 aerospace engineers used reports for a recent project • Anderson et al, 2001 MAGiC - use and value of technical reports

  4. Factors determining use • ‘Law of least effort’ • Accessibility • Ease of use • Chakrabarti (1983) • accessibility - 12th • utility of information - 5th • frequency of use - 8th MAGiC - use and value of technical reports

  5. Aspects of use • King and Griffiths (1991) • 90% of reports read for specific work activities • average age of reports read is 2 years • 50% are 6 months or younger • used over a longer period than journals • recommendations by colleagues • library staff report bulletins • citations online searches MAGiC - use and value of technical reports

  6. Value of technical reports • $709 savings per reading • stopping unproductive work • avoidance of primary research • confirmation of current research • modifying research/engineering design • 1-2% readings accounted for most savings • relevant reports are very valuable MAGiC - use and value of technical reports

  7. MAGiC impact study • Investigating • why engineers use technical reports • how reports are found and read • if reports are useful and relevant • comparison with other sources MAGiC - use and value of technical reports

  8. Methodology • Two locations • Cranfield University • dstl (defence science and technology laboratory) • Participants returning reports • 13 staff, 17 researchers, 11 masters (42%) • 29 engineers, 13 corporate, 3 government (95%) • Context of a particular report MAGiC - use and value of technical reports

  9. Results • How did you find out about the report? • 53% library catalogue • 17% recommendation • 16% citation • Recommendation • 86% dstl • Citation • 71% Cranfield MAGiC - use and value of technical reports

  10. Results • Why did you borrow the report? • 66% relevant to current work • 16% for the data • 94% subject matter was relevant to work • Which parts of the report did you read? • 40% fully read • 59% selectively read • abstract • results and conclusions MAGiC - use and value of technical reports

  11. Results • Did the contents of the report meet the need? • 51% fully • 41% partially • Was the report useful? • 85% to current work • 7% to future work MAGiC - use and value of technical reports

  12. Results • How did the report help you? • 48% gave new knowledge • 15% helped solve problem • 12% refreshed memory • 7% saved time • 6% substantiated hypothesis MAGiC - use and value of technical reports

  13. Results • Ranking the importance of sources MAGiC - use and value of technical reports

  14. Results - top sources graphically MAGiC - use and value of technical reports

  15. Results MAGiC - use and value of technical reports

  16. Conclusions • Reports are important to engineers’ work • Where reports are catalogued they will be found • The Internet is used and is popular • If only there were something combining all three... MAGiC - use and value of technical reports

More Related