A pbl project for sixth grade social studies
1 / 39

The Electoral College: Is it a Reflection of the Republic or - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

  • Uploaded on

The Electoral College: Is it a Reflection of the Republic or a Relic of the Revolution?. The Students Decide!. A PBL Project for Sixth Grade Social Studies. Begin With the End in Mind.

I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about 'The Electoral College: Is it a Reflection of the Republic or ' - Lucy

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript
A pbl project for sixth grade social studies l.jpg

The Electoral College:Is it a Reflection of the Republic or a Relic of the Revolution?

The Students Decide!

A PBL Project


Sixth Grade Social Studies

Begin with the end in mind l.jpg
Begin With the End in Mind

Social studies standards from the archdiocesan curriculum framework l.jpg
Social Studies Standardsfrom theArchdiocesan Curriculum Framework

The student will:

  • Summarize the main points in constitutional documents (6.14.09)

  • Explain the roles of citizens in choosing leaders in the United States (6.14.10)

  • Recognize the difference between fact and opinion and the importance of facts in the study of history (6.16.04)

Literacy outcomes based on the archdiocesan curriculum framework standards l.jpg
Literacy Outcomesbased onthe Archdiocesan Curriculum Framework Standards

The student will:

  • Compose a multi-paragraph piece which presents one position on an issue that offers sufficient support (6.03.17)

  • Arrange information in an orderly manner (e.g., outlining, sequencing, graphic organizers) (6.05.05)

Key skills l.jpg
Key Skills

  • Make data-based predictions

  • Categorize and analyze

  • Craft messages and use

    media effectively

Habits of mind l.jpg
Habits of Mind


School wide outcomes l.jpg
School-wide Outcomes

Use rubrics for evaluating writing

Craft the driving question l.jpg
Craftthe Driving Question

Should the constitution be amended to eliminate the electoral college l.jpg
Should the Constitution be amended to eliminate the Electoral College?

  • Has provoked debate

  • Is open-ended

  • Goes to the heart of the study of government

  • Is challenging – there is no simple answer

  • Is based on a real world dilemma

Unpacking the driving question l.jpg
Unpacking the Driving Question

  • How is the President elected according to the Constitution?

  • Why did the Constitutional Convention create the elector process rather than base the election on a direct vote?

  • How does the Electoral College function in practice?

  • How will/did it decide this year's election?

  • In what elections did the result of the electoral vote differ from the results of the popular vote? Did those election years have anything else in common?

  • Why is the Electoral College controversial?

  • Who are some of the "experts" who support changing the voting process? What are their reasons?

  • Who are some of the "experts" who support keeping the Electoral College? What are their reasons?

  • If the voting process is changed, what should replace the Electoral College? What would be the strengths of that system? What would be the weaknesses or potential problems?

Plan the assessment l.jpg
Planthe Assessment

Early in the project l.jpg
Early in the Project

  • Product (Individual)

    • Written summary of the Electoral College process

  • Artifact (Individual)

    • Note-taking from video on Electoral College

Criteria for summary l.jpg
Criteria for Summary

  • Correctly describes the function and process of the Electoral College

  • Is organized in paragraphs that contain one main idea and supporting details

  • Contains no spelling or grammar errors

During the project l.jpg
During the Project

  • Products (Small Group)

    • State by state predictions of the election outcome (map)

    • Overall prediction on the election winner based on map

    • Chart analyzing facts and opinions found in articles about the value of the Electoral College

    • Questions for an interview with a magazine editor on crafting letters to editors

During the project15 l.jpg
During the Project

  • Artifacts (Small Groups)

    • Record of discussion on overall election prediction

    • Guidelines for analyzing statements from articles into “for” or “against” the Electoral College and into “fact” or “opinion”

Criteria for predictions l.jpg
Criteria for Predictions

  • Every state on map is coded for McCain (red) or Obama (blue)

  • If all sources agree on how a state will vote, the map reflects that. If not, the group cites a source that they used to make their prediction for the state

  • The overall prediction follows from the elector totals for each candidate calculated from the state predictions on the map

Criteria for interview questions l.jpg
Criteria for Interview Questions

  • Each question helps bridge the gap between what the class knows about what the class thinks it needs to know to write a successful editorial letter to an appropriate media outlet

  • The question set includes a variety of types of questions: who, what, where, when, why, how

End of project l.jpg
End of Project

  • Product (Small Group)

    • Letter to Editor arguing for or against the Electoral College

  • Artifact (Small Group)

    • Graphic organizer for letter

Map the project l.jpg
Mapthe Project

Story board week 1 october 27 30 l.jpg
Story Board Week 1October 27- 30

Story board week 2 november 3 7 l.jpg
Story Board Week 2November 3 - 7

Story board week 3 november 10 14 l.jpg
Story Board Week 3November 10 - 14

Story board week 4 november 17 18 l.jpg
Story Board Week 4November 17 - 18

Manage the process l.jpg
Managethe Process

Differentiation l.jpg

  • Scaffolding material takes a variety of forms;

    • video

    • written

    • graphic

    • oral

  • Products require the use of a variety of learning styles:

    • verbal

    • spatial

    • logical

    • mathematical

    • interpersonal

Differentiation36 l.jpg

  • Initial grouping will be by readiness level so it is easier to scaffold, modify, or model as needed

  • Regrouping for letter writing product will be by interest

  • Project outcomes could be met by a student working individually, if necessary

Reflection and evaluation l.jpg
Reflection and Evaluation

  • Post six wall-pad sheets around the room

  • Title the sheets:

    • What we learned about the Electoral College

    • What we learned about making predictions

    • What we learned about analyzing info

    • What we learned about asking questions

    • What we learned about letters to the editor

    • What changes we would make to the project

  • Groups rotate among sheets adding their comments

  • When all groups have added to each sheet, student volunteers will report the responses.

What i expect to learn l.jpg
What I Expect to Learn

  • If the value added to the project by having an expert speaker exceeds the efforts of finding the expert and getting approvals for the visit.

  • If the students feel comfortable setting their work out for a wide public audience.

  • If the students have mastered previously taught research skills.

And finally we wait to see if we are published l.jpg
And finally...we wait to see if we are published!