1 / 28

Practicing Safe Rebanding

Practicing Safe Rebanding. Alan S. Tilles, Esquire Shulman, Rogers, Gandal, Pordy & Ecker, P.A. 11921 Rockville Pike, Third Floor Rockville, Maryland 20852 301-231-0930 www.shulmanrogers.com www.800mhzrebanding.com Incorporating Portions Of Glen Nash’s Presentation June 15, 2005.

Jims
Download Presentation

Practicing Safe Rebanding

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Practicing Safe Rebanding Alan S. Tilles, Esquire Shulman, Rogers, Gandal, Pordy & Ecker, P.A. 11921 Rockville Pike, Third Floor Rockville, Maryland 20852 301-231-0930 www.shulmanrogers.com www.800mhzrebanding.com Incorporating Portions Of Glen Nash’s Presentation June 15, 2005

  2. Who Are We? • Full Service Law Firm In Rockville, Maryland • FCC Representation • Counsel To Frequency Coordinators, Public Safety And Private Radio Licensees And SMR Operators Since 1984 • Also Counsel To The City Of Denver, PCIA, ARINC, Large & Small SMRs, Public Safety Agencies And Private Internal Users (Intel, Ford, United Airlines, Northwest Airlines) In The 800 MHz Proceeding • Negotiated The Document Which Became The “Consensus Plan” • Counsel To NENA • License Swap Negotiations • Negotiated Over 100 Re-Tune And Acquisition Agreements (Valued At Over $500 Million) With Nextel On Behalf Of Incumbent Licensees • Advanced Frequency Search Capability • Can We Find A Channel For You? • Experienced Licensing Preparation Personnel • Auction Assistance • Wi-Fi/WLAN And Tower Negotiations

  3. What Happens To Me? • ALL Non-Border Licensees At 851.0125 – 853.9875 MHz • Move To 854.0125 - 861.9875 MHz • NPSPAC Licensees (866-869 MHz) • Move To 851.0125 – 853.9875 MHz • Drop Current Frequency 15 MHz • All Non-Border Licensees At 854.0125 – 860.9875 MHz • You Stay Where You Are • Unless You Are A Public Safety Licensee At 860.0125 (857.5125 In SouthenLinc Markets) – 860.9875 MHz And You WANT To Move Lower

  4. The Process • TA Notifies A Licensee That Its System Needs To Be Relocated • TA Specifies A Replacement Channel For Each Non-NPSPAC Channel That Needs To Be Changed • All Incumbents Are Entitled To Comparable Facilities, But Are Not Entitled To Their Choice Of Channels • If Frequency Is Not Useable For Any Reason, Licensee Negotiates With Nextel For A Replacement, Which TA Must Then Approve • Nextel & Licensee Negotiate Reband Agreement Directly With Each Other, With TA Participating If Mediation Necessary • TA – "The Use Of The TA As A Conduit Should Not Be Considered A Substitute For Legal Or Other Expert Subject Matter Representation In Negotiations"

  5. The Process (Cont.) • FCC Applications Prepared By Whomever You Choose • No Frequency Coordination Required For Applications • FCC Will Not Require Approval Of, Or Consider Objections From, NPSPAC Regional Planning Committees With Regard To NPSPAC Relocations • FCC Grants Application(s) (Hopefully Expeditiously) • Re-Banding Work Performed • Whenever A Payment Event Is Reached (Beginning, Middle And/Or End), Licensee Requests Payment From TA, Who Certifies And Forwards To Nextel For Payment • When Work Completed, TA Audits Expenses • True-Up Of Expenditures, Only Actual Costs Are Paid

  6. Recoverable Costs From TA Handbook • Inventory • Evaluating Proposed Non-NPSPAC Frequencies • Defining Operating Environment (Interop. Agreements, etc.) • Equipment Costs • Retuning, Reprogramming And Replacement (Where Necessary) • Preparation And Filing Of FCC Applications • Installation, Testing And Engineering • Legal Fees • Preparing Cost Estimate And SOW (If Necessary) • Activities Of Licensee In-House Personnel Performing Reconfiguration Work • Licensee (And Vendor) Expenses Related To TA Mediation

  7. Recoverable Costs – Acceptance Testing • Scope, Level Of Effort And Cost Of Acceptance Testing Must Be Included In Cost Estimate • TA – Acceptance Testing "Should Be Performed Immediately Before Retuning And Again During Acceptance Testing In Order To Provide A Meaningful Comparison" • TA – Simple “Mic Test” May Not Provide Objective Basis For Comparing Before And After Coverage • TA - "A Formal Test Using A Well-Documented Route And An Automated Signal Measurement And Data Collection Procedure May Be The Only Objective Way To Compare Coverage“ • SRPGE Working With Industry Engineers To Develop Standardized Baseline Testing Methodology

  8. Non-Recoverable Costs From The TA Handbook • Inventorying Systems And Equipment That Are Not Directly Affected By 800 MHz Reconfiguration • Consulting Or Legal Fees Not Related To 800 MHz Reconfiguration • Vendor Charges Associated With Responding To Proposals Or Providing Bids And Quotes • Overtime Incurred By Licensee Personnel If The Licensee Does Not Pay Its Employees Overtime • Costs Which Were Not Incurred Or Are Not Sufficiently Supported By Required Documentation • TA – "Costs Incurred In Utilizing Non-Qualified Personnel, Or Costs Associated With Correcting Substandard Work Performed By Non-Qualified Personnel" • TA – "Licensee's Responsibility To Ascertain That The Personnel And Vendors They Utilize For Reconfiguration Are Qualified And Competent" • TA – "The TA Or Nextel Will Not Attempt To Qualify, Certify, Or Otherwise Determine What Qualifies A Qualified Resource"

  9. Documentation Of Costs • Internal Personnel • Hours And Costs Should Be Supported By Timesheets, Payroll Records Or Similar Documents • TA – "To Determine The Hourly Rate Of A Salaried Employee, Divide The Employee's Salary By 2,080 Hours” • Do The Math, This Is Not Your Cost To You Of Your Employee! • External Vendors • Only Reimbursed For Actual Costs Incurred • Support By Invoices And Licensee Acknowledgement Of Receipt Of Goods And Services • When Using Outside Vendors, Licensee Should Consider: • Obtaining Multiple Quotes • Validating That Proposed Prices Are Consistent With Prices That The Licensee Has Paid To The Vendor For Comparable Past Work

  10. Cost Overruns From TA Handbook • TA – "If, During Your Reconfiguration, You Determine That The Cost Estimate That You Submitted Is Inaccurate You Should Re-Estimate Your Costs And Submit A Revised Cost Estimate To Nextel" • TA – "Licensees Must Amend Their Contract With Nextel Before Incurring New Or Additional Expenses Beyond The Cost Estimate“ • What Happens If The TA Delays In Approving The Changes?

  11. Pre-Negotiation Period • Conduct A Complete Inventory • Evaluate Acceptable Outage Period • Evaluate Timing Issues • Evaluate Workload • Technical Staff • Administrative Personnel • Management

  12. Conducting Inventories • Inventory Repeater Make And Model, Combiners, Antennae, Duplexers, Consoles, Management Systems And Centralized Facilities That Are Frequency Specific • TA – "In General, The Inventory Should Be Accurate To Within 5% Of Units" • Don't Forget Mobile Data, Fixed Data, BDAs, SCADA, Traffic Light Control, Mobile Data Systems, Fire Alarm Enunciator Devices • TA – "Collecting Serial Number-Level Detail Will Not Be An Allowable Expense Unless A Valid Reason Exists To Collect This Information" • Example – "Additional Device Information Such As Serial Number Or Software Revision Level May Be Required To Determine The Appropriate Retuning Method“ • But, What About The Need To Track Which Units Have Been Retuned, And Which Ones Haven’t?

  13. The Inventory • Where Is It? • Building Locations • Vehicle Numbers And/Or License Numbers • Names Of People • Who Might Have Radios? • Operational Personnel • Allied Agencies • Elected And Appointed Officials • Media • Emergency Caches And Spares • Maintenance Equipment

  14. Upgrades During Reconfiguration • TA Discourages, But Plans Will Be Reviewed On An Individual Basis, Subject To The Following Considerations: • Upgrades Do Not Lengthen Schedule • Licensee Responsible For Additional Costs • Additional Costs Must Already Be Approved • Licensees Must Demonstrate That Vendors Have Committed To Schedule • TA – "Licensees That Upgrade Either Frequency-Dependent Infrastructure Or End-User Devices Must Certify That The Upgraded Facilities Will Be Comparable"

  15. Workload • Technical Staff • Do You Want “In-House” Staff To Do The Work Or Do You Want Outside Contractors To Do It? • If “In-House”, Then Need To Estimate How Much Effort Is Involved • If Contractors, Then Need To Estimate Your Own Support Of Them • Site Access • Quality Review

  16. Workload • Administrative Personnel • Property Managers • Clerical Staff To Maintain Re-Banding Records • Effort Required To Update Site Records • Effort Required To Update FCC Licenses • Legal Staff And Procurement Personnel To Conduct Negotiations And Review Contracts • Management

  17. Negotiating The Contract • Establish Cost For Doing All Of The Work • Include Your Agency Preparation Efforts • Include Your Agency Participation During Conversion • Include “Close-Out” • Establish Who Is Going To Do What • Establish When Work Is To Be Accomplished • Establish Where Work Is To Be Performed

  18. During the Conversion • Keep Records Of Work Completed • Compare What Was Converted Against Your “Inventory” • Ensure ALL Of The Radios Were Converted • Determine If More Radios Were Converted • Must Amend The Contract For Additional Reimbursement

  19. Expect • You Will Miss Radios During The Inventory • You Will Miss Radios During The Conversion • Those Radios WILL Appear—Perhaps Weeks Later • The Transition Administrator Will Want To Audit Your Expenses • If You Kept Records, This Should Be Easy

  20. Check Your Licenses! • Errors On Contact Information, Transmitter Site Coordinates, Etc. Are The Norm On Private Radio Licenses • Are Your Coordinates In The Ocean? • NOW Is The Time To Fix These Issues, NOT When You Begin Negotiations • You’re Only Entitled To Get What You’ve Got, Make Sure Your Licenses Reflect What You’ve Got • TA Says License Clean-Up Is Not A Recoverable Expense

  21. Don’t Believe Rumors! • At This Time, There Is No Definitive List Of Equipment, From ANY Vendor, That Nextel And The TA Agree Must Be Replaced • Other Rumors: • Educational Efforts Are Not Recoverable • Licensees MUST Accept Used Radios From Nextel As Permanent Replacements • These Are Items For Negotiation, And Every Deal Will Be Different

  22. Don’t Go It Alone • Keep Counsel Participating In Every Telephone Call And Meeting, And Have Them Pre-Review Every Document (Particularly SOWs), Even If You Think That’s It’s A Minor Issue • Prevents Information Being Transmitted That Is Wrong, Improperly Phrased, Etc. That Can Lead To Non-Complete Recovery Of Costs • Know Whom Represents Whom • Nextel Has Retained Outside People To Help Them Negotiate, But They Represent Nextel, NOT You! • Boiler Plate Contracts Rob You Of What Your Entitled To • Every Deal Is Different, Because Each System Is Unique, What One Licensee Is Entitled To Is Different Than What You’re Entitled To • Don’t Be Stuck With Someone Else’s Sloppy Negotiation

  23. Can You Avoid The RFP For Vendors • Strive For The Sole Source Contract • Extension Of Existing Contract With Radio Vendor? • Since There Are No Costs To You, Do You Need To Do An RFP? • Do You Have Time To Do An RFP? • How Do You Choose? • Best Price Or Best Value? • Fixing Shoddy Work By Non-Qualified Vendors Is Not A Recoverable Cost

  24. Joint Negotiations • Closely Tied Agencies May Wish To Consider Joint Negotiations • Joint Negotiations Minimize The Need For Multiple Layers Of Interagency Coordination • Eliminates “He Said, She Said” • Enables Smoothest Transition Possible

  25. Joint Negotiation Format • Agencies Need Not Give Up Their Autonomy • No Need For Formal Relationship Amongst Agencies • Allow The Professionals You Retain To Be The Conduit For Coordination • Retention Of The Same Negotiation Team By Each Agency Reduces Costs, Creates Format For Easier Negotiations • Where Multiple Vendor Formats Exist, There May Be A Need For More Than One Radio Consultant

  26. Timing • Nextel Is Aggressively Negotiating With GC Licensees And Wants NPSPAC Licensees To Be Ready To Negotiate Next • Does Your Agency Need To Go Through A Bid Process To Retain Outside Consultants? • Lack Of Payments By Agencies To Vendors May Negate The Need To Bid • Do You Have A Complicated Or Time Consuming Process To Retain Vendors? • YOU NEED TO ACT NOW!

  27. List Of Relevant URLs • FCC Web Site • http://wireless.fcc.gov/publicsafety/800MHz/bandreconfiguration/index2.html • Shulman Rogers 800 MHz Web Site • http://www.800mhzrebanding.com • We’ve Filled This Free Site With Every Document, Filing, Form, FAQ And Piece Of Information Possible • Transition Administration Web Site • http://www.800ta.org/index.htm • APCO Web Site • http://www.apcointl.org/frequency/800hp.htm

  28. THANK YOU! Alan S. Tilles, Esquire Shulman, Rogers, Gandal, Pordy & Ecker, P.A. 11921 Rockville Pike, Third Floor Rockville, Maryland 20852 atilles@srgpe.com www.shulmanrogers.com Much More Information Is Available At www.800MHzRebanding.com Please See Me For Thursday Individual Meetings

More Related