Octgt site visit september 29 2005
This presentation is the property of its rightful owner.
1 / 49

OCTGT Site visit, September 29, 2005 PowerPoint PPT Presentation

OCTGT Site visit, September 29, 2005. Research Management, Priorities, and Accomplishments. Suzanne Epstein, Ph.D. Associate Director for Research, OCTGT. The Challenge. OCTGT formed to regulate cell therapies, gene therapies, tissues, other novel products Key issues include:

Download Presentation

OCTGT Site visit, September 29, 2005

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript

Octgt site visit september 29 2005

OCTGT Site visit, September 29, 2005

Research Management, Priorities,

and Accomplishments

Suzanne Epstein, Ph.D.

Associate Director for Research, OCTGT

The challenge

The Challenge

  • OCTGT formed to regulate cell therapies, gene therapies, tissues, other novel products

    Key issues include:

    • Vector safety, efficacy

    • Survival and function of cellular products

    • Immune responses: efficacy of tumor vaccines, barrier to therapies

    • Characterization of complex products

Roadmap of this presentation

Roadmap of this presentation

  • Research management

    • Communication tools

    • Identifying research priorities

    • Assessment tools

    • Management of resources

  • Research, selected accomplishments related to:

    • Gene therapy

    • Cell therapy

    • Tissue engineering

    • Xenotransplantation

    • Tumor vaccines

    • New technologies

Communication within octgt

Communication within OCTGT

  • Purpose:

  • Keep all staff informed as to research expertise

    available in-house for consultation in relation to regulatory work

  • Encourage flow of Critical Path ideas among all review scientists

Tools for communication within octgt

Tools for Communication within OCTGT

  • Research work-in-progress seminars

  • Short research vignettes at staff meetings

  • Brief abstracts of research programs circulated to staff

  • Web-based, searchable research annual reports

  • Dialogue of research managers with leaders of all review divisions

  • Discussions initiated by review scientists

Communication beyond octgt

Communication Beyond OCTGT

  • Briefings of Center and Agency leadership, Grand Rounds

  • Information exchange with stakeholders:

    • Scientific conferences

    • Publications

    • Advisory Committee meetings

    • October 2004 Critical Path Workshop, FDA Science Forum, this site visit

How octgt identifies research priorities

How OCTGT Identifies Research Priorities

  • Receive input about new products on the horizon from pre-submission inquiries, conferences, literature

  • Identify anticipated areas of major product activity, and Critical Path issues

  • Monitor for gaps and weaknesses in expertise or redundancies, and address them

  • Example: A few years ago, we identified the need for adenovirus expertise and recruited an adenovirus research expert to fill the gap.

How we identify research priorities

How We Identify Research Priorities



Center Director/ADR

Office Director/ADR

Division Director/

Branch Chief


Project ideas

Octgt future research priorities identified

OCTGT Future Research Priorities Identified

Expertise identified as needed for future product review:

  • Tissue engineering: partnering/leveraging, adapting by existing staff

  • Cancer biology models for surrogate endpoints:

    Build on existing programs

  • Bioinformatics: enhance/leverage FDA capabilities, collaborate outside FDA

  • Proteomics: recruitment

Assessment tools for research productivity

Assessment Tools for Research Productivity

  • Quantitative metric for peer-reviewed publications,

    uses impact factors and authorship weighting (limitations of impact scores vs. quality, relevance).

  • Investigators describe the contributions of their research to Agency mission and other outputs (policy, guidance, advisory committee meetings).

Management of resources outside funding

Management of Resources: Outside Funding

  • Eligible for limited set of grant resources

  • Grant application prescreening: reviewed for conflicts of interest, alignment with OCTGT mission, possible recusals

  • Tracking of outside funds

  • Other leveraging (collaborations and partnering with other FDA centers, other government agencies, academic institutions)

Octgt research strategies

OCTGT Research Strategies

Anticipate needs, as well as addressing current problems:

  • Stay ahead of the curve as products and technologies change

  • Perform studies relevant to entire product classes,

    not only individual products

  • Make results public, and thus accessible to all

    sponsors, to advance the entire field

  • Some OCTGT research uses current product systems, some of it addresses underlying issues we must understand to move products forward.

Critical path challenges in gene therapy

Critical Path Challenges in Gene Therapy

  • Major issues: vector safety and characteristics,

  • patient immune responses.

  • Strategies to address them - Projects:

  • Adenoviral vector safety and biodistribution.

  • Retroviral vector safety and detection.

  • Herpesvirus vector safety and characterization.

  • Host immune responses induced by viral and

    plasmid vectors.

Adenovirus vector gene therapy

Adenovirus Vector Gene Therapy

Public Health Issues and Regulatory Challenges:

  • Adenovirus vectors being tested in many clinical trials

  • They efficiently deliver transgenes to the liver

  • Toxicity has been seen, leading to the death of one patient

  • Animal models are needed for predicting adverse events and understanding their mechanisms

What happens in animals with liver disease

Shift in vector biodistribution

Fatal pulmonary edema

Smith et al. (2004). Molecular Therapy 9:932

Smith et al. (2004). Gene Therapy 11:431

What happens in animals with liver disease?

Cirrhotic rats have a severe pulmonary reaction

after i.v. adenovirus vector

Adenovirus vector gene therapy1

Adenovirus Vector Gene Therapy


  • Insight into how adenovirus vectors cause toxicity

  • Animal model for gene therapy in the context of pre-existing liver disease – influence on clinical trial design

  • Model can be used for safety testing of new vectors

National toxicology program

National Toxicology Program

  • NTP is administered by NIEHS, federally funded.

  • Goal: Evaluate the safety of regulated products products nominated by FDA Centers

  • In 2004, CBER proposed studies of toxicity and pharmacokinetics of gene therapy vectors – the first NTP study of complex biologicals.

  • Collaborations of FDA, NIH and academic investigators to do large-scale, long term studies.

Octgt site visit

Goals of NTP Study: Retroviral Vectors

  • Establish a preclinical model for assessing risk of retroviral vector-mediated insertional tumorigenesis.

  • Assess the effect of vector dose, of deleting the viral enhancer, of using an insulator element

  • Compare risk of using enhancer-deleted lentivirus vectors

Octgt site visit

Goals of NTP Study: Plasmid Biodistribution

  • Establish a method for quantitative assessment of vector biodistribution.

  • Assess the effects of route of administration and of formulation on gene expression, DNA persistence.

  • Provide baseline information bridging to other vectors and formulations.

Cell therapy products living and changing

Cell Therapy Products: Living and Changing

Cell Product

Safe, effective

cell therapy



differentiation or


cell death

Critical path challenges in cell therapy

Critical Path Challenges in Cell Therapy

Major issues: controlling growth and differentiation of cells, product characterization, immune rejection

  • Strategies to address them - Projects:

  • Key signaling pathways determining cell fate, cell death, and development of anatomic structures

  • Cell-cell interactions controlling differentiation of cells derived from bone marrow precursors

  • Immune cell activation and immune responses to

    cellular therapy products

Cell therapy interacting signals that promote product efficacy

Cell Therapy: Interacting Signals That Promote Product Efficacy

  • Public Health Issue:

  • For many cell products, only a small fraction survive

    after administration to the patient. Thus, cell survival is

    a Critical Path efficacy question

  • Experimental approach: High throughput whole genome

    screening to evaluate interacting genes and identify

    new predictors of cell survival and product efficacy

  • Model: eye progenitor cells

Identify markers supporting bmp signaling and predicting cell product survival

Identify Markers Supporting BMP Signaling and Predicting Cell Product Survival

  • Markers predictive of

  • cell survival identified

  • in screen:

  • Signaling molecules

  • Transcription factors

  • Cell cycle regulators

  • Cell adhesion molecules

Normal BMPsignaling

Low BMP signaling

Apoptosis markers:

caspase 3, activated JNK pathway


Cell therapy interacting signals that promote product efficacy1

Cell Therapy: Interacting Signals That Promote Product Efficacy

  • Outcomes:

  • Identification of biomarkers that predict survival of cell therapy products, and can serve as manufacturing process controls

    • Functional biological interactions, providing link to clinical outcomes

  • Suggests approaches for improving survival of cellular products following administration to the patient

Cell therapy requirements for product efficacy

Cell Therapy: Requirements for Product Efficacy

  • Public Health Issues and Regulatory Challenges:

  • Cellular products being developed for treatment of myocardial infarction, neurodegenerative diseases other diseases.

  • Once potential biomarker identified, explore its role in vivo to permit characterization tests predictive of product efficacy and safety

  • A highly conserved signaling pathway which is crucial during development and reactivated during repair of injury requires Notch2

Inactivation of notch2 results in loss of notch2 myocardial cells and hypoplastic hearts






Inactivation of Notch2 Results in Loss of Notch2+ Myocardial Cells and Hypoplastic Hearts

Model: mice in which Notch2 can be turned on or off in specific tissue



Wild type


Wild type

Notch2+ cells are blue

vs = ventricular septation defect

Correct tissue formation requires Notch2 signaling


Cell therapy requirements for product efficacy1

Cell Therapy: Requirements for Product Efficacy

  • Outcomes:

  • Identification of markers on cellular products that predict their function and efficacy in vivo

  • Markers for process controls to characterize cellular products made from different precursors or under different culture conditions

Critical path challenges in tissue engineering

Critical Path Challenges in Tissue Engineering

Major issues: interactions yielding proper tissue structure and function.

Strategies to address them - Projects:

  • Tissue anatomy and factors controlling joint


  • Molecular signals determining liver development

Tissue engineering joint development repair

Tissue Engineering: Joint Development – Repair

  • Public Health Issues and Regulatory Challenges:

  • Joint damage is common, and inadequately treated

  • Products for repair of joint surfaces have given mixed results. Need to identify factors influencing successful joint formation.

Spatial patterns of gene expression

Spatial Patterns of Gene Expression


Key Finding:

Expression of growth factors and the enzymes that activate them overlaps only at anatomic boundaries


Tissue engineering joint development repair1

Tissue Engineering: Joint Development – Repair

  • Outcomes:

  • Identified novel molecular mechanisms contributing to development of the joints.

  • Micro-environment in vivo influences how cells differentiate and tissues develop.

    Related future work relevant also to cell therapies:

  • Phosphoproteomic profiling of chondrocytes to refine cell product characterization

  • Correlation of molecular markers with in vivo outcomes to identify sound potency assays

Critical path challenges in xenotransplantation

Critical Path Challenges in Xenotransplantation

Major issues: transmission of infectious agents between species, immune rejection.

  • Strategies to address them - Projects:

  • Porcine endogenous retrovirus (PERV) detection

    and species tropism

  • Transplantation immunology - approaches to

    avoiding rejection

Xenotransplantation porcine endogenous retrovirus perv

Xenotransplantation:Porcine Endogenous Retrovirus (PERV)

  • Public Health Issues and Regulatory Challenges:

  • Many more patients waiting for transplants than there are organs available

  • Risk of cross-species transmission of infectious

    agents, especially in immune-suppressed patients

  • Some PERV’s can infect human cells

Porcine pbmc release retrovirus that can infect human cells

Porcine PBMC Release Retrovirus that Can Infect Human Cells



Wilson, C., et al., J. Virol., 1998. 72(4):3082.

Infection of human cells determined by envelope




Infection of Human Cells Determined by Envelope

Portion of PERV-C envelope

differing from PERV-A by

9 amino acids greatly reduces

infection of human cells

Gemeniano, et al, Virology, In Press

Xenotransplantation porcine endogenous retrovirus

Xenotransplantation: Porcine Endogenous Retrovirus


  • Product Testing: Technical and scientific advice concerning assays for detection of PERV.

  • Product safety: Determinants of human tropism may reveal mechanisms to block infection and reduce risk of PERV transmission to recipients.

Critical path challenges in tumor vaccines

Critical Path Challenges in Tumor Vaccines

MAJOR ISSUES: Product characterization, including tests for identity, purity, potency; animal models, markers for monitoring and immunogenicity.

  • Strategies to address them - Projects:

  • Animal models of targeted intervention.

  • Markers of tumor growth for monitoring.

  • Immune response assays (used for potency tests)

Tumor vaccines

Tumor Vaccines

Public Health Impact and Regulatory Challenge:

  • More than 1.2 million Americans are diagnosed with cancer and half of them die each year

  • No tumor vaccine is currently available for general clinical use, but many are under development for cancer therapy

Identification of interleukin 13 receptor 2 as tumor associated biomarker

Identification of Interleukin-13 Receptor 2 as Tumor-Associated Biomarker

  • Overexpressed in variety of human tumors, compared to normal tissues

    Expression of receptor

    in astrocytoma

  • Overexpression sensitizes tumor cells to killing by receptor-targeted agents

  • Extracellular domain of receptor is cleaved and secreted into serum

Soluble il 13 receptor 2 as a serum biomarker

Soluble IL-13 Receptor 2 as a Serum Biomarker

Mouse model of metastatic ovarian cancer

  • Level of soluble receptor increased with tumor growth

  • Treatment with receptor targeted toxin decreases tumor burden as well as serum level of soluble receptor in mice

  • Survival improved


Tumor associated biomarkers

Tumor-Associated Biomarkers


  • Cell surface receptor expression as a marker of identity for tumor vaccines

  • Serum biomarker as a candidate for monitoring.

  • Animal models for study of interventions.

Critical path challenges new technologies

Critical Path Challenges: New Technologies

  • MAJOR ISSUES: Complex products require

  • state-of-the-art analytical methods.

  • Gene expression microarray

  • Quantitative flow cytometry

  • Transgenic animal production

  • Proteomics

New technologies

New Technologies

Uses of gene expression microarray

and flow cytometry

High throughput screening provides

detailed information. Can be used for

characterization of:

  • Cellular products

  • Cell substrates

  • Patient samples

Quality assessment of stem cells by gene expression profile microarray

Quality Assessment of Stem Cells by Gene Expression Profile Microarray

Identify markers of stem cell state



Outcome: CBER/NIH/Industry scientists identified and characterized common “stemness” genes in 6 stem cell lines. Bhattacharya, Blood: 103, 2956-2964, 2004

Quantitative flow cytometry fluorescence intensity standardization

Quantitative Flow Cytometry: Fluorescence Intensity Standardization

Calibration curve

Intensity, cell subsets

Microbead standards

  • Use fluorescence standardization to permit longitudinal clinical studies and comparison of data from different labs

Fluorescence technology for the 21st century

Fluorescence Technology for the 21st Century

  • Flow Cytometry and Microarrays Need Standards

  • Federal Standardization Initiative: NIST – FDA – CDC

  • Standard Fluorescein Solution Developed

  • Standard Microbeads Developed

NIST Microbead Standard

Reference materials needed to assure sensitivity and comparability of test methods

Reference Materials: Needed to Assure Sensitivity and Comparability of Test Methods

Retroviral reference material

Adenovirus reference material

LTR gag pol env LTR

  • Available from ATCC.

  • Used to show RCR assay sensitivity, reduce testing without compromising product safety.

    External RNA spike-in controls for microarray and RT-PCR


  • Available from ATCC.

  • Allows precise titers:

    • Viral particle

    • Infectious titer

Outcome: Sensitive, consistent testing facilitates progress, provides savings

Summary research prioritization as an ongoing process

Summary: Research Prioritizationas an Ongoing Process

  • New product classes present novel scientific and

    regulatory challenges and opportunities

  • We identify scientific questions of regulatory

    importance and address them.

  • Solutions to key problems facilitate product

    development, inform regulatory decisions and policy.

    We welcome questions and comments from the Committee.

Questions for the committee

Questions for the Committee

  • Please comment on the contributions OCTGT

  • research makes to the Critical Path development of biologics product and their availability.

  • 2. Please recommend opportunities for research expansion and redirection, and new collaborations or leveraging.

  • 3.Suggest research management strategies for anticipating future biological products and related scientific and product issues.

  • 4.Provide recommendations for attracting and retaining

  • high quality scientific staff.

  • Login