Public participation health gis an idea who s time has come
Download
1 / 41

Public Participation Health GIS: An Idea Who’s Time Has Come? - PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 296 Views
  • Uploaded on

Public Participation Health GIS: An Idea Who’s Time Has Come?. Russell S. Kirby, PhD, MS, FACE Dept of Maternal and Child Health School of Public Health University of Alabama at Birmingham. Objectives.

loader
I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
capcha
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about ' Public Participation Health GIS: An Idea Who’s Time Has Come?' - Gideon


An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript
Public participation health gis an idea who s time has come l.jpg

Public Participation Health GIS: An Idea Who’s Time Has Come?

Russell S. Kirby, PhD, MS, FACE

Dept of Maternal and Child Health

School of Public Health

University of Alabama at Birmingham


Objectives l.jpg
Objectives Come?

  • Consider strategies for taking web-based access to mappable health data to the next level: public participation health GIS

  • Describe typologies for serving maps and atlases on the Internet

  • Identify methodological, administrative and political issues that must be overcome

  • Have some fun – with humor and grace!




Slide7 l.jpg

Brief Summary for Those Who Are Knitting, Doing Crossword Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpeting

  • No vendor (hardware or software) or modeling approach has the hands-down best solution for serving public health maps on the Internet (and probably never will).

  • Must current applications fail to provide appropriate levels of end-user flexibility and functionality.

  • The technologies for true PPHGIS public health mapping applications exist – do we have the science and political will to make it happen?


The ten commandments of public health gis l.jpg
THE TEN COMMANDMENTS OF PUBLIC HEALTH GIS Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpeting

With apologies to Mel Brooks, and thanks for editorial assistance to

Elizabeth Kirby and for their insights to the following Internet contributors:

Dabo Brantley, DRH, CDC

Virginia Lee, ASTDR

Dona Schneider, Rutgers University

Russel Rickard, Colorado Department of Health and Environment

Dianne Enright, NC State Department of Health Statistics

Ravi Sharma, University of Pittsburgh

R.S. Kirby, December 2005


Slide9 l.jpg

The Ten Commandments of Public Health GIS Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpeting

Number 10

Thou shalt not expect thine health outcomes or disease states to respect administrative (block, census tract, ZIP Code, municipal) boundaries.

But without collecting geography in thine data, thou hast nothing that can be mapped.


Slide10 l.jpg

The Ten Commandments of Public Health GIS Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpeting

Number 9

Thou shalt not unknowingly commit spatial errors.


Slide11 l.jpg

The Ten Commandments of Public Health GIS Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpeting

Number 8

Know thy purpose (in creating and using your public health GIS).

Corollary: Thou shalt always be cognizant that the Scientific Method is not a built-in feature of any GIS software application.


Slide12 l.jpg

The Ten Commandments of Public Health GIS Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpeting

Number 7

Thou shalt know and understand thine data* prior to bringing it into a GIS.

*Editor’s note: this is a more specific example of the recently rediscovered 16th commandment, “Know thy data”


Slide13 l.jpg

The Ten Commandments of Public Health GIS Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpeting

Number 6

Thou shalt remember that while thine maps are abstractions, the maps reflect the physical environment and are based on data representing actual events that occurred to individual people.


Slide14 l.jpg

The Ten Commandments of Public Health GIS Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpeting

Number 5

Thou shalt protect individual records containing X,Y coordinates as thou wouldst protect records with individual identifiers, as both can reveal confidential information.


Slide15 l.jpg

The Ten Commandments of Public Health GIS Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpeting

Number 4

Thou shalt not clutter thine health data maps with unnecessary layers and map elements (i.e. chartjunk), nor shalt thou ignore information necessary to interpret the patterns on your map.


Slide16 l.jpg

The Ten Commandments of Public Health GIS Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpeting

Number 4 - addendum

“The real art of cartography is knowing more what to leave out, more than what to put in.”

- John Parsons


Slide17 l.jpg

The Ten Commandments of Public Health GIS Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpeting

Number 3

Know thine Metadata.


Slide18 l.jpg

The Ten Commandments of Public Health GIS Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpeting

Number 2

Thou shalt not assume that the default settings of your GIS software will generate useful and meaningful maps.


Slide19 l.jpg

The Ten Commandments of Public Health GIS Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpeting

Number 1

Thou shalt show humility to others, and be gracious even unto those who thought it would take weeks to accomplish what thou hast done in a few hours.


Are there other top ten lists l.jpg
Are there other Top Ten lists? Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpeting

  • Yes – just point your browser to http://www.soph.uab.edu/kirbytop10

  • Would you like to contribute to or suggest a topic for a future list?

    • Email me at [email protected]

  • Current lists under development include:

    • The Ten Best Ways to Use Email Badly

    • The Ten Best Ways to Misuse Hospital Discharge Data, Part 2

  • The long term plan?

    • Perhaps, a book with the working title:

      ‘The Practical Guide to Conducting Bad Health Research: A Book of Lists’


Topology of data atlas user interfaces l.jpg
Topology of Data-Atlas-User Interfaces Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpeting

  • Web interface as method of transmission only

  • Web interface for user to access pre-designed maps

  • Web interface for user to access database for generation of customized maps and tables

  • Web interface as point-of-service for integration of data from multiple geospatial data sources


Web interface for transmission only l.jpg
Web Interface for Transmission Only Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpeting

  • Utilize Web transactions to distribute static images and HTML files

  • User requests a map by submitting a request (clicking a button, entering a URL, etc)

  • GIS server prepares the images requested, sends to the Web server which then transmits to the user

  • User then accesses and manipulates the map with local GIS or mapping software

  • This method does not provide PPGIS, requires end-user to have knowledge of mapping software, and is limited in flexibility to customize the final map


Web interface for user to access pre designed maps l.jpg
Web Interface Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpetingfor User to Access Pre-Designed Maps

  • By far the most common current method for serving maps and atlases with health data currently

  • User connects to map or atlas website

  • User selects the desired map from a list, the map is then displayed

  • Some applications provide ‘customized’ variations, but in reality these are already prepared and stored for the user to access when selected

  • While this method provides end-user access to map content, the end-user has limited options and often cannot access or format the information as desired

  • Most of these applications are not PPGIS


Web interface for user to access pre designed maps continued l.jpg
Web Interface Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpetingfor User to Access Pre-Designed Maps (continued)

  • Many health examples:

    • http://www.cdc.gov/cvh/womensatlas/index.htm

    • http://www.cdc.gov/cvh/mensatlas/index.htm

    • http://www.cdc.gov/cvh/maps/strokeatlas/index.htm

    • http://www3.cancer.gov/atlas/

    • http://www.dartmouthatlas.org/default.php

  • This is a growing list!


Web interface for user to access database for generation of customized maps and tables l.jpg
Web Interface Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpetingfor User to Access Database for Generation of Customized Maps and Tables

  • The application webpage acts as a portal for the user to define a request for a map or table

  • The web server posts this request to the GIS or database server, which formats the request and generates the desired results

  • The results are then sent to the user’s screen

  • Applications using this methodology vary widely in their design and flexibility


Web interface for user to access database for generation of customized maps and tables continued l.jpg
Web Interface Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpetingfor User to Access Database for Generation of Customized Maps and Tables(continued)

  • Some early applications (e.g. HIT the SPOT) gave the user broad ability to define data ranges, map format, access to a wide array of statistical variables

    • http://hitspot.utk.edu/hit/main/SPOT/frames/SPOT/index.htm

  • Others incorporate various decision rules that limit access to results under specified conditions

  • Most of these applications generate univariate or bivariate maps, but typically from a single data source


Web interface for p oint of service for integration of data from multiple geospatial data sources l.jpg
Web Interface for P Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpetingoint-of-Service for Integration of Data from Multiple Geospatial Data Sources

  • This may be the future of serving health data maps on the web.

  • Multiple spatially enabled public health databases would be simultaneously queried from a single end-user request, with the results transmitted to the desktop for further use.

  • Most local and state public health agencies are far from able to contemplate this type of application, although there are numerous corporate examples.


Slide28 l.jpg
Web Interface for P Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpetingoint-of-Service for Integration of Data from Multiple Geospatial Data Sources (continued)

  • An early example is the Milwaukee COMPASS site:

    • http://www.milwaukee.gov/compass

  • Let me know if you have similar applications in your communities or states.


Public participation gis l.jpg
Public Participation GIS Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpeting

  • Not a new concept – in the literature and GIS community since mid-1990s! But not part of the lexicon of public health or community assessment.

  • Generally PPGIS focuses on “the use and value of GIS by marginalized peoples and communities engaged in social change” (Sieber 2003).

Sieber, R.E. (2003), Public participation geographic information systems across borders.The Canadian Geographer 47 (1), 50-61.


Applying ppgis to health issues l.jpg
Applying PPGIS to Health Issues Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpeting

  • The objectives of the community assessment initiative fit squarely within the framework of PPGIS.

  • However, to create truly PP-H-GIS will require transformational thinking beyond most current applications for serving maps and atlases on the web.

  • Some issues are the same:


Hardware software issues l.jpg
Hardware-Software Issues Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpeting

  • In developing map/atlas applications consideration must be given to:

    • Statistical server

    • GIS server

    • Web interface

    • GIS software

  • Decisions include:

    • Volume of traffic, number of users, level of interactive use


Hardware software models l.jpg
Hardware-Software Models Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpeting

  • There are many vendors for both hardware and software. None is sufficiently better than all others to warrant its mentioning specifically.

  • A well-designed application may separate the database and GIS functions, and utilize a web server as the front end. Software might include a statistical package, a high-end RDBMS, any of several GIS packages, and perhaps some specialized spatial statistical applications.

  • The most important issue in designing an application to serve public health maps on the Internet is the capacity to meet all functions in a time-efficient manner.


Transformational issues l.jpg
Transformational Issues Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpeting

  • Public participation implies freedom of choice as to what is important.

  • This means users need to have the capacity to initiate their own inquiries – and the PPHGIS must be designed to support this functionality.

  • End users shouldn’t feel constrained by the limitations of databases – the PPHGIS must be designed to handle obvious problems in background, things like:

    • Data elements of interest residing in two or more different databases

    • Aggregation of data into mappable units (by year, spatial unit, etc)

    • Records not linked at individual, household, ecological scales


Problems and pitfalls l.jpg
Problems and Pitfalls Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpeting

Provincialism of program managers

  • Fear of unfamiliar cartographic methods

  • Concerns with confidentiality

    • Leads to over-restrictive decision rules for data release

  • Under-powered applications, particularly for background processing of data on demand

  • Fear of what might happen when the ‘public’ can see ‘our’ data

  • Data quality issues – there are no warts until someone sees them. But . . . The warts don’t heal until they are treated! (Beware of antibiotic resistant strains . . .)

  • Will current data integration initiatives evolve to the point where they can support the high-end PPHGIS?


Problems and pitfalls36 l.jpg
Problems and Pitfalls Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpeting

  • Observation:

    • None of these issues are new or novel observations (Kirby RS, Stat Med 1996)

    • What remains lacking is the broad vision of key leaders in public health and health data organizations to find the ways to overcome these obstacle


And finally l.jpg
And finally, Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpeting

  • Will the thinking of public health professionals evolve to the point that health data is considered within the framework of broadly based determinants of population health?


Slide38 l.jpg

Health and Puzzles, or Discerning the Geometric Pattern in the Carpeting

Function

CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK FOR POPULATION HEALTH

Social

Environment

Physical

Environment

Genetic

Endowment

  • Individual

  • Response

  • Behavior

  • Biology

Health

Care

Disease

Well-Being

Prosperity

Traditional Medical Model of Health Care

Source: modified from Evans RG, Barer ML, Marmor TR, Eds, Why are some people healthy and others not?

New York: Aldine de Gruyter, 1994


Ten best ways to develop a bad public participation health gis l.jpg
Ten Best Ways to Develop a Bad Public Participation Health GIS

  • Now it’s your turn: what should be included on this list?


Questions thoughts or reflections after the conference l.jpg

Questions, thoughts or reflections after the conference? GIS

[email protected]

205-934-2985


ad